I decided to push through since everyone is talking about Season 2 now -- I was just busy with other stuff (I have a few other series to catch up on too, like ST-D).
I have mixed feelings about the show in general. I find it worth watching since the episodes are fairly short and they are fun. Each seems to be a mix of some decent things and some "eh, Buck Rogers, w/ Gil Gerard" style tone.
Episode 2 was probably the most frustrating; the ice spider sequences were cool, but the insinuation that all of the frog mom's eggs were actual babies coupled with The Child's view on them, was actually a little disturbing and threw off the tone for me. (Like, it wasn't actually funny, it was rather mortifying.)
Just finished episode 4 and again it is a mix of the silly SW stuff combined with some actual decent action sequences (the escape sequence in particular). Yet we have aliens with hands that are like giant paws and pretty much non-functional in terms of every-day use, or bases that can be blown up when certain controls are manipulated in 15 seconds even without any instructions and or a way to reset (positioned in an OSHA affront over a nasty drop for no reason, when any rational person would have put them on the accessible side), or convenient messages that cue to the exact spot desired despite the console being destroyed, or a Mandalorian with plate armor everywhere but his boots (because he makes no sound when running on metal surfaces -- which is a huge problem in D&D but the show just decides to ignore it), or stormtroopers who might as well not wear armor at all aside from identifying what side they are on because it's just PVC plastic anyway that never blocks a single laser blaster shot when hit, or a bunch of other cheesy stuff...
The acting ranges from decent to average (honestly, Gina Carano never learned how to really deliver a line yet, she's barely adequate.. but she can still throw people around without a problem, past her prime, so I guess that is good?). And the banter with Fish Guy Accountant should leave him shitting his pants, but he just manages witty banter without responding realistically from a dramatic POV...
All of which is just to say that you should not expect any true dramatic moments; so far this really is more of the surface level, casual, scifi western buddy show that doesn't try to be more than what it is. It does do that decently, which again is why I throw in the Buck Rogers reference.... get a likable hero with a few likable sidekicks who go on weekly adventures together, and keep the banter light and generally non-serious, like cosplay in space. It's fun casual watching but never really "touches" me in the heart or the soul.
But where I really noticed the improvements this season so far involve the action sequences. They've taken them more seriously as set pieces and they're fairly well-constructed and a bit more nerve-wracking. IOW, the action sequences are more dramatic than the dialogue/character moments so far.
I also like the occasion twist thrown into the script, even if not yet dealt with -- like, the thought that the Mandalorian is not actually part of the mainstream mando culture, he's considered to be part of a zealous cult. I hope they follow up on that thought later.
---
I guess my other thought is, what exactly is a Star Wars film? This really came to a head in the Sequel Trilogy, with Lucas off the projects; and I don't think it was ever resolved. There was a fairly decent first installment which unfortunately was very derivative of the Original Trilogy, then a second film that made a name for itself with a few large set-piece moments but otherwise seemed intent on breaking the SW formula completely and being kind of locked-in-a-box or tangential, and then a third film steeped in cliches of what boomer fans think a SW movie is, disconnected from the first two films in any substantial well, and just being a shit-show of a film in general, pretty much killing the viability of that story line, "let us never speak of this again" kind of thing.
is The Mandalorian back on the tracks of the general embrace of what a SW property is? At least it is more coherent, although still finding its way, tone-wise. I wish there was a more serious property in the pantheon (I liked the stakes better in Rogue One, that film actually makes me feel things every tie I watch it), but The Mandalorian is fun to watch the first time through even if I don't see myself rewatching the episodes any tie soon.