Rewatched Donnie Darko Sunday night, 4K, theatrical cut.
I prefer the theatrical version compared to the later director's cut. It's been one of those things where you wish the TC was a little more spelled out, but the DC goes way too far and breaks up the film, shows too much, and even embodies the director's opinion of what is happening. The beauty of the TC is that it is never really clear whether Donnie is having paranoid schizophrenic breaks with reality resulting in his visions of Frank or whether he is actually experiencing this in reality, whereas the DC ruins that. For me, the ambiguity is the draw and makes the film works on multiple levels at one, it leaves the film more edgy and intriguing.
I know Kelly also prefers the musical selections as arranged in the DC, but I like them better in the TC. I don't know why, I just prefer it. Maybe a case where lyrically he felt like something was a better match elsewhere, but musically I think tonally it works better as originally done. the beauty I guess is that both cuts exist.
this recent Arrow release actually seems to have tweaked the TC a bit near the end to add brief snippets I do not remember from my old DVD/blurays in order to make the film slightly more understandable.
I had not rewatched the film for awhile but this viewing evoked much of the same wonder I had in early viewings.
Patrick Swayzwe was pretty bold in undertaking such a distasteful role.
the Gyllenhaal siblings acting with each other is pretty remarkable. The early dinner room scene where Elizabeth announces she is going to vote for Dukakis sets the tone for the film and is utterly hilarious. I still laugh throughout any time I see it.
This might be the most "Beth Grant" role (as Kitty Farmer) that Beth Grant has ever done. She has been somewhat typecast after this film, I've seen her play permutations of the same character in later films.
There's an element here of sexualization of young women as well, which is never really the focus of the film. it's really fascinating how Middlesex as a school district is cheering on a bunch of prepubescent girls with adult makeup and glossy outfits (to Duran Duran's "Notorious") and marking them on a celebrity search show without even thinking twice about what that means, while at the same time calling Graham Greene's literature "pornographic" and supporting a guy who looks good on the surface while denying the clear evidence he had a kiddie porn dungeon in his home. I love that Kelly just slips this in and it's not even the main point. The whole pocket dimension seems rife with hypocrisy and danger as it proceeds forward, maybe making Donnie more heroic despite violating the law himself?
Mary McDowell is just so wonderful in this film. You can tell she's a flawed human being who still intensely loves her children. I always tear up when Donnie asks her how it feels having a whacko for a son. This is again one of those films that could have been a lot worse but one positive factor is a number of nuanced performances that elevate the story. Another is the score by Michael Andrews, concluding with maybe one of the best covers ever -- Mad World -- it all lends a dreamy, evocative feel to the film. Also, the editing is just superb.
Cap that with a bunch of casting choices of people who later became more well-known -- Jena Malone, Seth Rogan, hilariously Ashley Tisdale shows up in this film briefly, Jolene Purdy, Jerry Trainor (another Nickolodeon guy for iCarly), and of course all the regulars like Drew Barrymore, Noah Wyle, etc. Katherine Ross (the shrink) was a bit before my time.
there are hints in the film that this has happened before -- the pocket universe, needing to be closed off, to save the normal universe. There is discussion by the Darko parents about a kid in their class (Freddy Fiedler) with an alliterative name, who was "doomed to die" and did, but somehow Donnie seems to have survived, which relieves them. Also, there is an insinuation that Roberta Sparrow ("Grandma Death") was a prior past Receiver who survived her ordeal, resulting in a huge life change for her career-wise but also kind of left her mad over time.