I have very low standards and I enjoy most movies at the theatre with the exception of Superman IV: The Quest for Peace and Nothing in Common (early Tom Hanks film). The recent movies that have disappointed include:
1) Cloud Atlas - the previews looked great, but the movie was overly complex and not very engaging
2) Boyhood - so much time and effort put into this, but it's still terribly mundane
3) The Hobbit franchise - not enough Beorn, not enough Smaug, too much dwarf
4) Prometheus - I was looking forward to this because the preview looked great, but it didn't deliver. Not enough alien.
I also agree that American Beauty sucked. My advice: Stay away from Eric Rohmer films and French films in general.
Edit: to add Schindler's List, long and boring and depressing. This is the movie that ruined Spielberg. He hasn't made a decent film after this.
I personally love Boyhood. The commitment of the cast and crew was admirable. It was not mundane to me, compelling and moving in parts in fact, as I could relate to so many things that happened in it. Also, main character is INFP and I caught myself smiling at most of the things he said and the way he expressed himself.
French films are pretty bipolar. I really dislike the majority of French comedies, esp. romantic comedies. However, there are several French films I highly recommend, such as the crime thriller Tell No One (Ne le dis à personne), comedy The Intouchables (Intouchables), a handful of Michael Haneke's works such as the psychological thriller Caché, the erotic thriller The Piano Teacher (La Pianiste) and romantic drama Amour, and then of course we have the controversial Irréversible.
Other than that, I agree with you on the rest. Schindler's List was super boring, I was barely touched. Cloud Atlas looked special but not engaging. The Hobbit franchise should never have been made.
---------------------------------------------------
More to hate list:
I respect Lars von Trier's artistry, but I find it very hard to sit through his movies. The only one I liked was Dancer in the Dark. Everything else is extreme and too... unhealthy INFJ.
Frozen
Shrek franchise as well as most of Dreamworks' animations
Into the Woods
Everything made about Steve Jobs
Fast & Furious franchise
Most movies with the full names of the main guys in the titles: Jerry Maguire, Alex Cross, Nancy Drew, Jack Reacher, John Wick, John Carter, Max Payne, Forrest Gump (again), Happy Gilmore, Johnny English, Jonah Hex. You name it.
Movies with the word "versus" in the titles: AVP: Alien vs. Predator, Monsters vs. Aliens, Freddy vs. Jason.