• You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to additional post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), view blogs, respond to polls, upload content, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free, so please join our community today! Just click here to register. You should turn your Ad Blocker off for this site or certain features may not work properly. If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us by clicking here.

Confused? ISFP or ISFJ?

Generalist

New member
Joined
Nov 12, 2015
Messages
212
MBTI Type
ISFP
Enneagram
9
Instinctual Variant
sp
Hi, I would like to thank anyone who shows interest. I am not quite sure how to go about this in a helpful way to anyone that would be interested so I will try my best.

As far as type goes, I have mostly scored as an isfp, but I don't really fit the artisan description.

I am definitely introverted, I love my alone time, especially being outdoors alone hiking or going for a walk. I really don't know how those extroverted people find the energy to do what they do, social interaction except perhaps with a select few is draining.

I don't really see the deeper meaning of things as from the information that I take in. when it comes to things like discussing the human condition I either state the obvious, something that is common sense or a life lesson that I learned from experience or just regurgitating what someone who really is deep had said. I can recall things in detail, I often have trouble trimming down my messages because I will retell a story step by step almost feeling a need to add in every detail because they all could be important. I often don't view things as symbols or they may remind me of something but it is usually a memory or a prior situation. Like the scents from a barn reminding me of my father. When I am out, walking for example, I often become amazed and infatuated with the artistry of nature, how everything fits together, no deeper meaning, not even thinking of the basic biological processes being carried out that most of us know about, like photosynthesis, I just focus on the beauty of the flower and the aesthetics of everything around me.

I am definitely a feeler, being very sensitive and guilty of being way too nice. People usually describe me as a nice or good guy.

I am not organized. I have always been messy and when it comes to housework or getting organized I often do it. Part of the reason is I have much bigger things to worry about, like the direction of my life. to be honest I don't consider it important so I just put it on the back burner. before I started thinking about life direction I think I found it boring and to be honest I am a master procrastinator. I am one of those people who have the mentality of, why make my bed, I am just going to unmake it later. I procrastinate on everything and I have trouble resisting simple pleasures. I am very go with the flow partly because I am way to nice and have been more concerned with others then myself (of course if you are someone like me, then you probably have fallen in with people who are stronger willed). Also when it comes to small stuff like what or where should we eat, I don't really care, I will eat almost anything and I don't think it matters where we would go or what we would eat. Part of this laid back nature though could stem from extreme lack of self esteem and fear of conflict. A lot of the time I don't say anything because I don't want to stir up any trouble. I don't necessarily always feel laid back, I can be quick to anger I just don't express it. I am usually also late, it has actually gotten me into trouble at one of my jobs.

As far a comparison to me of the isfp descriptions I have read. I am friendly, enjoy moving at my own pace. I have been told I have good taste and a bit of talent for drawing and photography. I do pay attention to aesthetics and I have a part time farm job and I love being surrounded by the beauty of nature. I enjoy mostly quiet activities and I do have a weakness for giving in to temptation when it comes to food. I am not materialistic except for my previous mention of food but that is mainly in response to impulse purchases at the grocery store or going to a fast food place. I also have trouble resisting simple pleasures, like one in the past few years I have given into is watching stand up comedians on youtube. I am not a good planner and can be wrapped up in the moment. I have been in my head a lot more lately, but that is mainly due to obsessing over a career direction or because of mental health issues. I am not contemplating anything deep about the world. I really do enjoy learning by doing and working with my hands, but I don't think I am too mechanically inclined. I think would have much more success working artistically with my hands then as a skilled tradesman. I do love being outdoors. I am not the most athletic guy. I do love music, not necessarily the best musician and I did/do have a strong appetite for sex, but the sex has always been the same and routine even with women I have been with for years, even if the women is very open to trying things. I was once described as vanilla in regards to craziest type of porn I have watched.

As far as the differences go, I am not adventurous. I actually think of myself as a bit of a sissy. I am very boring. Most things that people find fun, I have no interest in doing at all. I am not a risk taker. I have a strong fear of heights and when I do see people engaging in thrill seeking in no way do I ever think, gee I would love to try that. No one I know or have known would ever describe me as a thrill seeker. Also I have never felt the urge to take sudden trips or just follow my impulses other then when it is typically for something simple. I have read descriptions of isfps feeling the need to run off and personally I think it sounds nuts. actually some of these general descriptions of artisans make them sound nuts. I also like the idea of being different, but I wonder how different I actually am. Other then my sense of humor which can be nutty and I do go to places that surprise people with my humor, upon review I don't think I am that different. I am/can be very socially awkward and at times I do have perspectives that people find unusual. But I don't feel a need to have a personal style that stands out. I dress very blandly. my favorite colors are brown, grey, dark blue, black (brown is probably my favorite) and barely any of my shirts, except maybe like two or three t shirts have any design or writing on them. I actually avoid shirts with any writing or anything that may draw attention to me. I suppose I have mixed feelings when it comes to compliments and I don't really like attention, I prefer to work behind the scenes. A former manager described me as looking like an ordinary guy. I have no tattoos and have zero interest in getting any. essentially I have no personal style. I can also be very routine. for example when going to restaurants I will order the same thing or one of the same three menu items again. to be honest I don't want to be disappointed when I order food because my dining experiences are important to me and I don't want to be disappointed. I actually at times can worry a bit if I order something new because I don't want it to suck in my opinion. But if someone offers me something new, I will try it. I also fall into other routines, not necessarily of getting things done, like a cleaning routine, but in my free time I will usually indulge in the same activity again and again, unproductive routines that change organically over time. I have an interest in different topics, but once I take an interest I can become obsessive about it, consuming lots of information, but not necessarily doing everything I can to master it. I have gone from playing bass for a few years,(eventually I just lost interest), to martials arts which I paid more attention to then the community college classes I was taking. I had to stop early for financial reasons, I probably would have kept doing that longer. Even though I enjoyed it, I didn't really take martial art classes for excitement, I wanted to be able to defend myself and be less afraid of confrontation and to get into shape. I was very interested in house plants, I volunteered as a dog walker which I loved. I didn't have the money to go to school at the time so I felt I should volunteer somewhere in my free time, make good use of it and I chose that. I would probably still be doing that, but I couldn't afford the gas any longer to get there. I also love making people laugh and I will do an improvised stand up routine at times with mixed results. I developed an interest in animal husbandry and consumed a lot of information on that. It seems that I do become interested in different things, but when I do I can become very focused. obsessive to the point that I kind of ruin it for myself, I take the fun out of it by becoming a task master to myself and instead of working harder, the task master in my head just causes everything to fizzle out.


I have never thought of myself as a very responsible person. I slacked in school for years and procrastinated, frequently being yelled at by my mom about my poor performance. In high my grades were mixed, one semester being good and the next bad, I actually got really sick of high school and came close to not graduating. to be honest I was really sick of school and I did not take my school duties responsibly, although I have done very well years later at one of the local technical colleges. Despite my poor performance through school, I usually followed the rules, I have never really been a rule violator, just a bad student. I was actually called a brownie (fun kid slang for goody two shoes). Even today I respect most rules and policies seeing a need for them and try to be as honest as possible. I was a facer at a grocery store, a boring manual task. I was very very slow and it was a mind numbing job. I was a dishwasher at my next job, but once again, very slow. when I worked these mindless manual labor jobs I just checked out. The next job was loading trucks was a bit better, again moving very slow due to the mind numbing work. I did do better once getting a gas station gig, but almost got fired because I was getting frisky with a female employee there. The next job was a call center, which went much better when I applied myself, but I had a bad attitude, plus I saw how some of the employees were treated and some of the selling tactics that were employed, like lying to customers to get a sale and I became disenchanted and let my work performance slip. I also got into trouble usually for being late. I did not like being micromanaged and it became more and more of a sales environment which I feel I did not do well in. I was bad about doing paper work, but very consistent on the phone. I was actually told once that I need to be baby sat.

I quit that job because I felt I had a need to get a job that helped people. It was an internal push. I actually could feel a sense of guilt about picking a job, that wasn't a helping profession. I struggled with it for a while during the time I spent trying to choose a career and I finally went in for human services. after some experiences with that, I decided it wasn't for me and I am now in a marketing program because I do find that and the business world quite interesting. it led me to getting a job as a caregiver for developmentally disabled adults. The pay is pretty poor so I got a second job with an alpaca farm. Both of these jobs you are not micromanaged at all and ironically once I got away from such a structured environment, I have done well. I still show up late, but neither job seems to care.

Like the isfp I do want to help people, sometimes too much. In around the last nine years, I had two long term relationships with troubled women. I put their needs before mine and they both bled me dry. Now I am 33 and I live with my mother because I was not focused on what I needed to do for myself. My therapist has told me I have codependency (a need to be needed) and it has really fucked things up for me. like taking a low paying caregiver job. I am too nice and too concerned about others.

In these romantic relationships and platonic relationships I think people have liked me, not necessarily for me, but for the emotional stability I offered them. I would listen to them all the time, offer support etc... I was always there for them. One girl, before even talking to her, left me a message saying, you look like someone I could talk too another girl referred to me as her rock or center. she actually called me dad a few times. creepy and gross. So what the hell am I, an extremely boring isfp or a half assed isfj? Thanks for anyone who actually read all of this and I am sorry.
 

Smilephantomhive

Active member
Joined
Aug 11, 2015
Messages
3,352
MBTI Type
ISTJ
Enneagram
6w5
Instinctual Variant
sp/so
I don't really see the deeper meaning of things as from the information that I take in. when it comes to things like discussing the human condition I either state the obvious, something that is common sense or a life lesson that I learned from experience or just regurgitating what someone who really is deep had said. I can recall things in detail, I often have trouble trimming down my messages because I will retell a story step by step almost feeling a need to add in every detail because they all could be important. I often don't view things as symbols or they may remind me of something but it is usually a memory or a prior situation. Like the scents from a barn reminding me of my father. When I am out, walking for example, I often become amazed and infatuated with the artistry of nature, how everything fits together, no deeper meaning, not even thinking of the basic biological processes being carried out that most of us know about, like photosynthesis, I just focus on the beauty of the flower and the aesthetics of everything around me.


This part seems really ISFJ to me.
 

Kullervo

Permabanned
Joined
May 15, 2014
Messages
3,298
MBTI Type
N/A
Whoa. You expect a group of affluent, committed yuppies to read of all that? I nearly had an aneurysm after paragraph two.

I am going to play devil's advocate and go with ISFP, as I sense a lot of Fi. Explanation if I'm pushed for it.
 

cascadeco

New member
Joined
Oct 7, 2007
Messages
9,083
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
9w1
Instinctual Variant
sp/sx
You sound very isfj to me. :)
 

highlander

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 23, 2009
Messages
26,585
MBTI Type
INTJ
Enneagram
6w5
Instinctual Variant
sx/sp
Can you answer these questions?


*What characteristic best describes you?
a. I am adaptable
b. I am consistent
c. I am humane
d. I am analytical

*Which statement best describes you?
a. I’m tolerant and on the lookout for useful compromises
b. I am hard working and dependable
c. I am enthusiastic and creative
d. I am competent and inventive

*It is most important for me to be:
a. Adaptable
b. Respectable
c. Authentic
d. Resolute

*It is most important for me to
a. Be lively and unrestrained
b. Do things that will produce good
c. Help others and be charitable
d. Be autonomous

*I yearn for
a. Impact
b. Belonging
c. Romance
d. Achievement

*I most value being
a. Excited
b. Concerned
c. Enthusiastic
d. Calm

The best word to describe me would be that I am:
a. Practical
b. Dutiful
c. Altruistic
d. Pragmatic
 

Hawthorne

corona
Joined
Jan 8, 2015
Messages
1,946
MBTI Type
INTP
Enneagram
5w4
Instinctual Variant
so/sp
Sounds very SEI which loosely translates to ISFJ.
 

Generalist

New member
Joined
Nov 12, 2015
Messages
212
MBTI Type
ISFP
Enneagram
9
Instinctual Variant
sp
Alright [MENTION=21639]Kullervo[/MENTION], I wish push for an explanation, thanks again!
 
Last edited:

Forever

Permabanned
Joined
Aug 30, 2013
Messages
8,551
MBTI Type
NiFi
Enneagram
3w4
Instinctual Variant
sx/so
ISFJ seems very suitable for you.
 

SearchingforPeace

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 9, 2015
Messages
5,714
MBTI Type
ENFJ
Enneagram
9w8
Instinctual Variant
sx/so
Care to examine functions?

Do you believe you use Si or Se?

Fe or Fi? Where do your values come from? Can you sense the vibe in a room? Do you accommodate others to ensure your actions don't cause hurt feelings?

How are you when really stressed out? Do you aggressively criticize others and micromanage or get wrapped in crazy possibilities and worrying?
 

Generalist

New member
Joined
Nov 12, 2015
Messages
212
MBTI Type
ISFP
Enneagram
9
Instinctual Variant
sp
Thank you for the help. Alright, lets examine functions. Do I use extraverted sensing or introverted sensing? I do have a talent for collecting facts and remembering them. I have always thought I have an excellent memory and during conversations, some things in the discussion will suddenly trigger an emergence of this random fact and I will share it, just because I think it is interesting. I do use my experience to guide me at least at times. For example, I have been repeating certain experiences. I mentioned volunteering as a dog walker, well as a child I absolutely loved dogs and at that time also had a dog of my own. As a child I briefly took karate classes, then as a way to learn to defend myself, get into shape and become more confident about conflict I started taking martial arts classes again. My job on the farm is a connection to my childhood and lifelong interest in animals and the fact that I grew up in the country and my dad grew up on a farm as well as my fairly new interest in birding. Looking back I am just having variations on the same themes. Also when assessing my strengths I tend to look to past experiences for evidence of where things went well. For example, teachers telling me I am good at something. Also sensory information does bring up past memories. Like tonight, I smelled the brandy my brother had bought for me for xmas. As I took in the scent, I just didn't absorb myself in the scent, memories of me from a few years earlier emerged, of me drinking brandy in my apartment at my computer desk and mixed feelings of regret and a feeling of freedom, when I only had one child. Images do bring up memories for me and I would not at all call myself a thrill seeker. I don't always feel a need to engage in my direct environment and seek out physical stimulation. I do give into temptation when it comes to food, sex or a walk with pleasant aesthetics, but I am not a thrill seeker. I am a pretty routine, boring person. Routines do change over time and they usually aren't productive, but I am definitely a creature of habit. Also when it comes to art, like music, things need to grow on me for me to like them at least part of the time. I know in certain cases that when I first hear music or see a piece of art, my initial reaction would be negative. Like when I started listening to the Who, I did not like it, but I kept listening and I came to absolutely love them or art that lacks a certain aesthetic quality. I know that there is more to it, then just looking nice and if I give myself time, I will come to enjoy the visual more. I am also not very materialistic. I don't feel a need to collect stuff or consume. There isn't a need to act on my environment. I do love physical beauty, I notice trends but I do not engage in them myself. I dress in a very casual, boring way with boring colors and I really don't care how I look. I would never really do anything that would draw attention to me. For example, I would feel uncomfortable wearing the color red because it is so bright.

Extraverted feeling or introverted? I read a description from a site that I found through a link on this site. It described introverted feeling as something that is challenging to describe using words. they are best described as images, gut feelings or feeling tones. I have no idea what they are talking about. I have never thought that the only way to describe what I am feeling by using an image. What the hell are feeling tones? Anger with a dash of sadness? If I felt something I have always felt I could describe it, anger, happiness, regret and so on. It also talks about know the essence of a person. again, I have no idea what they are talking about it. when I meet someone or am getting to know someone, I take in what they say and how they look and automatically put them in a category, comparing them to other people I have met and drawing general conclusions about them. I know this way isn't perfect, but I never felt I had the essence of someone. As far as having a filter or personalized values, I don't know how personalized my values are. Also something about reading fine distinctions among feeling tones. again, I don't even know what they are talking about. As far as extraverted feeling goes, I am very aware of other people's feelings. I notice changes in facial expressions, tones of voice, if they are happy or upset or seem sad. If there is conflict between two people and the conflict has nothing to do with me, I still can sense it and I feel very uncomfortable. I don't try to mediate it or anything like that, I do sympathize, but I don't try to fix it. I do feel a need to help people and I have put other people's needs ahead of my own even to the point of hurting myself. In the last, around nine years, I have had two relationships with two troubled women, who by helping them, I royally screwed myself. there were other women who had their shit more together, but they needed help and I think that is what drew me to them. my therapist has told me, she thinks I have codependency. A need to be needed. after breaking up the last one, I was having some negative feelings and I realized it wasn't because I missed her, it was because I wasn't as needed as I was before. I feel a sense of duty when it comes to helping people, like it is something I have to do. I have thought, it is the only thing I have felt a sense of duty about. I don't know if I necessarily take on the feelings of others, but I have very strong feelings about the way people are supposed to act towards each other and when people veer off that path and that path ranges from, just being a dick to someone for no reason or a major crime, it makes me very angry. I also am too concerned for others for my own good. here is an example. I had to take my ex's dog to the vet. I used the bathroom to pee. I noticed the toilet paper roll on the holder was almost out. I instantly thought of another person, sitting down to take a dump, not realizing it was almost out, then having to stand up, with a poopy asshole and get a new roll. So I took a fresh roll and put it on the back of the toilet so that person, who ever the hell they are, wouldn't have to stand up after shitting. Also I am more motivated to get work done when working on a group project in classes because I am concerned about the other students and I don't want something bad to happen to them and I don't want them to get screwed over. I am way to accommodating and even try or desire to help people who have screwed me over or are just dicks. When it comes to career choices, everything has to be turned to the perspective of, how does this help someone. it is nuts. I don't know how traditional I am in some ways. I would only care about certain things, if my kids did, like putting up an xmas tree. I have never decorated for the holidays and I could care less about that. But in some ways I am very traditional. I was born in the early 80s, I would never even consider growing my hair long, having anything pierced or tattoed. I am a white, heterosexual male, I listen to rock and roll, I would feel silly listening to hip hop, the word cool has become a permanent part of my vocabulary. I have a habit of trying to persuade my coworkers in their twenties to invest for retirement and I get excited about it. It is really weird. I would never engage in any of the styles that are popular with the men my age. I would not want one of those crazy relationships with multiple people. One woman is good.

Yes I am very accommodating. I would feel bad if I hurt someone's feelings and I have had to work on not being too concerned about others.

When stressed out, I don't try to micromanage, I worry and my mind can start concocting a variety of scenarios of how things could go south.

In some ways the isfj description describes me, but like I said, I am not as responsible as I feel I should be. I procrastinate, I forget about things like registering my plates, I show up late a lot, I am messy and when it comes to things like cleaning, it is not high on my priority list, at times I think I have bigger fish to fry or I am just fucking lazy. I have not necessarily taken my duties at my jobs seriously, having a bad attitude about things.

Again, I am sorry for writing so much. thanks again.
 

Generalist

New member
Joined
Nov 12, 2015
Messages
212
MBTI Type
ISFP
Enneagram
9
Instinctual Variant
sp
as far as extraverted feeling, I have a very strong talent for remembering details about people and their lives. even someone who I met once and then I see them again months later or longer I can remember details about their lives. I just remember things about people, I have always had this talent. I also think I have a bit of talent when it comes to gift giving.
 

fetus

New member
Joined
Mar 22, 2015
Messages
2,575
Enneagram
6w7
[MENTION=26575]Generalist[/MENTION] Your first paragraph is basically Si with no real Se. Second paragraph seems very Fe. You have strong feelings about how people are supposed to act toward each other - that sounds like a Fe thing, with social norms and whatnot. Taking care of others to the point of hurting yourself is much more Fe than Fi. Strong sense of obligation to help others, etc. Your example with the toilet paper also sounds pretty Fe. Personally, I would either not care or feel pissed off for my own sake (though that might not be type related at all).

The whole tradition SJ thing should be scrapped. It makes SJs seem closed-minded, like they're trapped in the 50s. I would disregard anything that labels them as "traditional."

Clear ISFJ to me.
 

SearchingforPeace

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 9, 2015
Messages
5,714
MBTI Type
ENFJ
Enneagram
9w8
Instinctual Variant
sx/so
Yep, clear as day, ISFJ.

As to co-dependency, Fe doms and auxs are especially in danger of becoming codependent. I struggle with this myself, greatly. And only realized it this year.

The best solution I know is develop better self love and boundaries. Even though you feel the need of others, your need is just as important. None Fe users often struggle to feel your need. So, include yourself in those in need and prioritize your need, as no one else will.

A good loving relationship to built on mutual respect and love, not on need. Build up your own love for yourself to prepare yourself to be with a healthy person. You don't need to save or rescue anyone. You just need to care more about yourself.
 

AphroditeGoneAwry

failure to thrive
Joined
Feb 20, 2009
Messages
5,585
MBTI Type
INfj
Enneagram
451
Instinctual Variant
sx/so
I think codependency gets a bad rap.

I think being codependent can be a good thing, and very appropriate in many situations. :)
 
Top