Yeah, I have. I think it makes a lot of sense, and I'll probably read more about it. INXP/INTX. So I'm wondering what makes you think INFP? And also since I know I'm not, do you have any thoughts on why I'm atypical (if you were to assume I am correct)?
I base it simply on analyzing the answers you gave in the OP. For example: "I would instantaneously evaluate what I agreed and disagreed with and why, and formulate my response. I would assess what his/her attitude was in saying it and what my attitude was and whether emotion or other personal factors were making either of us biased. Then I would respond with an emphasis on looking at the big picture."
When I search statements like this for clues, I don't look at functions much. So if I say that your response shows introversion in the first sentence, and intuition in the last, I'm not calling it Ni. (But a certain J-ness is present in the orderly way in which you mentally process the situation.)
"This has happened many times, and I have to modify my internal framework (both objective and subjective). I notice how I feel about this clash, and how much my ego might be attached to my beliefs and and whether I need to detach more to know the big picture." Here is feeling, intuition, and introversion.
"I value things both objectively and subjectively. Externally I value freedom, harmony, truth, responsibility, happiness, independence, collective empowerment, thinking outside the box, being openminded, seeing interconnectedness, having a balanced ego, compassion within reason, and honesty (both with others and yourself), among other things. I value practicality and applicability, as well as imagination and idealism and pointless mental activity. For me personally I value health and fitness, competence, being extraordinary, beauty, pleasure, logic, humor, being stable and sane, knowing myself, independence, maturity, and constant commitment to being my best. The most important thing to me is to know and understand reality and the ultimate truth of the universe (both objective and subjective). My ethics have evolved over the years and now consist of ‘be responsible for the consequences of your actions.’ (I don’t like making moral judgments anymore because they seem too Christian/religious. I’m pagan/Taoist/Hindu/atheist. The truth is never black and white or dualistic.) That said, I will protect and defend people and things I feel connected to. I feel one with the Earth and the life on it. (I also believe it is objectively true that we need to protect the earth no matter how people feel about it because it makes sense.) I feel connected to the goddess and god energy and am a feminist. Being pagan I believe in looking at things from the perspective of all human history and not being biased in favor of “civilization†and technology. I value both science and mysticism. Everything is balance. My values have never really changed, just had different emphases."
I'm not looking for functions here, but introverted feeling certainly pops out strongly in those statements. It's not because you talk about values (that's what was asked anyway), it has to do with a quest for meaning (" to know and understand reality and the ultimate truth of the universe"). You say it is both objective and subjective meaning. But the things you discuss clearly aren't objective ("I feel one with the Earth and the life on it" and "I feel connected to the goddess and god energy").
"Intuition is a very important tool, especially for a witch. I always trust my intuition, and it is very reliable and accurate. I always balance my subjective feelings with objective reality though, because they can be biased or clouded by emotion."
This comes across as more INFJ. My intuition keeps telling me to change the call to INFJ, so maybe I'll just do that.