Dr Horribles Sing Along Blog
Dr. Horrible
C'mon it's a 3 Act musical and each act is about 10 minutes long. Absolutely amazing.
I don't know, I think Crystal Skull was a lot better than Temple of Doom. It still had the Indiana Jones spirit that Temple of Doom lacked.
I actually thought A.I. was one of Spielberg's best movies. War of the Worlds wasn't that bad, either. Not his best, but certainly not his worst. Although I never understood why everyone thought Dakota Fanning was such a great actress in that movie, considering all she ever did was scream -- she reminded me of the little girl in Aliens.
The Lost World was probably one of Spielberg's worst movies. I thought it was awful and hardly Spielberg quality.
Saving Private Ryan was just relentlessly boring, and it was nowhere near as gory as I had imagined, so I was sort of let down. Munich was also boring, overall.
I think the motorcycle chase in Crystal Skull is the equal of pretty much any action sequence in any of the first three films. The difference is, again, that the first three have had time to become iconic in people's minds, and so the contest is rigged. It's just like how people reminisce about the "good old days", even if they're better off now.
I never cared much for Lucas, I always thought he was a hack that got lucky once with the first Star Wars film. But Spielberg (and by extension, Kahn) has made some exceptional films in recent years and I see no reason to put him out to pasture because there have been a few clunkers. It's only because he's trying to live up to "70s and 80s Spielberg" that the current Spielberg suffers by comparison. Anyone else who had Spielberg's 90s and 00s filmography would be roundly praised.
Just as an experient, let's look at his recent work. I'm going to arbitrarily pick the last 15 years of his career, since I think Jurassic Park is what a lot of people see as his last great action movie.
Schindler's List
The Lost World
Amistad
Saving Private Ryan
AI: Artificial Intelligence
Minority Report
Catch Me If You Can
The Terminal
War Of The Worlds
Munich
Indiana Jones And The Crystal Skull
In that list are a Best Picture winner (Schindler's List) and two other Best Picture nominees (Saving Private Ryan and Munich). Note that the nomination of Munich was as recent as 2005. I'd say that all on the list are at the least above average, and all but three (Lost World, AI, The Terminal) were widely praised upon their release.
Again, any other director with this filmography would be considered among the best. A director that might be past his peak can still make some amazing films, and Spielberg has. Just cause he's not batting a thousand anymore doesn't mean he's done.
Edited to expand my film nerd rant![]()
I also find Saving Private Ryan to be horrendously overrated. The Thin Red Line was the superior WWII film of 1998. It was much better-looking than SPR, too, and that is usually a latter-day Spielberg strong point.
It's so interesting that you say this. I thought Saving Private Ryan was by far the best film of 1998, and I always use The Thin Red Line or Mulholland Drive as my examples when I want to make the point that respected directors can get rave reviews for dreck based on reputation and the positivity effect.
It just goes to show that taste is a very personal thing with a lot of variance, even among experts in a particular discipline.
I can think of a decent number of good 1998 movies: Pi, Dark City, American History X, The Big Lebowski, As Good as it Gets, The Last Days of Disco, Rushmore, Jackie Brown
Maybe I'm the only one who likes those, and they may not be favorites, but it seems about average for a given year.
It's so interesting that you say this. I thought Saving Private Ryan was by far the best film of 1998, and I always use The Thin Red Line or Mulholland Drive as my examples when I want to make the point that respected directors can get rave reviews for dreck based on reputation and the positivity effect.
It just goes to show that taste is a very personal thing with a lot of variance, even among experts in a particular discipline.