Swivelinglight
Permabanned
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2010
- Messages
- 1,070
There is an idea
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ego_depletion
Ego depletion. The idea is you run out of energy, or willpower, by completing draining tasks. Eventually if you do too many of them you will run out of energy, or willpower, and you would be unable to complete any further tasks. The most famous study is in which a control tried to complete a impossible task. They were timed for how long they made the attempt. The average was about 18 minutes. The independent group was given a will power draining task before attempting the impossible task. The will power draining task was such that participants were shown cookies that were baked in the lab. The cookies were then presented to the participants, however they were not allowed to eat the cookies. Instead they were given a bowl of radishes to eat. This situation was made to drain the participants willpower. Afterward they were given the impossible task. They were timed at an average of about 8 minutes. So the control group was 16 and the independent was 8. Therefore a positive effect was shown. There were about 200 studies that supported this study and a meta analysis done of the studies that supported the first study, as well. This study became common knowledge. You'd hear things like you only have a limited supply of will power! It's shown in articles like this:
You've Got a Limited Supply of Willpower, so Use It Wisely
One of the researchers in the original study even made a best selling book about it:
Willpower: Rediscovering the Greatest Human Strength: Roy F. Baumeister, John Tierney: 9780143122234: Amazon.com: Books
Well guess what. That book is as useless as a paper weight. There was a study done in 2010 that refuted the findings. There was a meta analysis done in 2014 that also refuted the findings. Finally the Association of Psychological Science decided to do a huge study on whether the original findings were true. They employed 24 labs with over 2142 participants all around the globe:
http://www.psychologicalscience.org...RR_Hagger_FINAL_MANUSCRIPT_Mar19_2016-002.pdf
And guess what they found. They found no evidence of will power being a finite resource. This pillar of psychology ,as true as true can be, backed by over 200 studies and a meta analysis is incorrect. People are saying that science is crumbling. "At some point we have to start over and say, This is Year One†- Inzlicht
To be sure there's a lot of doubt right now about what is true and isn't true in psychology.
In depth look at ego depletion's fall: Ego depletion, an influential theory in psychology, may have just been debunked.
recommended reading: http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/failure-is-moving-science-forward/?ex_cid=538fb
A video giving a brief overview of what's going on:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ego_depletion
Ego depletion. The idea is you run out of energy, or willpower, by completing draining tasks. Eventually if you do too many of them you will run out of energy, or willpower, and you would be unable to complete any further tasks. The most famous study is in which a control tried to complete a impossible task. They were timed for how long they made the attempt. The average was about 18 minutes. The independent group was given a will power draining task before attempting the impossible task. The will power draining task was such that participants were shown cookies that were baked in the lab. The cookies were then presented to the participants, however they were not allowed to eat the cookies. Instead they were given a bowl of radishes to eat. This situation was made to drain the participants willpower. Afterward they were given the impossible task. They were timed at an average of about 8 minutes. So the control group was 16 and the independent was 8. Therefore a positive effect was shown. There were about 200 studies that supported this study and a meta analysis done of the studies that supported the first study, as well. This study became common knowledge. You'd hear things like you only have a limited supply of will power! It's shown in articles like this:
You've Got a Limited Supply of Willpower, so Use It Wisely
One of the researchers in the original study even made a best selling book about it:
Willpower: Rediscovering the Greatest Human Strength: Roy F. Baumeister, John Tierney: 9780143122234: Amazon.com: Books
Well guess what. That book is as useless as a paper weight. There was a study done in 2010 that refuted the findings. There was a meta analysis done in 2014 that also refuted the findings. Finally the Association of Psychological Science decided to do a huge study on whether the original findings were true. They employed 24 labs with over 2142 participants all around the globe:
http://www.psychologicalscience.org...RR_Hagger_FINAL_MANUSCRIPT_Mar19_2016-002.pdf
And guess what they found. They found no evidence of will power being a finite resource. This pillar of psychology ,as true as true can be, backed by over 200 studies and a meta analysis is incorrect. People are saying that science is crumbling. "At some point we have to start over and say, This is Year One†- Inzlicht
To be sure there's a lot of doubt right now about what is true and isn't true in psychology.
In depth look at ego depletion's fall: Ego depletion, an influential theory in psychology, may have just been debunked.
recommended reading: http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/failure-is-moving-science-forward/?ex_cid=538fb
A video giving a brief overview of what's going on:
Last edited: