Ridley Scott says the new Alien series he happens to be a producer on will never live up to the original Alien. He's probably right, but not exactly the kind of praise I'd be happy about if I were a fellow producer on that show.
Although I bet it will be superior to Prometheus and Alien Covenant
Yeah, as he's been overediting his films recently to shit so they become incomprehensible...
I saw this comment by him as well and was kind of shocked he said that publicly.
I have never really understood his sense of ownership over the Alien franchise, when he didn't even write the first film.... I wouldn't probably mind his dictatorial control over the franchise if not for his vocal disregard for anything not made with the Ridley Scott stamp of mediocrity. Probably the only reason he hasn't trashed Aliens and James Cameron is he's aware many consider it superior to his own film and he'd burn up any remaining goodwill toward him from Alien fans. He has acted like a jealous, petty child with other filmmakers who have expressed interest at taking a shot with an Alien film (see how he effectively lobbied to have Neil Blomkamp's proposed film killed). Time to move aside and allow other people a chance.
Yeah, it was never his baby.
I have a hate/love relationship with Scott's work. Some of his earlier stuff is really great, and I appreciate how he works cross-genre rather than doing just one kind of film. He has directed some memorable films.
OTOH, the longer he's been in the business, he's also released a growing list of shit so that I no longer think, "Oh cool, a Scott film is coming out, I just have to see it sight unseen!"
I've been really put off by his last two Aliens film. The trailers were great. I've seen what hit the cutting room floor, though, and it's made the movies both far worse. About the best parts of either film are simply the look and feel of them -- they have a lot of dark beauty and ambiance. But he seems to have lost a sense of the power of character and story.
We loved Alien, but that doesn't mean we need a convoluted origins story to destroy any sense of mystery around the first film. I sincerely hope the new show isn't going to do more of that, although I would like to see a resolution to David's arc done properly. That said, rumored conclusions to said arc I have seen are just silly. I do not need or want a story featuring David becoming Ash, and I really hope that one is just a baseless rumor and not something Scott actually has in mind. The guy is a terrible writer and should leave the ideas to other writers.
I haven't had a reaction either way to the Alien series that was announced. I've been too jaded over the years to care until something releases and I hear it is worth viewing. I typically just block stuff out too as "failed canon" rather than official storyline, at least in my own head.
I have not heard the "David becoming Ash" thing... but damn, what a shitty idea. Let's just ruin even the good stuff because we keep pumping out drivel.