Rewatched the last three Hunger Games films over the last two days. Michael Arndt actually polished the Catching Fire script and it shows. Francis Lawrence also adds to the action directing, something the first film was lacking.
Film Katniss is really a different iteration from the book Katniss, in that the latter is stoic and internalized, but in film you need to emote to convey information since you don't have a direct window into character heads. This is why Jennifer Lawrence was cast, she's great at this -- but it's just kind of odd sometimes to step back and see how externalized film Katniss is with her emotions whereas she's very difficult for other characters to read in the books. The character I keep thinking about is the girl from the True Grit remake (Hailee Steinfeld, her breakout role at age 13 and Oscar nominee) as more like the book Katniss, and how it worked in the film; but I think Mattie Ross was still very vocal, just not emotional, whereas book Katniss is very stoic and withdrawn.
But mostly I wanted to just comment that these films seem to really grapple with trauma and PTSD responses. It was really notable to me because I've been rewatching the RWBY american anime series and it also spends a lot of time on the impact of trauma -- mostly through Yang and Crow, although there's trauma being grappled with by Blake who is being stalked and both RWBY and Jaune from the loss/absence of people they loved and lost in terrible ways. Yang has actual physical responses to threats that remind her of a terrible incident she experienced, and it carries on for some reasons, whereas Crow essentially drinks himself to a stupor all the time to self-medicate (kind of like Haymitch from HG) although both are challenged to rise to the occasion by the younger generations and start recovery because they feel they both have a purpose beyond themselves. A whole season is spent on RWBY trying to figure out who she is in light of the loss of her mother, and Jaune's journey seems to linger just as long in terms of his feelings of unworth -- a few steps forward, a few steps back -- in being the one who's still around.
Especially the last Hunger Games film, we're left with the thought that Katniss and Peeta need a lot of space and time to dig their way out of the horrors they had to live through, and they are both able to support each other as survivors and find some solace in that. It's definitely a survivor's tale, but there's a lot of horrors along the way. the trauma plays out in how they interact with others and even what they perceive as reality. The last film (reflecting the book) digs into Peeta need external input to help him determine which things are real (aka what he needs to react to in order to survive and thrive) and what things are just his broken mind lying to him. There are still some things I wish they would have done differently, but I'm kind of impressed they managed to do these films fairly decently considering their blockbuster status -- considering all the YA films that tanked and/or were just convoluted messes with little emotional center.
This is probably my favorite Elizabeth Banks character. She tends to be solid but not exemplary in her performances and sometimes easily overlooked; but this was a case where the film character (Effie Trinket) was better than the book, and even endearing.