MBTI, Enneagram, and Zodiac correlations (my revision of PTypes correlations)...

[Shimpei]

BS

BS

This theorizing is so silly, guys. Actually the exceptions are many more than those cases that fit well in your systems.
One example: me - ISFJ - E9 - Cancer

 

[Totenkindly]

Oooooh--me too! 22 Nov, can't recall my natal chart tho.... Year of the Rooster, and yeah, I'm a cocky thing.

Oooh, I was born on CS Lewis' birthday (Nov 29) and you were born on the day he died.

Spooky.

I think I'm a Monkey. (Did I say that somewhere yet?)

 

[cafe]

Oooh, I was born on CS Lewis' birthday (Nov 29) and you were born on the day he died.

Oh wow. I have a son born on Nov 29th. I'll have to tell him he was born on C.S.Lewis' birthday. He won't care one little bit, but I think it's cool.

Myself, I'm a Leo INFJ 9w1 born in the year of the dog. I don't think I make a very good Leo. I'm married to an Aries INTP 1w9 and I believe he was born in the year of the pig/boar.

I have no idea what time of day I was born because they drugged my mom so much when she was giving birth to me that she doesn't remember. Makes it hard to get any detailed charts, etc.

 

[Lookin4theBestNU]

Not that I think too highly of anything zodiac, I know people who do . Anyway I am an ENFJ Leo 2w/probable wing 1 though I score highly on 8.

 

[Totenkindly]

Oh wow. I have a son born on Nov 29th.

It's also Madeleine L'Engle's birthday.

(We will just ignore the fact that -- I think -- it is also Howie Mandel's birthday.)

I have no idea what time of day I was born because they drugged my mom so much when she was giving birth to me that she doesn't remember. Makes it hard to get any detailed charts, etc.

That's funny -- I don't remember the situation with your father, wasn't he around to remember?

My sister was born by C-section in the hospital elevator. There apparently was blood everywhere. My mom remembers that one.

... though I score highly on 8.

^^^^ not a big surprise

 

[targobelle]

well this is a rather interesting thought process... it doesn't fit but it's interesting

my b-day is Jan 13th I am a Capricorn and a 2w3.......

 

[Jasz]

sun-jupiter conjunction in aquarius
aries rising
moon in scorpio

INTP

5w4

 

[cafe]

It's also Madeleine L'Engle's birthday.

(We will just ignore the fact that -- I think -- it is also Howie Mandel's birthday.)

I'm pretty sure he won't care about any of them. Maybe if it was somebody that wrote one of his favorite video games he'd find it significant. But I think it's cool.

That's funny -- I don't remember the situation with your father, wasn't he around to remember?

Mom had changed her mind about liking him before she found out she was pregnant. Instead of breaking up with him, she left on a cross-country road trip with some friends. She didn't tell him about me until I was nine months old (I assume because she needed some cash). I was very small for my age and he didn't buy that I was his, so she huffed off and didn't contact him again until I was 27.

My sister was born by C-section in the hospital elevator. There apparently was blood everywhere. My mom remembers that one.

Yikes! I'm guessing she was not properly anesthetized?

 

[meshou]

Yes, but then it doesn't make any sense if you correlate them with the Zodiac Signs.

What's said about the SP temperament is more related to the Fire signs, since Fire is impulsive and spontaneous.

The SJ temperament correlates with Earth because it's said to be stable and traditional.

NT correlates with Air because it's said to be intellectual and logical

Finally, NF correlates with Water because it's said to be emotional and intuitive.

These correlations are very very modern understandings, and would not have been agreed upon as early as a couple hundred years ago. Modern astrology differs hugely from its roots. 'S all I was saying.

 

[Natrushka]

I am a Cancer. Does this mean I can't be an INTJ anymore

 

[Totenkindly]

I am a Cancer. Does this mean I can't be an INTJ anymore

YOUR HOROSCOPE FOR TODAY (CANCER)

• The position of Jupiter says you should spend the rest of the week face down in the mud
• Try not to shove a roll of duct tape up your nose while taking your driver's test

 

[Natrushka]

I knew I should have stayed home today.

 

[The Ü™]

I am a Cancer. Does this mean I can't be an INTJ anymore

Fret not, for I am a Pisces (Cancer moon, Gemini rising) and not an INFP.

 

[The Ü™]

I made a few adjustments, namely changing Pisces and Scorpio MBTI types around, along with changing Virgo's 6w7 Enneagram type to 9w1.

 

[Shimpei]

I made a few adjustments, namely changing Pisces and Scorpio MBTI types around, along with changing Virgo's 6w7 Enneagram type to 9w1.

What for? It would be as erroneous as the previous theory of yours.

 

[raincrow007]

From the OP:

....I do not necessarily believe in it...

What for? It would be as erroneous as the previous theory of yours.

Sheesh, he's just playing with ideas on paper.

Don't ya ever try new recipes just for the hell of it?

 

[The Ü™]

The correlation is about what the astrological symbols mean, not about a person's personality in relation to astrology.

I keep saying, I am a Pisces and not an ENFP 4w3 (which I now typed it as, might make another change). I correspond to Aquarius. Therefore, I am well-aware that it's nothing serious.

 

[Shimpei]

Sheesh, he's just playing with ideas on paper.

Don't ya ever try new recipes just for the hell of it?

I think it's just a waste of time but as long as you enjoy it... Can't believe a herd of NTs pay attention to such things.

 

[rivercrow]

I think it's just a waste of time but as long as you enjoy it... Can't believe a herd of NTs pay attention to such things.

Oh, it's a system and we can't help ourselves.

Besides, JUNG was interested in astrology.



I object to Scorpio being an NF. Scorpio is far too devious and vengeful in it's dark phase to be an F. Ever. And too calculating to be an F.

It's also ruled by Mars (I don't hold with the neo-planetary associations) and Pluto's been, well, plutoed. Scorpio is also associated with Aries, which is hardly an F-ish god.

Heh. This sounds like me, too. I should dig up my natal chart--I have it on my blog someplace....

 

[The Ü™]

I think an Introverted Feeling INFP could be quite vengeful and forceful if their values are violated. And Scorpios hold very passionate values.

And besides, vengeance is driven by feeling, and not logic.

INFPs can get quite angry, but they just don't show it, since Feeling is internal -- they're often very Scorpio-like. Scorpios are also big on loyalty, a Feeling trait revolving around people.

Scorpios are either extremely loyal or extremely rebellious, much like an Enneagram 6 type, which corresponds to Jung's Introverted Feeling.

As a water sign, Scorpio is intuitive and emotional -- clearly corresponding the NF.

EDIT: Oh and yes, Cancer is ruled by the Moon and Leo by the Sun, neither of which are planets...so what's wrong with Scorpio being ruled by Pluto?