1. Must Haves
Very intelligent
(okay Im atleast above average)
Strong moral integrity & standards
yes
Spiritual
yes
Physically attractive
to me not really going to be
Kind, compassionate, thoughtful, considerate, encouraging, supportive
yes
Emotionally stable
yes
Loyal
yes very
Responsible
im intp so that might not be something I am a lot
Affectionate
same thing as above but Im average
Can lead/take initiative
actually I can take the lead, I expect that I should actually
Good communication skills
yes
That undefinable chemistry/spark
who knows
1 1/2. Would likes
Compatible interests/tastes - art, music, food, travel, etc.
I think all in all we have the same or close atleast
Compatible humor - witty &/or silly, but no comedian needed
yes if you like intp humor
Creative, special talent/expertise/passion for
something sort of not really something in particular but all in all, yes
Intellectual, book smarts, analytical side
I would say I am
Altruistic
No
Warm & expressive
No, or above average compared to other NT's
Spontaneous & adventurous - likes NEW things
yes
Driven/motivated
hmmmmm, thats tough, maybe I am driven
Sexay
no
Good style/grooming
hmmmm, no
ENFJ
No, not at all
2. Rather Nots
Lots of tattoos
no tattooes, yes
Atheist and/or disrespectful of my beliefs
not atheist yes
Sports freak, or generally more physical than cerebral
Im more cerebral than physical but I do enjoy some sports
Bald
not bald, yes
Very fat or skinny
No 
Ugly dress & grooming
Hmmmm, average
Passive / clingy / whiny
I can be passive yes, but Im getting better at not being passive
Very reserved/cold
Im average cold
Loud
yes Im not loud
Health nut or very unhealthy habits
Hmmm, as a fat person Im not either, which might surprise some
3. Deal Breakers
Opposites of my must-haves.
we already covered that
All the usual stuff: violent, drug use/abuse, dishonest, married, bad hygiene, lazy, etc...
Im sure I would fit to those things
Argumentative, condescending, rude
Im not, so yes
Alcoholism (that is not in check)
I like a bottle of wine once a week or so...
Porn fan
Im not a porn fan, so yes
Smoking
Im not smoking
Kids
No kids
Obese
I am kind of obese 
Asexual
Im not entirely asexual, its pretty much average
Obnoxious
I dont think so
Military / police / owns a gun
I have no guns or never would want one
Domineering
Its about common respect for me, so Im not domineering
Stupid relationship games, manipulative
I would never do that
Man, I could keep going....I swear I am more negotiable than this