Watched Episode 1 of Poker Face on Peacock, the brainchild of Rian Johnson and starring Natasha Lyonne w/ a ton of familiar character actor guest stars.
About my only complaint is that the episodes are long -- the pilot was a good 67 minutes, which felt about 15 minutes too long, but I'm not sure of how it would have been squeezed. At least the rest are a LITTLE shorter, as they look to run 48-58 minutes in general, but that can still feel a bit long.
Lyonne is pretty brilliant, and tonally the show is put together well. I am too young to TRULY remember Columbo (I knew who he was and might have watched some episodes but as an adult I don't recall details) with Peter Falk, and intuitively I'm seeing this as some kind of homage, just with a female lead. Even her crazy accent reminds me of Columbo, and as Charlie, Lyonne plays her as a bit eccentric, shabby, but very dogged and intuitively smart. Her "power" (which they don't waste time trying to explain, as she doesn't even understand it) is that she can immediately tell if someone is lying to her. As she clarifies in the episode, this isn't as helpful as one might think because people are constantly lying about a variety of things so she has to somehow discern whether the lie they are hiding is related to the crime she is investigating. So the show becomes more of a logical "who dun it" approach, where she sleuths along and gets enough information to logic out the answer enough to start quizzing people and testing her guesses; in that sense it's more like the logic problems you'd see in puzzle books where you can use a bit of information to gain further information (or exclude answers) and then slowly piece together the final answer.
The audience isn't really part of this process, as at least in the pilot we're aware of what happened and who did the crime before she is, and the fun is more in watching her navigate and facing off with someone we know is the villain. It's kind of fascinating to watch how her brain work and rooting for her.
This pilot reminds me also of the "Incredible Hulk" TV setup, where that pilot basically sends David Banner on the run and then it becomes a weekly adventure in a new place as he tries to avoid discovery by Jack McGee and others. There's a similar setup in here where Charlie will now need to keep moving... and apparently solving crimes in whichever new location she's at next time.
In the opener, as opposed to that crappy Ghosted film, Adrien Brody is actually decent. He seems to intuitively know how to play his character and his skin feels "lived in" versus just pretending to be sketchy. (Again, not a spoiler -- you know what's going on as soon as the opening finishes.)
If you are into this style of show, it's a no-brainer to watch as it's really put together well, it's kind of fun, and the acting is great. If you are not into this, it might still be worth watching just because it's a good show. I might or might not finish it because the episodes just feel long to me, but it's not a bad time investment.
--
I also watched e1 of Citadel on Amazon Prime. I'm kinda in the middle on this show. It becomes quickly apparent this spy show isn't going to have a lot of quality in the detail -- it's kind of on the surface and traffics in tropes. Priyanka Chopra Jonas and Richard Madden are the main stars, accompanied by a darker Stanley Tucci. I mean, I'd never shirk from something with Stanley Tucci in it, and the two leads are decent enough. But there's not a lot of brain here, it's pretty much by the numbers and feels like high-end glam spies who can pretty much win any fight even when they outgunned. Of course the pilot sets it that the entire org is wiped out and our two protagonists go awol... then it comes down some years later that out of the entire org, there are a few survivors who have to now stop their nemesis org.
The entire series was supposedly bankrolled at $300 million. I can't say I can see where that money has gone, from the pilot episode. And paired with the writer strike -- the scripts are functional but pretty much by the numbers, ChatGPT could probably write the first draft. I guess we see where the money did not go. Which leaves me wondering why they don't pay the writers more -- to GET QUALITY WRITING? The writing and plotting is actually the structure of the show on which everything else is hung, yet they squeeze writing costs down to hang fancy flesh on bones that can't support it. When will they get their heads on straight enough to actually hire quality writers and runners?
I predict this show will either get canceled or Amazon will just break even or lose money on it if they persist. It's not like it's a Rings of Power thing where even a shitshow won't dissuade hardcore fans from watching it. Let's face it, in 5-10 years, neither RoP or Citadel will be spoken about much at all.
If you want a kind of brainless but pretty show with pretty leads, Citadel might be for you. It's okay so far. I suspect if you want thriller shows with a brain, watch even some older stuff like Person of Interest.