It's fairly close to the Stephen King story, with a few key changes that might make it less good (where the character detail or plotting lost some nuance). And I'm not talking about how Morgan Freeman is cast as a white Irish guy with red hair; Darabont made it into a decent joke (calling a black guy "Red"), it is stuff mostly with the Warden etc that was overdone.
However, it's pretty much verbatim the ending, and the ending is primarily why people love it so much.
It is one of the best Stephen King endings both in his writing and in the film adaptations that is actually a positive and inspiring ending.
For whatever reason, the Gen X FB groups have been arguing this week about whether Forrest Gump deserved its Best Picture win over Pulp Fiction and Shawshank Redemption.
I think Gump was kind of dazzling with its tech savvy at the time, as well as some inspiring themselves; Pulp Fiction was more of a niche film and Shawshank hadn't really been attended much when it dropped in the theater. I think at the time, it's understandable why a blockbuster like Gump had the most votes and awareness. Nowadays Gump scores the lowest on IMDB but all are in the top 15 from what I thought.
However, over time, especially with its tech marvels diminishing (because we've seen so much more since), basically Pulp Fiction is easily the most creative of the three (Tarantino is firing on all cylinders), while Shawshank actually earns the heartfelt drama without reliance on cheap gags and had been seen by a lot more people. If the Oscars had been held a few years later, there might have been a different outcome.
I think Pulp Fiction is the best of the three. I've seen it the most recently out of all of them. I don't remember me loving or hating Forrest Gump when I saw it, but I think as I learned more about the history of what it was covering, it began to bother me. I tend to see it as a list of Boomer cliches, sort of an annoying cinematic "We Didn't Start the Fire." This is probably unfair, and I should give it a rewatch before going on a long-winded rant about why I don't like it.
Shawshank I don't hate, but I've changed so much since I saw that I may have a very different reaction now. I'm more open to being moved by things.
My favorite King adaption to date is The Shining (RIP Shelley Duvall), which everyone knows King hated. I love atmospheric horror, especially when it centers around isolation. I haven't read very much King so I can't comment on the divergences from the books
Pulp Fiction though.... That movie was way ahead of its time. There's just the structure of it. Now lots of movies do nonlinear storytelling, but I don't think they were doing it too much before Pulp Fiction came around. I think the story and characters must also have been unusual. Jules is my favorite, as he must be for most people who watch the movie. The only real issue is that there's something Tarantino decided to do in the movie, and I have to wonder why he thought it would be a good idea to do that. Everyone who has seen the movie probably knows exactly what I'm talking about.
Huh. I don't tend to have much interest in that genre myself. I'm not sure why either. I'm not adverse to it -- I really like Bound (but more because of the queer themes and the cinematography and performances) and The Departed, for example, and I will watch mafia movies that have been deemed good, but usually remain kind of indifferent. It feels like a limited genre to me and a lot feels alike to me.
I've never felt a strong desire to watch The Sopranos although I know a lot of people love the series. Maybe if I watched the first few episodes, it would grow on me.
The Sopranos does many different things subtextually that are interesting. It often riffs on ideas some people have of masculinity (although I'm sure some people that watch it don't see it that way). The characters will spend a lot of time pontification on the rules, and then demand other characters follow them, while proceeding to break them, and I find stuff like this comedic. There are also episodes that touch on religious hypocrisy, and I think it's interesting to see how other family members come to terms with what Tony is.
For me, I think this scene sold me:
I also watched The Creator today. I enjoyed it, although I saw a certain plot twist coming.
This story dealt with a lot of themes I really love. For instance, I love sci-fi that traffics in the idea of humans fearing something they don't understand.
It also dealt with broad, archetypal concepts and I felt that gave the story much emotional resonance.
I was definitely moved by this movie, and it mostly hit all the right notes for me.
My only criticism of this film is that I got really tired of them showing up at a place, staying for a while, and then getting attacked and having to flee to wherever will move the plot along. I think it would have been ideal to go to this well less often; I think it diminished the impact of the climax of the film.
This is not the movie's fault, but I got tired of CC making references to "New Asian". In particular, I got sick of the caption saying "Police officer yells something in New Asian." Like, why not just make It Japanese or Chinese? There's no New English or New American.