I recently rewatched the Christopher Reeve Supermans. He really owned that role and I hadn’t realized how skilled he was at using subtle gestures and posture to separate Clark Kent from Superman. He really was an S tier actor who should’ve been more successful outside of this franchise, but he got pigeonholed as a pretty boy for most of his career.
Superman 1, pretty solid introduction and doesn’t linger on the origin story longer than it needs to, unlike a lot of post 2000 superhero stuff. Brando and Hackman are awesome
Superman 2, kind of silly but still the best. I’ve never seen the Donner cut, maybe it improves on Lester’s cut, which does tend to play up the silly elements and comic relief too much when more drama is needed. Zod is the best villain of the series, largely due to Stamp elevating what was otherwise a very one dimensional baddie
Superman 3, I have mixed feelings. I really enjoy the evil Superman and Smallville subplots, but then the Richard Pryor stuff just makes it very disjointed. Remove Pryor and Robert Vaughan, add Gene Hackman, and you’d have the perfect follow up to part 2. Reeve looks and performs best in 3, I mean he got JACKED for that one whereas he’s just a tad too lanky in the others. I think his physique in this film is preferable to what we’ve seen with actors in newer superhero films, in which it’s obvious they’re using steroids. It’s also better than the beefcake look that was getting popular around the same time with Stallone and Schwarzenegger. I want to look like Reeve in Superman 3 and I think it’s a realistic and achievable goal with a natty routine. Tie between 2 and 3 as my favorites.
Superman 4 is just sad, Cannon Films had a golden goose and they blew the opportunity by cutting corners on story and fx. The Cannon films documentary had some interesting on why they failed with Superman 4 and Masters of the Universe, films that should have been major hits. They just couldn’t get past the style of low budget production, which might work for a Bronson or Norris action film, but in something that is dependent on optical effects, you can’t cut corners. The flying visuals in 4 look worse than those in the original 1978 film, and that’s unforgivable in a 1987 movie when special effects had come quite a ways.
For the most part these films had a good balance of heart/drama and the silly camp I’d expect in an adaptation of a 1930s comic book. Also Williams original theme music will never be topped.