I didn't say ISTJ's were all of those things. Just the artistic part. And other types can fit some of the other things.
OK, for the best fit type. VJ and her friends once pointed me towards that one (as the best set or profiles), and I still found the ENFP to be too "Sanguine" to be me, which is what I tended to notice about ENFP profiles, though I'll have to look again to see what you mean by 'supernatural'. She even had suggested that most other ENFP profiles were "contaminated" by ESFP.
ENFP on that profile basically goes again by the Keirsey Idealist definition that they are all mediating social worker types (which is wonderful, I'm just not a very good mediator and I can often be less than diplomatic, though I'm quite sweet when I'm not upset) and suggests that ENFPs can see through strangers, which I cannot. My ESFJ ex said I could see through him and tell when he was lying, but that's certainly not the same thing as
seeing some little boy's soul, or going around telling each and every stranger what is special about them and being uber-understanding (again, which is great, a wonderful talent, it's just not quite me).
I'm more about freedom like the ESFP profile emphasizes, a little more earthy, and more into bonding/connecting and "one-up-manship" and a little competition in conversation, while I'm too sensitive to take strong personal attacks like in the ISFP profile.
Black Cat said he found Best Fit to be a good resource when he was deciding between INFP and ISFP. Of course, Black Cat is a 9, so I'm not going to be exactly like him, either.
I really like the PTypes ISFP description, and it's just a fact that I fit Hedonist better than Idealist, and even fit Keirsey's Artisans slightly better than his Idealists.
I remember a long, long time ago (like when I very first got into personality types) I took the PTypes test - just the temperaments, I didn't know how they linked to the individual types at that point so I hadn't read them - and I got Hedonist and I was, like, embarrassed? Because I just took it like it was saying that I was some kind of bad person who didn't think of anyone but my own good time or something lol....now I understand that Hedonist just means Artisan or SP, and that it isn't some moral judgement on me. Now I'm totally fine with it and it makes sense to me.
The main thing I relate to about ENFP descriptions is the standing up for what I believe in, like how I am about protecting my loved ones or defending my political views. But apparently according to this PTypes description of the Exuberant type, they take pride in not being afraid to stand up for what they believe in, too.
Anyway, on Best Fit SFP sounds most like me, on PTypes ISFP sounds most like me, and in Keirsey while I relate to some of ENFP, ESFP and ISFP, I fit the Artisan temperament in terms of highest form of intelligence, where I get my self-respect, and career choices or whatever better than Idealist, which is ultimately the primary point of Keirsey...skills and job placement.