purplesunset
New member
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2009
- Messages
- 113
- Enneagram
- 4w5
There is a fundamental contradiction between the answers that these two questions are getting:
1. Do you think you're sometimes more selfish, mean, and less lovey-dovey than what people think us to be?
and
10. Do you think the world would be a bit better with more INFP's?!
---------------------------------------------------
People are even contradicting themselves within the same post.
The answer to number 1 is most often Yes !
The answer to number 10 is overwhelmingly NO!
The reasons they cite for saying no to number 10 is that the world will be filled with too much fluffy pink bunnies, random silliness etc.
HUH??? This contradicts directly with what they answer for number 1.
----------------------------------
Things like this help to discredit the validity of MBTI, in my opinion.
Is it supposed to be about preferences, or is it more about the stereotypes?
The stereotypes just won't go away, and it seems like INFP's themselves are fostering the stereotypes with their answers to number 10.
I wish Orangeappled (I'm calling you out, sister
) would weigh in on this.
I'm not sure about my type, but if I'm the only (possible) INFP seeing this contradiction in the answers, then I guess I could safely rule out being an INFP myself.
-----------------------------------------
There is also the possibility that you guys are being facetious in your answers to number 10,and I am just taking them way too seriously (as usual).
1. Do you think you're sometimes more selfish, mean, and less lovey-dovey than what people think us to be?
and
10. Do you think the world would be a bit better with more INFP's?!
---------------------------------------------------
People are even contradicting themselves within the same post.
The answer to number 1 is most often Yes !
The answer to number 10 is overwhelmingly NO!
The reasons they cite for saying no to number 10 is that the world will be filled with too much fluffy pink bunnies, random silliness etc.
HUH??? This contradicts directly with what they answer for number 1.
----------------------------------
Things like this help to discredit the validity of MBTI, in my opinion.
Is it supposed to be about preferences, or is it more about the stereotypes?
The stereotypes just won't go away, and it seems like INFP's themselves are fostering the stereotypes with their answers to number 10.
I wish Orangeappled (I'm calling you out, sister
I'm not sure about my type, but if I'm the only (possible) INFP seeing this contradiction in the answers, then I guess I could safely rule out being an INFP myself.
-----------------------------------------
There is also the possibility that you guys are being facetious in your answers to number 10,and I am just taking them way too seriously (as usual).