G
Tell Carl.
This man has a curious version of reality; this is the first time I have quoted or responded to his posts in this thread.
It's not unhealthy; it's just Ti.
I've told you before; I'm not your mother - go away. Do I need to repeat the same speech?
Come on, projection is not what I'm talking about. That's trolling isn't it? The goal of constructive critisism is for positive change; there's a time and place for it.
Does the kitty need a hug?
Too bad he didn't live to tell about it.
No, projection is trolling, correct? The way you described it earlier.Giving my opinion and quoting Jung is trolling? No, it is not.
No wonder Jim started this thread. He has a point.
He's alive in the picture... telling about it.
No, projection is trolling, correct? The way you described it earlier.
No, projection is trolling, correct? The way you described it earlier.
If a member is that intent on telling another member they're in an "unhealthy loop," they may just be looking at themselves in the mirror and don't like what they see.
Projections change the world into the replica of one's own unknown face.
- Carl Jung
Is constructive criticism judgment?
Come on, projection is not what I'm talking about. That's trolling isn't it? The goal of constructive critisism is for positive change; there's a time and place for it.
Actually, I think all criticism is formed from judgement and that a great deal of it also originates with projection. The projection can introduce distortion but may not always. These things are true whether the criticism is constructive, helpful or not.
Projection in the negative sense is trolling, correct? Not in all cases, but in some.
Yes! I must have been projecting! :hi:...
Does INTJMom need a hug? :hi:
Yeah, that's not okay....
Ne wants to mirror the mirror, anything which refuses to do so is unhealthy by self definition and Ne projection defaults to the unhealthy type labels.
As I said, it's not unhealthy use of Ne; it's just Ne.
Judgment? For heaven's sake, what does this topic, "Unhealthy vs. Healthy - a Failure of Typology", have to do with Jesus Christ and casting stones? This isn't judgment day! "Unhealthy" is just a simple adjective with simple meaning. It's *not* judgment in the same sense as your example. You're taking things out of context. Is constructive criticism judgment?
I think people should be free to tell others they're in an unhealthy loop or that their implementation of a function is unhealthy. This isn't limited to shadow functioning. As I've said before, "unhealthy" is not a difficult thing to spot. There are *widely accepted* ideas of what's healthy and what's not. I have no problem if someone wants to tell me I'm unhealthy and break it down on a function level by implementation. I appreciate the constructive critisism.
No and I don't think anyone ever said that in this thread. I know the OP didn't say that. As a matter of fact, you are the first person I've seen make that assumption. Where are you getting that from? Who are you debating? Specifically, how does a weak function look unhealthy if, as you said, you "recognize it"? an example?
I don't recall anyone ever telling you not to use your less developed functions because it makes you look unhealthy.
Unstable was meant as a frame of mind that hinders the correct use of the processes. Not a stable personality that has faulty cognition, from a subjective point of view.
I can agree with this.My perception of the use of "unhealthy" on this board is that it is referring to emotionally instability which clouds a person's thinking. Unhealthy is not really a word used for poor thinking, usually.