you know, I really really wish that this show was consistent.
The opener for Season 4, second half, I thought was really strong and kind of reminded me of why I had ever liked the series in the first place. It was written by Kirkman (so I'm gonna have to give him props) and directed by Nicotero, who's directed some pretty strong episodes including the one where Merle and Daryl meet for the last time... It was paced nicely, took its time, and I felt like it really conveyed the seriousness of what just happened. I felt like Herschel got screwed over big-time by the mid-season cliffhanger, it was just so poorly treated; but Herschel's appearance here with Michonne was handled just right.
It was a great character study of Michonne and Carl, despite not much dialogue. Carl's growing up and trying to find that balance of being a man while still admitting his own fear. I just thought it was great how he shifts back and forth, trying to be the grownup but... he's just not quite there yet even though for all intents and purposes he carries that load regardless.
The whole scene with him eating on the roof was just funny, albeit also unsettling; and him telling his dad what he ate made me laugh.
Rick has definitely seen better days. he really took quite the beating from the Governor. I don't think I've ever seen him so poor off. Who is he, now that he really ISN'T the leader and protector (as he has no one to lead)?
It's also nice to see a little bit of Michonne's backstory, but there's likely far more to come. Also, she has changed; she used to just be able to walk with the zombies as a matter of survival, but she no longer wants just survival, she's more than a zombie, she wants to be with other people. That was a big step for her -- given a choice between going solitary and finding others, well, she made her choice.
I really hope the quality stays this high for the rest of the season, but this show is just a crapshoot sometimes. I'm expecting disappointment but hoping I'm wrong.