Well man.. FWIW, even though I have a lot of disagreements with you, and we don't exactly get along (just being honest), I respect that you at least argue your points and try to participate in discussion. That's why I suspect Spurgeon is a troll. His level of dismisiveness and deflection is unrealistic. I've never seen anything like it at least. There are intolerant people in the world, but he seems like a parody of intolerance.
And the second thing that makes me confused is... Why here? Typology Central. Suddenly this of all places is some battleground to wage holy war against? He couldn't have gone to a forum that truly revels in "depravity"? He could have chosen a website devoted to "piss fetishists" or some racist forum. But he chose a psychology website? This makes no sense to me.
I do think this is phony, I also have begun to rethink a lot of other threads too when I think about it. There's a couple of them that I suspect right away of being invented as pretext to just messing with people.
The second part, there's other TypoC members I have on ignore, I suspect some of them would create threads to try and bait people into discussions with them. Its part of the reason I have them on ignore in the first place. I suspect that some of them could or would create an account like this. There are, yes, other forums and sources of contact on the web which I've had with people who've turned out to be jerks and I ignore them too, either because the forums in question afford that function or just the old fashioned way of not reading anything they post. There ARE some of them who're obsessive or weird types and I'd not be surprised if they followed me here because I use the same username and discuss the same topics in the same way here as elsewhere. That's a possibility too.
If you mean in general why they'd choose here, if they're a randomer and not a troll and not seeking to try and bait any particular members, well, maybe in a search engine this site just came up?