JustDave
New member
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2008
- Messages
- 992
- MBTI Type
- xNTP
Could be INTJ?
Definitely. Although I can't seem to reconcile her caring nurturing nature with what I know of INTJs ...
Could be INTJ?
Have you read much at INTJ message board? Read the women's posts?
I have not, and I probably should. Thanks.
To Heart and anyone else who might care,
How can one distinguish a very organized ISTP from an INTJ?
*nods* Could likely be INTJ. Definitely a J though... based on her habits. Organizing stuff... Te like? Maybe...
The only thing I am certain of is she is an Introvert. Overall she seems to posses and Artisan temperament but has several traits not typically found in Artisans.
The only problems I have with the INTJ assessment is:
- As far as I know she does not have any secret plans or hidden agendas.
- Although IMO she is very intelligent she is not an abstract thinker.
- She is a very caring person.
Is it possible for an Artisan to be both organized and nurturing?
Here's my assessment so far:
INTJ - she is too caring and concrete.
INFJ - she is too concrete.
Guardian - she is a Habitual rule breaker.
ISTP/ISFP - Most plausible (INFJ being the second) but she is very organized which is a trait that an Artisan is not likely to naturally posses.
A guardian can be a rule breaker... If the guardian prescribes to a different set of rules... STJ more likely than SFJ though in this case.
Why can't INXJs be concrete sometimes? As people grow older, they do learn to use their shadow functions...
An SP being very organized is more unlikely though in my opinion...