On May 23, 2017 I sent the following e-mail to my mother and aunt, both of whom are Trump supporters:
From: Jonny
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2017 1:11 PM
To: M & A
Subject: Some prophetic words for you about our political environment today
Below is an excerpt from a
2010 interview with Noam Chomsky, Professor Emeritus at MIT. He’s a renowned intellectual and political scholar, and has a body of work spanning our lifetimes (so nobody can say he lacks the experience to opine on the problems facing our country and the world). In this interview he’s discussing the emerging political climate and growing discontent as a result of rising inequality and lack of effective response from those in power. My concerns have never been rooted with Trump himself, but in what his election and the current trajectory of our politics says about us as a people. Old habits die hard, and humanity is nothing if not habitual.
It [the political climate in the United States] is very similar to late Weimar Germany. The parallels are striking. There was also tremendous disillusionment with the parliamentary system. The most striking fact about Weimar was not that the Nazis managed to destroy the Social Democrats and the Communists but that the traditional parties, the Conservative and Liberal parties, were hated and disappeared. It left a vacuum which the Nazis very cleverly and intelligently managed to take over.
The United States is extremely lucky that no honest, charismatic figure has arisen. Every charismatic figure is such an obvious crook that he destroys himself, like McCarthy or Nixon or the evangelist preachers. If somebody comes along who is charismatic and honest this country is in real trouble because of the frustration, disillusionment, the justified anger and the absence of any coherent response. What are people supposed to think if someone says ‘I have got an answer, we have an enemy’? There it was the Jews. Here it will be the illegal immigrants and the blacks. We will be told that white males are a persecuted minority. We will be told we have to defend ourselves and the honor of the nation. Military force will be exalted. People will be beaten up. This could become an overwhelming force. And if it happens it will be more dangerous than Germany. The United States is the world power. Germany was powerful but had more powerful antagonists. I don’t think all this is very far away. If the polls are accurate it is not the Republicans but the right-wing Republicans, the crazed Republicans, who will sweep the next election.
I have never seen anything like this in my lifetime. I am old enough to remember the 1930s. My whole family was unemployed. There were far more desperate conditions than today. But it was hopeful. People had hope. The CIO was organizing. No one wants to say it anymore but the Communist Party was the spearhead for labor and civil rights organizing. Even things like giving my unemployed seamstress aunt a week in the country. It was a life. There is nothing like that now. The mood of the country is frightening. The level of anger, frustration and hatred of institutions is not organized in a constructive way. It is going off into self-destructive fantasies.
I listen to talk radio. I don’t want to hear Rush Limbaugh. I want to hear the people calling in. They are like [suicide pilot] Joe Stack. What is happening to me? I have done all the right things. I am a God-fearing Christian. I work hard for my family. I have a gun. I believe in the values of the country and my life is collapsing.
You two both talked about how the growing welfare state is responsible for many of our woes. That proliferating immigrants, both illegal and legal, are sucking away your money and jobs. I contend this is false, and that our problems lie in more fundamental issues with the distribution of wealth and, more importantly, opportunities to climb out of poverty… to achieve the “American Dream.†There’s a hopelessness. It’s chronic. It’s endemic.
A political philosophy grounded in hate and blame, in caricaturizing and demeaning a group of people as less intelligent or productive or moral, won’t solve the problems we face.