Kelly Clarkson

[HongDou]

I've no clue but I think she's awesome.

She's been my idol for most of my life!

I'm still feeling ESFP 6w7 so/sx - I used to think ENFP because I wanted us to be the same but she seems more ESFP to me. Not as sure about her Enneagram but BoY sounds very 6 to me and she's very security-oriented overall. Waiting for some refreshing new ideas though before voting.

 

[EJCC]

[MENTION=17131]Chanaynay[/MENTION]

Merged with the previous Kelly Clarkson typing thread you made

 

[HongDou]

[MENTION=17131]Chanaynay[/MENTION]

Merged with the previous Kelly Clarkson typing thread you made

I forgot I made this!! Oh how times have changed (slightly).

 

[Kingu Kurimuzon]

funny how people usually assume ESFx for any pop singer.

I agree with ENFP

 

[HongDou]

funny how people usually assume ESFx for any pop singer.

I agree with ENFP

Haha Starcrash let's not go down this route...I'm pretty sure almost all of the forum knows how hard I stan for Queen Kelly so I'm sure you know how many years I've invested into getting to know her through her music, interviews, concerts, etc. There is absolutely no way I would type her as ESFx just because she's a pop singer and I'm actually pretty insulted you would even think I would do such a thing.

I'm still leaning towards ESFP but ENFP is also reasonable so I'm interested in what you have to say for it.

 

[Kingu Kurimuzon]

Haha Starcrash let's not go down this route...I'm pretty sure almost all of the forum knows how hard I stan for Queen Kelly so I'm sure you know how many years I've invested into getting to know her through her music, interviews, concerts, etc. There is absolutely no way I would type her as ESFx just because she's a pop singer and I'm actually pretty insulted you would even think I would do such a thing.

I'm still leaning towards ESFP but ENFP is also reasonable so I'm interested in what you have to say for it.

I wouldn't rule out ESFP, just a sort of general vibe from quotes over the years. Years ago a girl I dated made me watch that first season of american idol. She has a very take-me-as-I-am attitude, so I assumed aux Fi, which wouldn't rule out ESFP. She doesn't seem particularly tuned into the latest trends, or at least she isn't making any great effort trying to stay on top of them but rather she just enjoys being a performer--that led me to think Ne-Si over Se-Ni, but it's a tossup, really. ESFPs are the performers of the MBTI, but that doesn't necessarily make every performer ESFP.

You know more about her, so your typing is probably more accurate than mine. Like I said, just a general vibe, little more.

 

[Olm the Water King]

ESFP 6w7

 

[Lunar Light]

She's been my idol for most of my life!

I'm still feeling ESFP 6w7 so/sx - I used to think ENFP because I wanted us to be the same but she seems more ESFP to me. Not as sure about her Enneagram but BoY sounds very 6 to me and she's very security-oriented overall. Waiting for some refreshing new ideas though before voting.

Yeah I thought ESFP (though I agree ENFP is possible) and I agree with so/sx. I always sort of automatically assumed 7w6 because of a sort of free-ness she has with herself, but 6w7 definitely seems possible and seems more evident in her songs. I see strong themes of both... hmm... For some reason though, I keep getting Se/Ni feels (though I don't have something concrete to back it up). Ne/Si just doesn't "feel" right... even though she fits what you'd expect from an ENFP quite well.

Also I like her a lot too ^_^.

 

[plastic ciel]

ESFP would be my primary guess but I wouldn't be shocked by ENFP either

 

[ChocolateMoose123]

She is a total ENFP.

 

[Captain_Invincible]

From what I know of her: Definite sop-fest. She likes singing about faces and body parts a lot. She seems to focus more on Se than Ne to me. She seems like an ESFP who needs serious counselling.

Enneagram? Yeah, she seems like a slightly unhealthy 6. She seems clingy, anxious, depressed and 'not herself' without her 'other half',from what I know. Going for Sx dominant also.

And she's also overplayed in my house.

 

[HongDou]

From what I know of her: Definite sop-fest. She likes singing about faces and body parts a lot. She seems to focus more on Se than Ne to me. She seems like an ESFP who needs serious counselling.

That's funny you say that since the latest album she just released was very upbeat and happy to reflect her current place in life. I think she's healthier than she was during the My December era for sure.

I'm really unsure for her MBTI-wise at this point. I think ENFP, ESFP, and ESFJ are the most reasonable guesses for her and I can see all three working for her - I think her interaction style is most apparent. Some Socionics forum types her as LIE-Te which is like lol...

She's definitely a 6w7 tho.

 

[HongDou]

Here are some of her more personal songs/lyrics:

I watched you die
I heard you cry every night in your sleep
I was so young
You should have known better than to lean on me
You never thought of anyone else
You just saw your pain
And now I cry in the middle of the night
For the same damn thing

Because of you
I never stray too far from the sidewalk
Because of you
I learned to play on the safe side so I don't get hurt
Because of you
I try my hardest just to forget everything
Because of you
I don't know how to let anyone else in
Because of you
I'm ashamed of my life because it's empty
Because of you
I am afraid

And all I remember is your back
Walking towards the airport, leaving us all in your past
I traveled fifteen hundred miles to see you
Begged you to want me, but you didn't want to

But piece by piece, he collected me
Up off the ground, where you abandoned things, yeah
Piece by piece he filled the holes that you burned in me
At six years old and you know, he never walks away
He never asks for money, he takes care of me
He loves me
Piece by piece, he restored my faith
That a man can be kind and a father could... stay

Far, away from it all
You and me with no one else around
A brand new start
Is all we need, it's all we need to mend these hearts
Back to the beginning

Be still
Let it go

Before we lost hope
When we still touched and love wasn't so hard

Be still
I already know

Foolish one with the smile
You don't have to be brave
Every time we fall down
But we're falling from grace
I'll gladly climb your walls if you'll meet me halfway

Slow, slow it down
Why do we run, we're missing so much babe
Just lay in my arms for a while

Be still
We should've known

Foolish one with the smile
You don't have to be brave
I'll gladly climb your walls
If you'll meet me halfway
Every time we fall down
But we're falling from grace
Here's my hand and my heart
It's yours to take

Be still

I don't wanna be left behind
Distance was a friend of mine
Catching breath in a web of lies
I've spent most of my life
Riding waves, playing acrobat
Shadowboxing the other half
Learning how to react
I've spent most of my time

Catching my breath, letting it go,
Turning my cheek for the sake of the show
Now that you know, this is my life,
I won't be told what's supposed to be right

I wish she wrote more of her own songs. She wrote every song on My December but even then I can still count all of her truly personal songs on my fingers. But I guess she's too guarded to disclose so much over her music. Hopefully next album she shares more of herself with her fans.

 

[Annaifiwas]

she's definitely not thinking dominant

Haha, indeed!

 

[Annaifiwas]

I don't think she can be an ExFJ, that'd call for Fe dom, and I'm pretty sure she uses Fi.
Extrovert as far as I can see.
Also, Ne would be pretty hard to imagine for her, but I don't think it's Ni auxiliary.
Only options left are ENTJ and ESFP.
She's definteley not a Te dom XD
ESFP is what fits her the best, I think.

 

[Elfboy]

I originally thought 6, but I could see 6, 9 or 3 core

 

[biohazard]

I think she's ENTJ and probably a 3.

 

[SigmaEnigma]

I don't see where she has dominant Ne at all. She seems highly focused on the physical aspects of things, so I'm pretty confident she's an Se dom. As for aux, definitely Fi > Ti. ESFP 6w7/7w6 would be my guess.

 

[neko 4]

6 or 9

 

[Julius_Van_Der_Beak]

The most innovative musician of the last 100 years. She's simultaneously all the non-SJ types at once.