OrangeAppled
Sugar Hiccup
- Joined
- Mar 20, 2009
- Messages
- 7,626
- MBTI Type
- INFP
- Enneagram
- 4w5
- Instinctual Variant
- sp/sx
Julia Roberts is an INFP? I'm sure I am biased because I am INFP & cannot stand her, but what's the evidence?
how do you conclude that?
you see them as Fi or as dichotomy perceivers?
i guess my idea is that DN's list should be at least consistent. so as long as he and other here manage to correctly identify Fi people and list them as infp
do you agree that tim roth, lisa edelstein, ben browder, are the same?
do you have an opinion about rufus sewell
what i notice is the banana shaped face that comes from a strong chin and mild cheekbones (gosling, mel gibson ...)
I just watched Donnie Brasco last night...
May I suggest Johnny Depp as ISFJ? I think I've finally nailed him down. ;-)
I was also gonna suggest Al Pacino as INFJ but you already got him there...
are you actually trying to nail them down based on their appearance in movies? that's like trying to describe someone's face when they're wearing a mask.
Julia Roberts is an INFP? I'm sure I am biased because I am INFP & cannot stand her, but what's the evidence?
Additionally, I do V.I. usually extremely accurately, and he looks very ISFJ in his expressions. They have a very held back look, almost a stony wall to their look. The eyes do very unique things as well.
If you don't think it's possible to tell someone's type based on their features combined with expressions, I feel you're missing out on a fascinating aspect of type. ;-) But of course, that's not all I base my typing on.
a) you don't have merit to prove what you said in the first paragraph. measure is empirical, and even when you say it's accurate, it could be for a million reasons that you get the same result. i know an ISFJ and he is nothing like you describe, and nothing like depp looks in at least 2 interviews. how would you explain that?
b) i know i have more success with determining a person's type through what they say, not how they act. let me tell you why: non-verbal communication, like verbal communication, is based upon how extrovert or introvert you are. if you are introvert, you'd be more passive in your body language than if you were extroverted. conversely, if you were extroverted, your body language would be more aggressive. but that's the thing: body language only measures introvert/extrovert ratio. there's almost no way to tell whether a person is S or N purely from their body language. it gets especially hard when you try to decipher an introvert's entire type just by body language, since theirs is so much more passive. so yes, i would agree with you on the part that depp is introverted based entirely on his body language, but not more than that.
as an addendum, i see you're letting your S get the best of you by trying to explain things that you have little evidence for and judging other people on how they look on things. may i suggest you double check future posts to avoid further non-sequiturs?
Actually, I would suggest avoiding "suggesting" (a.k.a. ordering around) other people's behavior.
it's funny how what you just wrote is a hypocritical paradox. i can't help but try to fix broken things, but at least i don't make a fuss about it when people tell me differently.
also, i would love to see some argumentation from you here... it doesn't work for me to see claims without reason.