Julius_Van_Der_Beak
Fallen
- Joined
- Jul 24, 2008
- Messages
- 22,429
- MBTI Type
- EVIL
- Enneagram
- 5w6
- Instinctual Variant
- sp/so
Pausing to say this: I'll have to write my review tomorrow. I also pose a question to all of you:
I always liked the implication that the kid knew what Malcolm didnt and never pushed the issue. Showed maturity in Cole's character.Needed a comfort film, so I watched my new 4K of The Sixth Sense.
I never quite viewed this as horror, to me it just is character drama with supernatural elements (kind of like Mike Flanagan's stuff as well). The enduring qualities of the film are just really the arcs of the three main characters (Malcolm, Cole, and Lynn) and how they all resolve in hard-won ways.
Obviously Malcolm is centered in his role and desire to help children; in a sense, he's also justifying the award he has just won at the film's opening, but the kids always mattered to him. Balanced against this is feeling like it is costing him his relationship with his wife. The end of the film, he resolves both.
Cole states what he wants pretty early in the film -- not to be afraid anymore. The first time we see him, he is scurrying along to the sanctity of a church, where he at least feels safe. But he is terrorized everywhere else in the film... by his peers, and feeling like he's not necessarily living up to his mom's expectations after his dad abandoned him, and also by the objects of his secret which we discover partway through the film, spinning our interpretation of events on its head. There's that beautiful scene where Lynn greets Cole home from school by telling him all the wonderful make-believe things she has done that day -- and when Cole reciprocates, we hear a boy who just wants to actually fit in and be liked by his peers. The last thing he fantasizes about is "being carried around on their shoulders triumphantly"... and the end of the film brings that full circle... but also brings he and his mom together.
Lynn's arc isn't as complex but essentially her husband left her, and her son has problems he doesn't let her help with, and she is working two jobs, and she feels like she is badly failing as a mother and is no one to be proud of. Cole working through his fear and telling her what's wrong contributes to both of these insecurities being washed away.
I have always loved Toni Collette in this film, she has always felt like the quintessential ESFJ who here might not be gifted with leaps of intuition or prodigious knowledge, and often she feels confused and overwhelmed by life, but she fiercely and tirelessly loves her son and any time her frustration or anger threatens to get the better of her, she just doubles-down and fiercely protects and loves him even more. She is Cole's protector and champion and nothing is going to take away her love and commitment to him, regardless of the cost.
It is not a perfect film, there's early signs of Shyamalan being too in love with his ideas and tossing in things that muddy the waters (like "automatic writing" and Cole's "Stuttering Stanley" freakout, which seem to move away from "ghosts" as the root of all the film's weird happenings), but the parts that are there are just really nuanced and top-notch. Any careful rewatches will just note little details that reflect on the film's ending -- even the first time Malcolm comes home to find a bare plate on the table and his wife in bed, as he's standing there, she curls up a little tighter and pulls her shawl a little tighter, as if the temperature had dropped. Even his brief cameo is okay, in that his lines make sense and are very limited. It is a pretty emotionally coherent film and I wish he hadn't let his fame go to his head, where he let his ideas get more grandiose, rather than refining them and keeping his films tighter.
The emotional moments generally land, including the side bits like with the girl ghost Cole finally helps at the film's end. The ghosts are generally handled in an eerie way too. (Like when she grabs his ankle as he passes the bed, then peers out at him with cold dead eyes. Or the boy who obliviously tells Cole to come see his dad's gun, unaware the back of his head has been blown off.)
James Newton Howard's soundtrack is also top-notch. he's talked before about how the music is almost like "another animal in the room" stalking about, as if about to spring. It really pushes the emotional beats up a notch and drives home the ending.
I really like watching how Malcolm builds trust with Cole in the opening parts of the film, by providing him with information about himself, asking him the right questions without prying, respecting him, playing the "mind-reading game," etc. They actually develop a rapport on film, with Malcolm proving he is an adult that can be trusted and then with Cole eventually turning the tables and advising Malcolm / helping HIM heal as well.
How long does Cole know what Malcolm really is? The film shies away from providing a definitive moment. Very obviously in the last scene, which is like Cole's last gift to Malcolm because he knows he won't see his friend again after helping him -- you can see it on his face. There's some ambiguity in the middle of the film, where it could go either way, but in the beginning of the film you could think that Cole knows, by his initial responses to Malcolm at their first few meetings. So I lean towards Cole knowing from the start (resulting in his fear response) which then changes as Malcolm asserts repeatedly his stability and harmlessness to Cole.
Cole led a very conflicted existence. He was a young boy with all the anxieties and fears that come from that, but also gifted with deep empathy and awareness -- so he was also wiser than a lot of adults (including his mom).I always liked the implication that the kid knew what Malcolm didnt and never pushed the issue. Showed maturity in Cole's character.
Yeah, I did like that bit too. The teacher only knows the conventional history back to a certain point, Cole is getting the news from very specific people who actually saw what happened, even if his knowledge is limited to what those ghosts know.The stuttering Stanley thing is weird, but I like the bit preceding this where Cole says "They used to hang people here", and the teacher is like "No, they didn't this was a courthouse, there were judges", and Cole goes "They were the ones that hanged everybody." I don't know if any of this is actually true of that location, but it reminds me of the debates people have about history. In this movie, though, we have a kid who can talk to ghosts and tell you what actually happened.
What about offscreen?The make up and rags are for the humidity, heat, and sun. Same with the ice bucket hat. He mentions it in the movie.
Montgomery goes insane. Its arguable that he and Meraou were insane the whole time, but Montgomery was at least able to seem sane for a chunk of the movie. Montgomery didnt believe in what the good doctor was trying to do, but he helped in exchange for money, drugs, sex and meat. Pretty much the quintessential henchman for a mad scientist.
My only dislike was maybe 2-3 times I think Cage's performance was not as quite restrained as it needed to be to mesh with the rest -- he kinda went to 11 a bit early, although in the ending act, 11 was appropriate. But such a decent cast (including Joely Richardson! And Tommy Chong?!)
Yeah. I mean, you have a piece of visual media, so color has to exist (unless it's gonna B&W it like The Lighthouse). I think the magenta was a good choice to visually stamp it, and I think it is handled very effectively. I love how it's just there with the meteor at first but then starts appearing in the flowers popping up one by one, then other elements, then finally the whole things seems to shade magenta by the end.I made a joke about this movie using magenta for an color that has never been seen before by humans, but this was a good movie. Anyway, I suppose magenta is as good as any, because it's a non-spectral color which means that iT only exists in our minds.
Yeah, I was like dude just chill -- that and 2-3 scenes around it, he just peaked early and it was a bit jarring, and he got that "crazy Cage" twang in his voice that almost drove the film into caricature. The director should have pulled that back a bit.Let me guess, one of those times was Nicolas Cage vs. the tomatoes, right?
I don't think she MEANT to, but I have not read the story to see if that is mentioned in it.I have to wonder about this daughter's witch ritual. Did she somehow summon this thing? Is she tapping into magic that is somehow linked to alien technology? Is this part about witchcraft something in the short story? She also mentions that she wants to leave this place, and she leaves it psychologically at the end of the film.
Before me, Raphael.
Behind me, Gabriel.
To my left...
...Uriel.
And to my right, Michael.
I call upon the principalities of earth, air, fire, water, and ether.
Be present with me now.
Spirit of fire, continue to burn out any trace of cancer from the body of Theresa Gardner, my mother.
Grant me your protection.
Grant me my freedom.
And last, not least, get me out of here.
Such a great ending. I like that the guy named Ward tries to protect them all but fails. He survives, but it haunts him; the water is very deep, but even then "I will not drink it."I was very shocked by where this movie goes. Things get crazy! There was so much tension. It's horrifying to see the disintegration of a family unit like that. The closing narration, accompanied by an ominous implication, actually sent shivers down my spine.
I'm just really enamoured with this film. I'm kinda surprised it ever got made, lol.I also the colors were beautiful. There is the eponymous color, particularly with those beautiful flowers and mantis-like creatures. There is also blue, like the blue of the beam of the flashlights and the clothing on the siblings. Maybe blue is the opposite of the Color Out of Space? It looked beautiful either way. This was an excellent example of pure horror.
I don't think she MEANT to, but I have not read the story to see if that is mentioned in it.
It's Wiccan (she clearly spells it out), not Alexandrian spellcasting.
The irony is that she is not summoning demons, she's calling on archangels.
I never thought she intended it. She wanted to leave but she also wished for good health for the mother. I'm under the impression that many Lovecraft stories involves humans messing with things they don't understand and than unleashing unimaginable horror as a consequence. This would fit with that.According to Rudolf Steiner, four archangels govern the seasons: spring is Raphael, summer is Uriel, autumn is Michael, and winter is Gabriel.
And this is her prayer:
Here is the irony: Michael rules fire; Gabriel, water; Raphael, air; and Uriel, earth.
But she calls upon the principalities of those + ether.
I think Lovecraft referred to the Elder gods as traveling through space via ether?
So maybe it is IRONY rather than INTENT?
I ran CTRL+F on the story, and only saw three mentions of the word witch. So, maybe there's no daughter character in the story who practices witchcraft.That she would ask for these things, that end up being granted by a force of pure chaos that destroys her family?
So maybe you are right in that she unleashed (or at least synced up with) something horrible coming her way.
Anyway, bonus links:
Color Out of Space (2019) - Transcripts - Forever Dreaming
West of Arkham... ...the hills rise wild... ...and there are valleys with deep woods that no ax has ever cut. There are dark, narrow glens where the trees slopetranscripts.foreverdreaming.org"The Colour out of Space" by H. P. Lovecraft
'The Colour out of Space' by H. P. Lovecraftwww.hplovecraft.com
Yeah. It doesn't play it safe or shy away from things at all.Such a great ending. I like that the guy named Ward tries to protect them all but fails. He survives, but it haunts him; the water is very deep, but even then "I will not drink it."
I'm just really enamoured with this film. I'm kinda surprised it ever got made, lol.
I wish we had more info in that article. The only thing we have detail on is info on the initiation process, really.I guess technically Alexandrian is just a subset of Wiccan, one of its many flavors.
Alexandrian Wicca - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org
Yeah, I had noticed that -- that movie seemed to be troubled, from everything I read, but he was so good with this film I feel like I need to watch that at some point too.I just found out the director of the Color Out of Space was the original director of the Marlon Brando Island of Dr. Moreau. There's even a documentary about it. That might be a November watch....
The story is really compelling underneath, I think, and that helps make the movie remain highly watchable despite all the weird and dumb things. I'm going to assume Brando clashed with him (maybe because he made bizarre demands and Stanley wouldn't give in to them) and maybe was responsible for him getting fired. My intuition tells me that every weird thing about Brando's character for this movie was Brando's idea, because he was like that. I don't know why, but that's the way he was.Yeah, I had noticed that -- that movie seemed to be troubled, from everything I read, but he was so good with this film I feel like I need to watch that at some point too.