Members who embody each type

[Jaguar]

8w7= Jaguar

Well done.

 

[Luminous]

Here ive done a list take it with a grain of salt though .

2w3= Mighty Fetus (She hasn't been around a while), Luminous, Cloudpatrol (Shes not around anymore ether).

So/Sp= Frosty, Neal, Virtual

Attachment= Jaq, Neal, Meth
Compliant= Lumi, Geedo,

Sorry, kid, but those are waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay off.

I have so little 3, the idea of me having a w3 is absurd, Neal is NOT sx blind nor that strong on attachment (there's 3 and 9, but I don't see 6), and I also don't see 6 for myself that strongly. Way off.

I would say I very much embody 9w1 sx/sp. And rejection triad (you got that one right). If you can't see that, it's because you aren't looking at my motivations, but rather my behavior.
And Neal embodies so/sx and positive triad (you got that one right too).

 

[Saturnal Snowqueen]

9w1 - [MENTION=30122]Lord Lavender[/MENTION]

More! More!

 

[Lord Lavender]

Sorry, kid, but those are waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay off.

I have so little 3, the idea of me having a w3 is absurd, Neal is NOT sx blind nor that strong on attachment (there's 3 and 9, but I don't see 6), and I also don't see 6 for myself that strongly. Way off.

I would say I very much embody 9w1 sx/sp. And rejection triad (you got that one right). If you can't see that, it's because you aren't looking at my motivations, but rather my behavior.
And Neal embodies so/sx and positive triad (you got that one right too).

As I said take my observations with a grain of salt obviously I don't know you as well as you know yourself. I get the feeling you don't want to be a 2w3 , I could write a paragraph on why you are 2 (Preferbly else where lets not clog this thread up with debate and blocks of text) if you are curious tbh I don't think you are 9 fixed I think you are 1 fixed. You have a history of getting defensive when people type you as a 2. Maybe look inward and ask yourself why you get defensive when folks type you as as 2 I am not innocent of disliking certain typing's but I try to not get my pink fur all rustled . You seem to want folks to see you as a 9 for some reason. But then I am just a random little purple kitty cat watching folks from my tree branch not Carl Jung himself and I cannot know the mysterious of the Luminous brain only she can for we are all mad here.

 

[Red Memories]

1w9= Virtual Ghost for sure.
1w2= me. XD honestly, Hard/Isoprene is a pretty good example too. we just have very different 1w2 values. XD
2w1= Geedo
2w3= ...I wanna joke and throw Lord Lavendar here so I'm gonna cuz this was one of my original assessments of him. XD
4w5= Powehi, Peter Deadpan
5w4= Everin
5w6= Coriolis.
6w5= Highlander 10/10, Radical Doubt
7w6= Burner yo
7w8= Masokissed
8w7= Yuu, Chickpea, Jaguar
8w9= CeeCee
9w8= prpl, Hive
9w1= Hermit, LL.

*runs*

 

[Kingu Kurimuzon]

ENTJ 1w2: [MENTION=13112]Justin Trudeau[/MENTION]
ISTJ 8w7: [MENTION=29687]Frosty[/MENTION]
ESFP 6w5: [MENTION=38618]Saturnal Snowqueen[/MENTION]
INTP 3w2: [MENTION=23222]senza tema[/MENTION]
INFJ 9w8: [MENTION=9913]captain curmudgeon[/MENTION]
ISTP 2w1: [MENTION=19700]Tactical Turtleneck[/MENTION]
ESTJ 7w6: [MENTION=7991]chickpea[/MENTION]
ESTP 9w1: [MENTION=9811]Corvus[/MENTION]
ISFJ 1w9: [MENTION=195]Jaguar[/MENTION]

Is this a joke?

 

[Luminous]

As I said take my observations with a grain of salt obviously I don't know you as well as you know yourself. I get the feeling you don't want to be a 2w3 , I could write a paragraph on why you are 2 (Preferbly else where lets not clog this thread up with debate and blocks of text) if you are curious tbh I don't think you are 9 fixed I think you are 1 fixed. You have a history of getting defensive when people type you as a 2. Maybe look inward and ask yourself why you get defensive when folks type you as as 2 I am not innocent of disliking certain typing's but I try to not get my pink fur all rustled . You seem to want folks to see you as a 9 for some reason. But then I am just a random little purple kitty cat watching folks from my tree branch not Carl Jung himself and I cannot know the mysterious of the Luminous brain only she can for we are all mad here.

Indeed, I actually know my own motivations far better than you.

And I don't care to debate or even discuss it with you. I don't think you have enough in-depth knowledge of the system or of me. Only superficial observations based on things you don't know about and can't see the hidden meat of (because it is hidden from your view and I have no interest in exposing it here at all.)

And Jung didn't do the enneagram.

 

[Kingu Kurimuzon]

I’m still confused how anyone sees me as a 5, or a 2, for that matter. I could see a case being made for 6w5 or 1w9 though

 

[Hive]

Is this a joke?

I assure you that I am serious.

 

[Kingu Kurimuzon]

I assure you that I am serious.

The IxxP, you’re probably correct on. 2 though?

Most people typing me as such, I’d just assume they didn’t know their shit, but I know you know your shit and didn’t just come up with that on a whim

 

[Red Memories]

Indeed, I actually know my own motivations far better than you. And I don't care to debate or even discuss it with you. I don't think you have enough in-depth knowledge of the system or of me. Only superficial observations based on things you don't know about and can't see the hidden meat of (because it is hidden from your view and I have no interest in exposing it here at all.) And Jung didn't do the enneagram.

I mean...Cat is quite knowledgeable about these systems and enjoys studying them. Typings from others vs. self typing can be very different things and allow for an opportunity to see all kinds of things. An odd typing choice from someone else isn't some insult. Insulting his intelligence doesn't make you change his perception. You're being needlessly hostile about a thread that's meant in good fun.

 

[miss deceit]

Ok, so I want to chime in here with something that may benefit everyone here:

The issue I have with telling people their enneagram is that it's strongly connected to motivations and childhood. It's A) More explicitly saying "I know you better than you know yourself" and B) It's essentially invalidating any childhood trauma or whatever that person may have. So if someone is saying they are motivated a certain way because of things that have happened to them in childhood and then someone comes in like "well actually you vibe like a 4 hehe" or whatever it's incredibly disrespectful.

Not only that but there seems to be a disconnect with some people viewing it as a bit of fun and some people taking it more seriously (likely due to reasons I've stated above), neither side is really wrong or right in that case but I think it may be useful to exercise some caution over something like enneagram that may be strongly connected to childhood.

 

[Kingu Kurimuzon]

I mean...Cat is quite knowledgeable about these systems and enjoys studying them. Typings from others vs. self typing can be very different things and allow for an opportunity to see all kinds of things. An odd typing choice from someone else isn't some insult. Insulting his intelligence doesn't make you change his perception. You're being needlessly hostile about a thread that's meant in good fun.

I like getting odd typings. It forces me to take a hard look at myself. Even when they type me SJ and 2

 

[Kingu Kurimuzon]

Ok, so I want to chime in here with something that may benefit everyone here:

The issue I have with telling people their enneagram is that it's strongly connected to motivations and childhood. It's A) More explicitly saying "I know you better than you know yourself" and B) It's essentially invalidating any childhood trauma or whatever that person may have. So if someone is saying they are motivated a certain way because of things that have happened to them in childhood and then someone comes in like "well actually you vibe like a 4 hehe" or whatever it's incredibly disrespectful.

Not only that but there seems to be a disconnect with some people viewing it as a bit of fun and some people taking it more seriously (likely due to reasons I've stated above), neither side is really wrong or right in that case but I think it may be useful to exercise some caution over something like enneagram that may be strongly connected to childhood.

I love you

 

[Red Memories]

Ok, so I want to chime in here with something that may benefit everyone here: The issue I have with telling people their enneagram is that it's strongly connected to motivations and childhood. It's A) More explicitly saying "I know you better than you know yourself" and B) It's essentially invalidating any childhood trauma or whatever that person may have. So if someone is saying they are motivated a certain way because of things that have happened to them in childhood and then someone comes in like "well actually you vibe like a 4 hehe" or whatever it's incredibly disrespectful. Not only that but there seems to be a disconnect with some people viewing it as a bit of fun and some people taking it more seriously (likely due to reasons I've stated above), neither side is really wrong or right in that case but I think it may be useful to exercise some caution over something like enneagram that may be strongly connected to childhood.

Well for one, any typing could be perceived in the way you suggest. If you dislike the way a person typed you, you are welcome to ignore it or gently refute it. I usually ask why rather than get angry. I've had many type me xxFJ which is not my self typing. I have many call me an E4 or E6 without suggesting someone who thinks different than I do does not know typology theories well.
Enneagram can be connected to childhood so I see that point, and it would seem very obvious your self typing is likely stronger than a random person on a threads typing. What is the point in feeling hostile and belittling someone's intellect on the subject? He thinks I'm an ENFJ and I disagree but he's also a good guy who doesn't deserve to be treated like garbage by someone over a damn typing.

 

[cascadeco]

I'm willing to bet half the forum would type me differently - that's the nature of the systems as practiced on a site like this. Pretty subjective and tied to the approach each person decides to use.

Someone who used to be on here who was pretty knowledgeable on enneagram typed me as an intj 1, but 1's on here stated I couldn't possibly be a 1 when I posed inquiries on it. Similarly, a long time ago someone knowledgeable on both systems video typed me as an intp e5. . I was video typed a long time ago too as a repressed enfp by someone really into facial tics and their supposed ties to functions, and have also been typed as isfj. I think there can be 'truth' in individual perceptions even if it doesn't jive with our self perception. I am someone who thinks behavior is just as important and telling in psychology as motivation . That said, I've been at the opposite end where I have been pigeon holed for years under an umbrella that wasn't actually me/my motivations, so I understand that as well.

 

[Kingu Kurimuzon]

It depends on who is giving the odd typing and also the context. When [MENTION=11809]Hive[/MENTION] says I’m a 2, for example, I might disagree, but I’m going to be curious to understand why because I know he isn’t someone to just casually dole out typings based on a vibe. Vibe typings don’t really bug me in fluffier threads.

But on the other hand, someone just decides to say something along the lines of “this is why you are X type”, say, in the middle of a heated political thread, then I have to question their motives and sincerity. This has happened to me before, and those who did this, you know what you were doing.

 

[miss deceit]

Well for one, any typing could be perceived in the way you suggest. If you dislike the way a person typed you, you are welcome to ignore it or gently refute it. I usually ask why rather than get angry. I've had many type me xxFJ which is not my self typing. I have many call me an E4 or E6 without suggesting someone who thinks different than I do does not know typology theories well.
Enneagram can be connected to childhood so I see that point, and it would seem very obvious your self typing is likely stronger than a random person on a threads typing. What is the point in feeling hostile and belittling someone's intellect on the subject? He thinks I'm an ENFJ and I disagree but he's also a good guy who doesn't deserve to be treated like garbage by someone over a damn typing.

Sure, but you don't know what a person has gone through that is causing them to react the way they do. Could it have been handled better? Yes. But just because you don't feel hostile doesn't mean others don't. To some people it's more than a "damn typing".

The reason I bring this up in connection to enneagram is because the connection to childhood trauma is often a lot stronger and deeper. Functions can have that connection sure, but it often doesn't and the connection is usually a lot less emotionally impactful (especially since a lot would argue type is somewhat genetic whereas enneagram comes from childhood responses, so the connection is easy to see there).

 

[Population: 1]

There’s hardly in-depth ego shattering psychoanalysis occurring in this thread. It’s supposed to be a thread to speculate about people’s enneagram types- for fun. Remember fun? If people can’t make basic level observations about others maybe this place should just blatantly become the political forum it so desperately wants to be.

 

[miss deceit]

There’s hardly in-depth ego shattering psychoanalysis occurring in this thread. It’s supposed to be a thread to speculate about people’s enneagram types- for fun. Remember fun? If people can’t make basic level observations about others maybe this place should just blatantly become the political forum it so desperately wants to be.

I think there's certainly a point to be made here about it being a fun thread and I'd agree that it's going to happen due to the nature of typology forums, but at the same time wouldn't you say that by telling someone they are a different type it naturally opens the gate for a defensive response from people who do take it more seriously? Because by virtue of it being a typology forum there are always going to be people in both camps so I think it's probably more beneficial to understand where both sides are coming from.