I consistently test ISTJ, trying to be as honest as I can on any given test (including one like 10 minutes ago). I've tested a dozen times and it's always ISTJ.
*I dislike conformity. It bothers me.
*I hate stupid rules
*I'm irritated by people who follow and enforce stupid rules and that think everyone should be/act a certain way
*I can be pretty lazy and un-dutiful. If I can't see a direct, positive result in completing a given task, I probably won't do it or I'll slack at it - meaning, I don't preoccupy myself with work and busyness just for the sake of being busy.
*I'm not a clean-freak... But I'm not a pig.
*I'm not overly concerned about upholding traditions or at least to the 'T', in fact, a lot of the time, I think it's a little cheesy.
*I don't use spreadsheets, or a day-timer, or really notes at all for that matter.
What am I? Just a fucked up ISTJ?
Maybe you're not an ISTJ after all. When you first came here, you thought you were INFJ, and I told you that you probably weren't. Maybe you didn't have to go all the way to ISTJ... should have just stopped at INTJ?
Anyway... I agree with most of what you said, though I'm obviously not an SJ. Only ones I disagree with are the bolded ones. For instance, I don't dislike conformity unless it's pushed on people in some way. Otherwise, it's just one choice out of several valid ones.
Also, I'll do any task I don't have a serious moral problem with, given to me by someone above me, even if it doesn't make much sense to me. Though I don't usually go around looking for something to keep me busy if it isn't assigned to me, and will relax at that point.
I occasionally use spreadsheets when working out something like paying bills or putting together a project that costs money, but not that often. I tried taking notes, but usually the act of writing them down helped more than going over them later, and I usually had a good enough memory that the notes weren't needed anyway.
I don't use day planners, but then again, I've never had enough on my plate in a single week or month to actually justify bothering with that level of organization. My life has been simple enough that I haven't had to worry about it.