Totenkindly
@.~*virinaĉo*~.@
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2007
- Messages
- 50,434
- MBTI Type
- BELF
- Enneagram
- 594
- Instinctual Variant
- sx/sp
Blew through Season 1 of Alice in Borderland so I could push into Season 2. Started that late last night and I'm already 3 episodes in, it's pretty engrossing although I found the opener a little disturbing. (Too much graphic gun violence, not as much nuance.)
Episodes 2&3 were back on track, and Episode 3 is really the emotional kicker so far this season, as Episode 3 in Season 1 also was.
I'm not quite sure why, but I keep being reminded of Lost in some ways. Puzzle box mysteries (on figuring out the games), regular leaps into flashbackstories although not spending nearly as much time as Lost did on them, but there's an emotional core/catharsis based on backstories for characters buttresses by music that reminds me of Giacchino's approach -- beautiful swelling music (lots of strings) to emphasize emotional depth leading to almost overwhelming emotion at certain climaxes of plot... because these most powerful plot points are not necessarily plot resolutions but character growth resolutions. It's also reminding me a lot of Mac Quayle's music for Mr. Robot -- at times riveting, other times excruciatingly poignant and bittersweet, so your heart almost bursts when hearing it. One can never downplay the contribution of music to a show or film, it can complete change the context of a scene especially when it plays against what might be the expected reading.
As someone who watches foreign shows and films, I would say to never watch English dubs, which are hit and miss -- it's original dialogue + subtitles all the way. In this case, the dubs might also not be trustworthy. Back in S1E3 for example, there's an example of where they dubbed a line differently in order to avoid offense to the English audience, but it totally changes the context of the scene; if you read the subtitles, you actually better understand the character talking. It in fact screws up the morality of the other characters a bit too. Totally horrible line dub.
The show is also interesting if you can draw counterparts between the cast and Alice in Wonderland characters. I think the most obvious are these ones, although there could be others... and of course, I know the Queen of Hearts / Red Queen plays a big role at the end of Season 2:
Episodes 2&3 were back on track, and Episode 3 is really the emotional kicker so far this season, as Episode 3 in Season 1 also was.
I'm not quite sure why, but I keep being reminded of Lost in some ways. Puzzle box mysteries (on figuring out the games), regular leaps into flashbackstories although not spending nearly as much time as Lost did on them, but there's an emotional core/catharsis based on backstories for characters buttresses by music that reminds me of Giacchino's approach -- beautiful swelling music (lots of strings) to emphasize emotional depth leading to almost overwhelming emotion at certain climaxes of plot... because these most powerful plot points are not necessarily plot resolutions but character growth resolutions. It's also reminding me a lot of Mac Quayle's music for Mr. Robot -- at times riveting, other times excruciatingly poignant and bittersweet, so your heart almost bursts when hearing it. One can never downplay the contribution of music to a show or film, it can complete change the context of a scene especially when it plays against what might be the expected reading.
As someone who watches foreign shows and films, I would say to never watch English dubs, which are hit and miss -- it's original dialogue + subtitles all the way. In this case, the dubs might also not be trustworthy. Back in S1E3 for example, there's an example of where they dubbed a line differently in order to avoid offense to the English audience, but it totally changes the context of the scene; if you read the subtitles, you actually better understand the character talking. It in fact screws up the morality of the other characters a bit too. Totally horrible line dub.
The show is also interesting if you can draw counterparts between the cast and Alice in Wonderland characters. I think the most obvious are these ones, although there could be others... and of course, I know the Queen of Hearts / Red Queen plays a big role at the end of Season 2:
- Arisu - He is Alice, kind of daydreamy and floating along, and the show seems bent on teaching him how to engage reality and actually being a leader of some kind, not just a smart guy.
- Usagi - This literally means rabbit or hare in Japanese, she is clearly the White Rabbit -- small and fast and a runner/escaper type (and very smart on how to evade people) in her role. She's also the closest to Arisu as the plot develops.
- Chishiya - The Cheshire Cat, obviously. He's smart, a laconic observer who sits back to get a sense of what is unfolding, and uses his brain (along with occasional deliberate actions) to survive. he usually seems above everything, keeps his own counsel, and you can tell he's piecing it altogether. He's morally neutral, vs Arisu who would be a "good" character, and remains pretty detached -- and often will throw something chaotic into the mix just to trigger people revealing their intentions so he better understands a situation.
- Kuina - To break her smoking habit, she's been chewing on lollipops a lot of the time, similar to the hookah pipe used by the Caterpillar. But more importantly, she is a character with a major transformation in her past, with the symbol of the butterfly/caterpillar attached to such things. So I think that latter bit even more cements her in that role.
- Mad Hatter - One of the antagonists in Season 1, who is in charge of the Beach but has slowly been growing paranoid/mad.
Last edited: