ygolo
My termites win
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2007
- Messages
- 6,731
The use of IQ tests is an entirely seperate issue than how accurate they are. One reason I'm not arguing this, besides time, is that I don't agree with how IQ tests are used. That, and there are quite a few problems IQ tests even for research purposes.
I'm of the same opinion on personality tests, however. I think every flaw with IQ tests can be reflected with personality tests... often to a worse degree. That puts it in perspective to me... These tests are good for research, for understanding people... but life is complex and tests simple.
(Again, though, I'd say the same for the ACT or SAT tests... there has to be some level of testing, however unfair... I'm just not able to draw the line.)
I think we may have been in much more agreement than I thought, all along. Just like as in personality theories (and I agree there is less cause to believe these than IQ) where we don't want to create pigeon-holes and stereotypes usigng OCEAN or MBTI, we don't want to create pigeon-holes for IQ quartiles (percentiles, whatever). In the end, human will is too strong and chaotic a variable (pragmatically speaking, even if the is no real "Free Will").