That guy needs to go off the Red Bull Latte speeders.
For some reason, I buy that Amazing Atheist and Jenna Marbles are the type of people they portray themselves to be in their vids; this guy is more a poser.
SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This douche thinks there is a continuity error between Space Seed and STID.
A continuity error over 40 years time? Real time? And different shows?
Geesh, the effort some people will go to.
Uhhh.... I agree that it's a silly issue -- it's not really central to the story, it's a "casting difference" IMO that you just accept as a part of the actor change, just like you accept that this Carol Marcus has an accent (although her dad doesn't... hilarious).
However if you watch the vid, the guy really didn't put much"effort" in that, he was just pointing it out and didn't seem to really care about it (it was a throwaway criticism made as part of his "shtick"), so I'm not sure why you're making him out to be some anal retentive fanboy. He's not the type of geek you're alluding to. Did you watch the whole clip? He's a lot more surface-oriented/casual, not anal.
His Kirk and Weller impressions were decent enough, the others not as much. he also wasn't really bothered by them cribbing the best moments from WoK, although he commented on Spock's line and how it didn't work as well -- the reality is that it was entirely forced and didn't feel organic, which is WHY it didn't work as well, and then just kind of made a mockery of the power of the original.