Mal12345
Permabanned
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2011
- Messages
- 14,532
- MBTI Type
- IxTP
- Enneagram
- 5w4
- Instinctual Variant
- sx/sp
Bullshit.
Si.
Bullshit.
Si
Se
Si
si
se
se
Si
Si
Se
Si.
Si..if it exists.... I see as being associated with recognition of sensory patterns. This also, as I understand it, applies to internal senses. Like "gut feelings." The beard statement is a perceived pattern.
Side note: Why do people have such an issue with multiple choice? Pet peeve of mine whenever someone asks a question with only a few clearly defined answers, and then they put in their own answers. That's not really answering the question, it's dodging it.
Which of the following represent Se and which represent Si?
1. I like to imagine shapes of things in clouds.
2. How should I wear my hair today?
3. I often find myself battling my inner demons.
4. People who have beards are hiding something.
5. The people next door have no common sense.
6. You're such an angel!
7. I have unusual feelings that I can only express
through the world around me.
8. I enjoy looking for the man in the moon.
9. There is much beauty in ugliness.
10. I had a feeling something bad was going to happen.
Which of the following represent Se and which represent Si?
1. I like to imagine shapes of things in clouds.
2. How should I wear my hair today?
3. I often find myself battling my inner demons.
4. People who have beards are hiding something.
5. The people next door have no common sense.
6. You're such an angel!
7. I have unusual feelings that I can only express through the world around me.
8. I enjoy looking for the man in the moon.
9. There is much beauty in ugliness.
10. I had a feeling something bad was going to happen.
I'm looking at Si and Se purely, and then applying them to the ten statements.
I would treat them both as Dominant by default.
Thank you for illustrating you still don't know what Si is.
Could be said by any human being.
Could be said by any human being.
Could be said by any human being.
Could be said by any human being.
Could be said by any human being.
Metaphor. Could be said by any human being.
Could be said by any human being.
Could be said by any human being.
Could be said by any human being.
Could be said by any human being.
No, you're not.
When any human being makes a comment, you have no idea if it's coming from conscious thought, unconscious reaction, a mixture of unconscious and conscious elements, the parroting of another person's thoughts they have adopted for their own use, something a person has learned, or any other possibility I haven't mentioned. For someone to think they know what is purely derived from conscious thought, alone, then subsequently assigning Si and Se to it, and even worse, placing it in the dominant position which automatically assumes everything coming out of someone's mouth is 100% conscious, renders the understanding of the human psyche at about the same level of a 2-year-old child's understanding of a random Shakespearean sonnet.
I'll play along, take my stab in the dark [without looking at the previous attempt
1. I like to imagine shapes of things in clouds.
Se...because it has to do with physical experience in the outside world.
2. How should I wear my hair today?
Se, because Se dominants usually are concerned, at least to some degree, about physical appearance. Se is my weakest, inferior, function and I a concerned about my physical appearance. I like to look good and I won't even deny it
3. I often find myself battling my inner demons.
Si, because a lot of inner demons come through the "little" stuff that inwardly nags at people everyday and because they're inner demons, not outer ones.
4. People who have beards are hiding something.
Probably Si. I have no real good reason, other than I have heard a lot of ISTJs make similar statements [not about beards, but about shifty eyes or bandanas or tattoos or low brow bones, those types of things.]
5. The people next door have no common sense.
Si? Maybe the people next door are Se and they've been hang gliding off the water tower or maybe they don't cut their grass on a regular schedule or maybe they keep racing their lawn mowers in the middle of the night.
6. You're such an angel!
Si? Sounds like something my coworkers would say.
7. I have unusual feelings that I can only express
through the world around me.
Se, just before he/she hops on a motorcycle and goes off to experience the "world" in their own way.
8. I enjoy looking for the man in the moon.
Si? Haha...I'm guessing. Seriously, I can't believe anyone would look for the man in the moon.
9. There is much beauty in ugliness.
Se, how else could an ESTP pull an old wrecked car out of the salvage yard and remake it into a work of automotive art?
10. I had a feeling something bad was going to happen.
Si, because I work with lots of Si-dominants and they say that all of the time.
You got 90% right!
TRANSLATION: [MENTION=195]Jaguar[/MENTION] has no clue as to the difference between pure and applied typology.
What Sky said, except for question number 6 and 8.
Translation: [MENTION=13589]Mal12345[/MENTION] has no clue what the definitions of Se and Si are.
Sure I do. Si is your memory, and Se is watching the world around you. Right?
Fucking hopeless.
You also scored 90%.
So did I get 80, or 100?