I've tried that. Doesn't work. Because they don't reciprocate the gesture.
For that to be true, there's got to be some kind of exceptional circumstances going on there, cos I guarantee you, if you're frank and open with anything but the most unhealthy of ENTP's, they
will reciprocate the gesture.
Could it be that you're not being actually direct, but just what counts as directness for you? I mean no offense, but I've known Fe types to be very "beat around the bush" and leaving things to be implied or whatever, not really saying anything definite or explicit, and then later claiming to have told me "explicitly"... and also I've known Fe types to take what is actually my attempts at openness and directness as "being mean" or personal criticisms, at which point they switch off and don't listen. I've had it so many, many times where I've been very carefully choosing my words to say exactly what I mean and no more or less, and yet the FJ seems to insist on "reading between the lines", mostly inaccurately.
Example:
INFJ: So I was thinking, perhaps it might be an idea if we do X instead of Y?
(subtitles: I really hate doing Y and it upsets me a lot, it'd mean a lot to me if we could do X instead because with all the problems I'm having at home at the mo I could do without the stress)
ENTP: Well, whyever do that? Y seems to be working so let's stick with it
(subtitles: why would you want to switch from something efficient to something less efficient? it just doesn't make sense, but if you have a reason then I'm listening...? Thinking: we're just talking about X and Y here, aren't we?)
INFJ: Well I don't really mind, it's up to you, but I'd rather do X
(subtitles: I know it's slightly less efficient but in doing X I have to deal with a person who's always rude and unpleasant to me and it really upsets me to deal with that every day. Thinking: you're just dismissing my suggestion because you think it's crap and you don't take me seriously)
ENTP: Well if you don't mind then I'd like to continue doing Y for the time being, unless there's a good reason to change, as it's more efficient for these reasons.... I mean if you're having trouble with getting the hang of Y then just say and I can run you through it again...?
INFJ: Well ok then, no it's alright, we'll stick with Y if that's what makes you happy.
(thinks: oh great, now he thinks I'm stupid! he just doesn't give a shit how I feel does he? he doesn't think my feelings are a "good reason" for anything! I've tried to tell him my problem and he's just been critical and mean in return! It's nothing to do with Y or X or what's more efficient, it's about me being happy with my work and not adding to my stress load!)
ENTP: Well it's not about making me happy, I'm just thinking this gets the job done quicker...
(thinks: oh hang on, she used the H word - is this not about the job in fact??) But if there's a problem for you with this, I mean we could easily switch to X I suppose and give it a go for a bit....?
INFJ: No, no, it's alright, I'll muddle through.
(thinks: that's right you asshole, all you care about is getting the work done, you don't care who it hurts in the process do you?)
ENTP: Well, if you're sure? Just let me know if there's any problems...
(thinks: shit, it was about something bothering her, but now she's gone into martyr mode and won't tell me anyway!)
That seem familiar to anyone?
