Nocapszy
no clinkz 'til brooklyn
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2007
- Messages
- 4,517
- MBTI Type
- ENTP
Well there's the problem. Typology doesn't employ opinion.Hmmm....
In my opinion:
Te nitpicks too. Nitpicks for different reasons, but they're still the same mechanism.Analysis - Ti (deconstructor). Yeah, the nitpicking function.
Synthesis - Te
You're right to point to the perceiving function. Having a good strong idea of what's happening in the _whatever is to be criticized_ gives INTP the upper hand in analysis, hence criticism.In my opinion, INTPs could be better critics than the TJ because of the former's flexible P function which needs to be adaptive in criticizing various forms of art (film, etc.) or system. Not everything should be judged the same.
True. Again though, you're referencing the perceiving function. Their ideal impression of what should be happening is the only criteria they use in criticism.TJs tend to apply a universal objective elaborate guideline to everything.
It's why often E_TJs appear to be less logical, and more arbitrary in their analysis, than even E_TPs despite being logic dominant, and that Te is just as good an analyzer as the introverted version of itself.