Blew through the last 5 episodes of Season 2 The Last of Us this past weekend.
I have a lot I could say. I think most of the arguments about it must result from disparities between the game plot/characterization vs the show, because if you don't have any game knowledge, I think the show is kind of remarkable and pretty morally complicated and viscerally gruesome at times. It looks like large portions of it match up, so I don't quite get the fan squabbles occurring. I suspect the game Ellie is a bit different in the show Ellie simply because it's Bella (who is autistic) playing her, but Bella is just nailing this role -- I think she is just doing it differently than expected. I think she's colder/flatter than game Ellie, but in the moments she has to break and show strong emotion, she just totally nails it. It gives more of a sense she feels things very deeply but often hides behind a belligerent / indifferent attitude.
(I will take a moment to say the closest I can guess is the disparity between book Katniss and film Katniss from The Hunger Games -- Jennifer Lawrence is far too likeable and emotive to reflect the book Katniss, who is kind of unlikeable and distant from everyone, SO internalized emotionally, but the two different mediums kind of demanded a more engaging Katniss since you aren't being told what's in her head all the time but you have to have Lawrence emote it somehow. I think both versions work, but they are notably different.)
The show also benefits from casting experienced actors in smaller roles. I won't list them all there, but these are people who can take a few minutes and totally nail a character by pure acting skill rather than a long narrative build-up or a lot of script. Some really well-known faces in here who I didn't realize were in the season. I will say that Catharine o'Hara is perfect for a new character added to the story, she's just so great.
The show hasn't really gone in the directions I had expected, but another thing I appreciate is how characters aren't "dumb" in order to further the plot. I think Jesse in S2E7 is an example of that. A lesser show has people be oblivious to things to allow a plotline to go in a desired direction, whereas Jesse is decently aware.
The production values are excellent. When e6 dropped, it could be labeled fan service in a way (because fans really wanted this), but it also is organic and feels natural and provides a lot more depth to past events. Just a really wonderful episode. There's also a lot of intense and terrifying moments.
I think in this sense TLoU has benefited from being tightly scripted and having a less meandering plot. Nothing feels extra. It's not like TWD, which often felt meandering and repetitive because they were trying to pad out 20+ episode seasons for network TV, yet then again the comic book was rather meandering as well. There was a show that needed to be a LOT tighter to remain effective. TLoU isn't having that issue. The content all matters.