• You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to additional post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), view blogs, respond to polls, upload content, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free, so please join our community today! Just click here to register. You should turn your Ad Blocker off for this site or certain features may not work properly. If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us by clicking here.

Jung and Big 5 Comparison Test (requires free registration)

Kephalos

J.M.P.P. R.I.P. B5: RLOAI
Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Messages
554
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
5w4
Link:

Personality Assessor | Jungian Personality Type Test

Summary "Jung and Big 5":

Jungian extraversion (vs. introversion) primarily taps how sociable you are. Big Five extraversion is a broader concept that includes how active and energetic you are, how much risk you like to take, and how many positive emotions you usually feel.

Jungian intuiting (vs. sensing) taps how creative and imaginative you are. Big Five openness is a broader concept that includes creativity and imagination, but also taps your desires for variety and to have new experiences.

Jungian feeling (vs. thinking) overlaps least well with the Big Five model. People high in Jungian feeling are tenderhearted, which overlaps with Big Five agreeableness. People high in Jungian feeling are also thin-skinned and easily hurt, which is included in Big Five neuroticism. People high in Jungian feeling are reflective and driven by emotions, and this sort of emotionality is a part of Big Five openness.

Jungian judging is extremely similar to Big Five conscientiousness.

View attachment Your Results.pdf
 

Vendrah

Never-retiring Millenial
Joined
Mar 26, 2017
Messages
1,852
MBTI Type
NP
Enneagram
952
It is not true that this website requires registration to show up the results.
It requires registration to save the results, but you can simply press ctrl + P and print as a PDF. I had just pressed print screen in part of the page.

I found this test cool, and my case is pretty interesting: I had managed to get Extrovert in "Jung" and Introvert in Big 5.
Although I am kind of familiar with the systems, I swear I havent done on purpose.

4RVmaKT.png


RGPdrsi.png


My usual Big 5 test results is similar to the website and (Extraversion is a little bit lower than usual, I usually have 20th-35th; Neuroticism is lower than usual but yesterday I had a great day), besides E/I, I understand the differences (the difference on N/S to Openness is that I have quite low Artistic Interests, and Im also middle on facet Liberalism but I dont think that is featured on this one; I am like a SJ when it comes to art).

For those who dont know, Agreeableness connection with Feeling and Thinking is low, I have seen some Feelers with low Agreeableness and quite a few Ts with 60-70th on Agreeableness. Neuroticism is either independent of F/T or relates to Feeling very weakly in some researches. Openness to Experience has the facet emotionality, but also has the facet Intellect that counters emotionality on Thinking/Feeling department.

Another interesting thing is them using percentile in MBTI, I like that hehehehehehheeh but, a person who is 60th percentile on intuition should get sensor in test results. I am also middle on T/F, but most people on world are Thinkers by 5% (I guess their sample follows that?), so I know I am a feeler in terms of percentile, although Thinking or Feeling on dichotomy depends on day and test for me.

I also think that they used the term Jung to avoid citing MBTI, because they do want to pass that impression that Big Five is superior (which is not, they are equal even in terms of statistics, and you dont need to be indoctrinated into one OR the other). This test seems to not do much with cognitive functions (Jung typology does) and instead focus on dichotomies. Just because Big 5 does not combines it dichotomies to form types doesnt make them superior to MBTI, that is a very fragile argument.

EDIT: [MENTION=39780]noname3788[/MENTION], should give it a try.
 

noname3788

Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2019
Messages
155
MBTI Type
INFP
Enneagram
4w3
Instinctual Variant
sp/so
[MENTION=32874]Vendrah[/MENTION] too lazy for screenshots today:



no idea why my extroversion scores are that inflated... wth is going on.
 

Luminous

༻✧✧༺
Joined
Oct 25, 2017
Messages
9,853
MBTI Type
Iᑎᖴᑭ
Enneagram
952
Instinctual Variant
sx/sp
I took this awhile back.

INFJ


Your "Type" as Traits
Extraversion - 8th percentile - extremely low
Introversion and Extraversion are just opposite ends of a single spectrum. You are extremely low in extraversion—which equivalently means that you are extremely high in introversion.

Intuiting - 68th percentile - high
Like introversion and extraversion, Sensing and iNtuiting are just opposite ends of a single spectrum. You are high in intuiting—which equivalently means that you are low in sensing.

Feeling vs. Thinking - 92nd percentile - extremely high
Feeling - 95th percentile - extremely high
Thinking - 32nd percentile - low
Thinking and Feeling aren't necessarily opposite of each other. However, Jungian personality type tests tend to pit them as opposites against each other. Within this framework, you are extremely high in feeling vs. thinking. Splitting thinking and feeling into separate components, you are extremely high in feeling and low in thinking.

Judging - 57th percentile - about average
Perceiving and Judging are just opposite ends of a single spectrum. You are about average in judging—which equivalently means that you are about average in perceiving.

Your Big Five Traits
Extraversion - 21st percentile - very low
You are very low in extraversion. People high in extraversion are sociable, active, and like to take risks. They also tend to feel many positive emotions. People low in extraversion (introverts) prefer time alone, are more risk-averse, and may feel fewer positive emotions.

Agreeableness - 87th percentile - very high
You are very high in agreeableness. People high in agreeableness are kind and considerate and strongly motivated to maintain positive relationships. People low in agreeableness are more likely to prefer competition over cooperation and to dislike giving and receiving favors.

Conscientiousness - 63rd percentile - high
You are high in conscientiousness. People high in conscientiousness are hardworking, orderly, organized, and punctual. People low in conscientiousness are more spontaneous and less structured.

Neuroticism - 86th percentile - very high
You are very high in neuroticism. People high in neuroticism tend to feel a lot of negative emotions, like anger, sadness, or anxiety. People low in neuroticism tend to be more stoic.

Openness - 64th percentile - high
You are high in openness. People high in openness like to try new foods, visit new cities, have new experiences, have intellectual discussions, and reflect on their experiences. People low in openness tend to be more conservative and prefer routine. They are more comfortable with familiar surroundings.

Extraversion
Jungian E vs. I - 8th percentile - extremely low
Big Five Extraversion - 21st percentile - very low
Jungian extraversion (vs. introversion) primarily taps how sociable you are. Big Five extraversion is a broader concept that includes how active and energetic you are, how much risk you like to take, and how many positive emotions you usually feel.

Intuiting
Jungian N vs. S - 68th percentile - high
Big Five Openness - 64th percentile - high
Jungian intuiting (vs. sensing) taps how creative and imaginative you are. Big Five openness is a broader concept that includes creativity and imagination, but also taps your desires for variety and to have new experiences.

Feeling
Jungian F vs. T - 92nd percentile - extremely high
Big Five Agreeableness - 87th percentile - very high
Big Five Neuroticism - 86th percentile - very high
Big Five Openness - 64th percentile - high
Jungian feeling (vs. thinking) overlaps least well with the Big Five model. People high in Jungian feeling are tenderhearted, which overlaps with Big Five agreeableness. People high in Jungian feeling are also thin-skinned and easily hurt, which is included in Big Five neuroticism. People high in Jungian feeling are reflective and driven by emotions, and this sort of emotionality is a part of Big Five openness.

Judging
Jungian J vs. P - 57th percentile - about average
Big Five Conscientiousness - 63rd percentile - high
Jungian judging is extremely similar to Big Five conscientiousness.
 

Koto

Active member
Joined
May 22, 2021
Messages
301
Doesn't look like it's been mentioned yet, but not all is as it seems with the MBTI descriptions; make sure and read it all carefully when you get your results.
 

RadicalDoubt

Alongside Questionable Clarity
Joined
Jun 27, 2017
Messages
1,847
MBTI Type
TiSi
Enneagram
9w1
Instinctual Variant
sp/so
It gave me INTP (I was initially quite shocked by the description lmfao because it didn't fit at all, but they jokingly gave me the ISFP description)

Your Type as Traits


Big 5 Traits


This is perhaps the lowest I have ever scored on openness. Perhaps it is the fact that I never leave my house lmfao...
 

Koto

Active member
Joined
May 22, 2021
Messages
301
INFP

Your "Type" as Traits


Extraversion - 8th percentile - extremely low

Intuiting - 99th percentile - extremely high

Feeling vs. Thinking - 66th percentile - high

Feeling - 60th percentile - about average

Thinking - 31st percentile - low

Judging - 6th percentile - extremely low


Your Big Five Traits

Extraversion - 3rd percentile - extremely low

Agreeableness - 5th percentile - extremely low

Conscientiousness - 4th percentile - extremely low

Neuroticism - 98th percentile - extremely high

Openness - 97th percentile - extremely high
 
Top