BlackCat- INTJ? INFP? ISFP?

[Glycerine]

Since when is depth an introverted trait? I'd think it was an N trait. You can have a shallow ISTJ, I know plenty of them.

Anyone can have depth. I think anyone who is at least somewhat intelligent has depth.

 

[Nonsensical]

Anyone can have depth. I think anyone who is at least somewhat intelligent has depth.

I guess it depends on how you view depth.

I look at depth as being very dynamic. Having many levels and characteristics. Hard to place a hand on.

I guess I can see how it relates to introversion, but it seems also, like iNtuits have more depth, in this manner, than do Sensors.

 

[BlackCat]

You have a crispness, an edge I think that wouldn't necessarily be accounted for by enneagram. I haven't read every post you've made, but a couple that come to mind about not getting how your mom feels re certain issues struck me as a bit surprising for a self-professed NF. That being said, I do still see you as an F, perhaps SFP, not an NT and not a J, although that one might be close (P / J balance).

I knew how my mom felt, but I didn't understand why.

Also elaborate on this "crispness" and "edge" please? And reasoning on SFP.

Just a few thoughts, I do hope this is helpful.

In the final analysis, the letters aren't really the be-all and end-all to relating to others anyway. You know I have personally wondered from time to time on my I vs E, so I appreciate the frustration of feeling that the "clothes" don't quite fit right, but don't worry too much about it.

It is helpful.

Yeah there are a lot of other factors personality wise dealing with how you relate to someone. Lots of other aspects.

I JUST WANNA FIT INTO A BOX!

 

[PeaceBaby]

This is why people get confused with MBTI all the time.

N does not equal depth or intelligence per se.

I does not equal depth or intelligence EITHER.

 

[PeaceBaby]

I knew how my mom felt, but I didn't understand why.

Also elaborate on this "crispness" and "edge" please? And reasoning on SFP.

I have to head to bed but will chat with you tomorrow on this, k?

 

[Nonsensical]

Like I said:

I didn't say that intelligence and depth were strictly related to N vs. S.

I said he has the depth and intellect OF an N.

If that makes any remote sense at all to you. If it doesn't than I have no idea what I'm talking about and it's a bunch of rubbish.

 

[Asterion]

Ahhh, but a well developed introverted function is more likely to have explored their mind and created inner depth. You always hear the profiles saying "Fi users have a rich inner world" do you not? Anyone can be deep of course. And I think intelligence isn't even really related to type (as ability does not come with type)

 

[BlackCat]

OH GOD ENPS ARE TROLLIN UP MY THREAD AND DERAILIN'!

I have to head to bed but will chat with you tomorrow on this, k?

Thanks.

What OneWithSoul is saying is that I seem N basically. And that I show traits of an N.

 

[PeaceBaby]

Like I said:

I didn't say that intelligence and depth were strictly related to N vs. S.

I said he has the depth and intellect OF an N.

If that makes any remote sense at all to you. If it doesn't than I have no idea what I'm talking about and it's a bunch of rubbish.

I heard you sweetie.

You said: "You're way too dynamic and have the depth and intellect of an N."

It is a bit of a smack to the sensors, don't you think?

Since there are plenty of deep-thinking S's around, who are dynamic and intelligent. Some of the sensors in these parts might find your statement somewhat offensive.

So sending out to all so there's no misunderstanding in the heat of debate!

 

[Nonsensical]

OH GOD ENPS ARE TROLLIN UP MY THREAD AND DERAILIN'!



Thanks.

What OneWithSoul is saying is that I seem N basically. And that I show traits of an N.

YES!
thank you.

 

[Asterion]

OH GOD ENPS ARE TROLLIN UP MY THREAD AND DERAILIN'!



Thanks.

What OneWithSoul is saying is that I seem N basically. And that I show traits of an N.

yes, whoops, sorry.

I'm putting you in the INFP box. That comment about INTJs not developing their Fi in such a way was quite clear. The close judging score is common for INFPs, and being a male, there is always the chance that you have been influenced into being more T (although that's not the greatest reason for typing you as an F exactly). The N/S score is slightly anomalous though, It could be because you can't quite analyse yourself right, but you don't quite seem like an SP much, right?

 

[Quinlan]

I'm deep, like the Mariana trench deep.

 

[PeaceBaby]

^ cool ... Mariana Trench - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[Nonsensical]

That's pretty deep, Quinlan.

 

[BlackCat]

The N/S score is slightly anomalous though, It could be because you can't quite analyse yourself right, but you don't quite seem like an SP much, right?

The T/F I think deals with being a male and growing up with an INTP and an ESTJ, with a lot of T friends. I can analyze myself just fine but I'm not really an SP. I'm just intuitive and also very grounded and concrete.

I'm headed off, yes 11:30 PM seems like an odd time to hang out with friends but they wanted me to. I'll get back to these responses later tonight, since I'll be at my house.

 

[EcK]

The whole self cult thing and selfishness, that kind of screams unhealthy Fi.

cats, also. Who the hell likes cats.

 

[BlackCat]

Annnd I'm here.

 

[Quinlan]

What about SP doesn't fit for you?

 

[BlackCat]

What about SP doesn't fit for you?

SPs tend to give off a pretty specific vibe, it's common between them (Se use vibe) and I don't relate to it. Just their general mind set and how they relate to things... I don't resonate with it. But this might be different for me because of the tertiary temptation.

 

[Quinlan]

SPs tend to give off a pretty specific vibe, it's common between them (Se use vibe) and I don't relate to it. Just their general mind set and how they relate to things... I don't resonate with it.

That is such an NF explanation.