• You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to additional post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), view blogs, respond to polls, upload content, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free, so please join our community today! Just click here to register. You should turn your Ad Blocker off for this site or certain features may not work properly. If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us by clicking here.

[ISTP] Question for ISTPs on a painful/awkward issue...

anii

homo-loving sonovagun
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
Messages
901
MBTI Type
infp
Enneagram
9
I have a brother whose alcoholism is tearing his family apart. Literally. Currently. His wife is ready to leave *this week* with her 2 young sons (4 year-olds).

This guy is an ISTP; his father was an ISTP and also an alcoholic. Please... if this was you, would you be open to an intervention? How would you want to be approached about this?

Any advice at all?
 

Schizm

New member
Joined
Sep 10, 2007
Messages
134
MBTI Type
INTP
Hell no. Confront my ISTP friend about his drug abuse and you will find yourself dealing with someone extremely difficult.

I think in your case more than likely the key would be getting a big group of people and putting the ISTP on the spot. Pointing out all the BS he has down to everyone. You should all picture yourself as the frying pan that already has the butter melted while you are all in the circle of the pan as that the egg starts a frying.
 

Totenkindly

@.~*virinaĉo*~.@
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
50,145
MBTI Type
BELF
Enneagram
594
Instinctual Variant
sx/sp
Ugh. Honestly, I would have no idea what to do.

An INTP still has the Ti primary but is usually able to accommodate conversation and speculation on things; even if he was stubborn, he'd listen (and wax philosophically on what was going on, annoying everyone and not seeming to take things seriously).

ISTPs tend to see "the System" as trying to control their freedom and often just digs in when pressure is put on them to conform to someone else's demands, though.

There might not be a way to prevent the separation; maybe he needs it in order to motivate him to stop.

I know at least one person here is married to an ISTP. perhaps one of them will have some ideas...
 

htb

New member
Joined
May 14, 2007
Messages
1,505
MBTI Type
INTJ
Enneagram
1w9
An alcoholic ISTP? Now, there is obtuseness times four.

Confrontation will simply cause him to temporize. Only consequences -- material deprivation -- might jostle him into rehabilitation.

Either way, your concern should be the welfare of your nephews. Get them and their mother out of there.
 

substitute

New member
Joined
May 27, 2007
Messages
4,601
MBTI Type
ENTP
When my ISTP best buddy was going this way, I found that what made him most receptive to criticism and taking things on board was, ironically, to go out to a bar with him and have a man to man talk over a few beers. After listening to him rant and being supportive and basically showing that I sympathised with his issues and stuff, I found that I was then able to find the right moment to say "But mate, you have been going over the top a bit - no offence to you but I have been feeling sorry for your poor mrs lately, you've been a bit of a c**t" and in that context he was able to hold up his hands and say "Yeah, I suppose you're right", and there was the opening to continue with "But think of it from her point of view, imagine you were sitting there [as she does, description] and someone came in and [what he does, description], it's not really on is it mate? C'mon, let's be honest here..."

You have to use just the right balance of friendliness and light-heartedness, together with a certain firmness and forthrightness. Don't waste time with hints or outright accusations - hints go right over their heads and accusations just put their backs up.
 

"?"

New member
Joined
May 2, 2007
Messages
1,167
MBTI Type
TiSe
I guess I always have to ask, what makes you believe the person is ISTP? Have they disclosed this to you, or is this a self-assessment on your behalf? You also reference to your brother, however his father, as being alcoholic. Are you making some connection that since they both are alcoholic, then they are both ISTP and did you know your brother's father?
 

proteanmix

Plumage and Moult
Joined
Apr 23, 2007
Messages
5,514
Enneagram
1w2
I guess I always have to ask, what makes you believe the person is ISTP? Have they disclosed this to you, or is this a self-assessment on your behalf? You also reference to your brother, however his father, as being alcoholic. Are you making some connection that since they both are alcoholic, then they are both ISTP and did you know your brother's father?

I wanted to ask the same question, but I thought to leave it alone.

I'm not understanding if there's a connection being drawn between ISTP and alcoholism or if you're asking for help in reaching an ISTP alcoholic. I think those are two separate issues.

I'd first address the alcoholism problem. I personally don't think this is time to leave a person unsupported, even if they're a type that typically doesn't respond well to this kind of intervention. If he's at all aware of his behavior and has a smidgen of motivation to change, then don't abandon him. IMO, personality type is irrelevant at this point.

If the wife and children are in any danger, then they need to leave immediately. There are many websites that gives advice on how to deal with the general problem of alcoholism. Aside from this very meager advice, I'd seek professional help.
 

ptgatsby

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 24, 2007
Messages
4,476
MBTI Type
ISTP
I'm pretty sure it is meant as "He is an ISTP and an Alcoholic, how do I reach out knowing that?".

Coming from that situation, I think his type is largely a 2nd thought. The first and foremost problem is to identify his addiction. Is he hiding it? Does he know it causes problems? Is he in denial? Does he blame others?

A checklist like that will help you decide how to act. The basic rules, I think, go something like this;

1) Hiding or signs of guilt = intervention. It's possible to bring it out into the open and thus create a support network and create new expected behaviour. Professional help is a good idea here too, but it isn't as required. Just read a lot about it at the very least.

2) Denial - It can be intervention, but this is the "hard core" intervention. Normally the family had to leave already, job loss or DUIs. This breaks the denial and is extremely painful. Get professional help no matter what on this one.

3) Denial + blame + uncontrolled outbursts/any sign of violence - Leave first, worry about your friend second.

Normally I'd cut the friend off at point #3. Addiction is a black hole of suffering. Make one major try, offer to be there when they have come to terms with their addiction and leave.

The ISTP part is more about how to deal in the immediate situation - how will you approach him within the meeting, etc. A tool for communication. The drinking sytles supercede type for sure, even if type does contribute to which category he'd be in.
 

anii

homo-loving sonovagun
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
Messages
901
MBTI Type
infp
Enneagram
9
There might not be a way to prevent the separation; maybe he needs it in order to motivate him to stop.

At this point we are all agreed the marriage is over.

Our goal is to get him into treatment and preserve whatever rights he has to his sons.
 

anii

homo-loving sonovagun
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
Messages
901
MBTI Type
infp
Enneagram
9
Coming from that situation, I think his type is largely a 2nd thought.

The ISTP part is more about how to deal in the immediate situation - how will you approach him within the meeting, etc. A tool for communication. The drinking sytles supercede type for sure, even if type does contribute to which category he'd be in.

Well, when I contemplate approaching him both his and my dad's type come to mind. Neither are/were in touch with their "feelings" at all. Neither seem/seemed have any psychological or emotional insight. So approaching them from a feeling or even values orientation (my sister in law is INFP) seems doomed to fail.

We never did an intervention with my father because I was too afraid at the time (in my 20s) to broach it with my brothers.

I'm still very hesitant and frankly, regretted placing it on the table with my younger brother (ISTJ) the moment it was uttered. However, I love my sister in law and of course my nephews.

Both of my parents are deceased so my brothers and I are... all we have. I feel I should at least make the attempt this time. That way, even if it fails, I can say I tried.
 

anii

homo-loving sonovagun
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
Messages
901
MBTI Type
infp
Enneagram
9
I wanted to ask the same question, but I thought to leave it alone.

I'm not understanding if there's a connection being drawn between ISTP and alcoholism or if you're asking for help in reaching an ISTP alcoholic. I think those are two separate issues.

I'd first address the alcoholism problem. I personally don't think this is time to leave a person unsupported, even if they're a type that typically doesn't respond well to this kind of intervention. If he's at all aware of his behavior and has a smidgen of motivation to change, then don't abandon him. IMO, personality type is irrelevant at this point.

If the wife and children are in any danger, then they need to leave immediately. There are many websites that gives advice on how to deal with the general problem of alcoholism. Aside from this very meager advice, I'd seek professional help.

I am in no way saying they are alcoholics because they are ISTPs. I am saying that, in my experience, at least one ISTP was resistant to the idea of treatment, 12 step groups, etc. until the day he died due to complications of alcoholism.

In this situation, I don't want to repeat the same mistake. I want to give my brother one chance - and only one from me - to get his shit together. I'm concerned that on some level he thinks none of us cares... noone seemed to care what happened to my dad.

As to typing them... my dad took the MBTI as part of a severence package and typed as ISTP. I gave my brother the Kiersey (unofficial version) and he typed as ISTP. I could go into superficial traits (epicurian, egalitarian, detests authority/rules, likes beer/darts/cars, etc. but he's already taken the damn test).

My sister in law asked if she's doing the right thing by telling him she'll leave with the kids if he doesn't go to rehab. I said she is.

She is not thinking rationally at the moment and keeps going back and forth. She still thinks she can get him to change his behavior, if only she could find the 'secret password.' She is alone with him in Texas... she has no one else to help. At this point I'm rambling on a tangent. I've told her that any choices she makes from this point on should be solely about what is best for her and her children, and not about what may or may not get the desired response from my brother.

He's about to lose everything; this is just my 11th hour brainstorm to see if maybe, possibly, there's a way to get him help.

I know he has to want it... I'll ask her to call a professional interventionist and let them advise her.
 

miss fortune

not to be trusted
Joined
Oct 4, 2007
Messages
20,589
Enneagram
827
Instinctual Variant
sp/so
I really don't want to talk about this issue....

I went through a bit of a difficult time a while back and instead of talking about it to anyone I decided to drink about it instead- it was easier. I spent over a year drunk on a daily basis (at least 10 drinks a day for a 120 lb woman). My friends tried a couple of different approaches to getting me to stop, but none of them really worked. The thing that ended up working was realizing that I would never get a job that I wanted unless I quit drinking since I was usually too drunk or hung over to do homework or go to the gym. My friends opinions had no real importance to me I'm sorry to say- it was purely motivation to get what I wanted. I hope that he values his wife and child enough that he will stop drinking in order to keep them. I hope that this was of some help.

oh God that was uncomfortable! :)
 

INTJMom

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 28, 2007
Messages
5,413
MBTI Type
INTJ
Enneagram
5w4
...My sister in law asked if she's doing the right thing by telling him she'll leave with the kids if he doesn't go to rehab. I said she is.

She is not thinking rationally at the moment and keeps going back and forth. She still thinks she can get him to change his behavior, if only she could find the 'secret password.' She is alone with him in Texas... she has no one else to help. At this point I'm rambling on a tangent. I've told her that any choices she makes from this point on should be solely about what is best for her and her children, and not about what may or may not get the desired response from my brother....
This all sounds good to me.
She is the one living with him. She knows better than we do.
I have learned that family situations like this are incredibly complex.
If she has the guts to leave then she should do it. Tough love sounds like the right answer to me. Maybe the marriage will work out in the end.

My mother stayed with my alcoholic father. He never got the help he needed. She ended up enabling him. He just kept getting worse.
 

wildcat

New member
Joined
Jun 8, 2007
Messages
3,622
MBTI Type
INTP
I really don't want to talk about this issue....

I went through a bit of a difficult time a while back and instead of talking about it to anyone I decided to drink about it instead- it was easier. I spent over a year drunk on a daily basis (at least 10 drinks a day for a 120 lb woman). My friends tried a couple of different approaches to getting me to stop, but none of them really worked. The thing that ended up working was realizing that I would never get a job that I wanted unless I quit drinking since I was usually too drunk or hung over to do homework or go to the gym. My friends opinions had no real importance to me I'm sorry to say- it was purely motivation to get what I wanted. I hope that he values his wife and child enough that he will stop drinking in order to keep them. I hope that this was of some help.

oh God that was uncomfortable! :)
A rare post.
 
Top