• You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to additional post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), view blogs, respond to polls, upload content, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free, so please join our community today! Just click here to register. You should turn your Ad Blocker off for this site or certain features may not work properly. If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us by clicking here.

[NF] Being realistic in life and relationships: NFs please help!

21%

You have a choice!
Joined
May 15, 2009
Messages
3,224
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
4w5
Hi everyone. I've been around for a while, mostly lurking. This is my first thread ever, and I would really appreciate feedback from fellow NFs!

This is going to be long, so please feel free to skip to the SHORT VERSION if you don't want to read all the details. (I've just realized after I typed up the whole thing that reading the short version would do just fine)

Background:
I've been together with an INFP for almost 2 years now. I'm from Bangkok. He's from the US. We met in England during our MA studies. The connection was amazing and we had a wonderful year in England. When it was time to go home, we didn't even consider breaking up. His plan was to come to Bangkok to teach English and we would take things from there.

<side note> He was already thinking about coming to Asia to teach English before he met me, because one of his friends was doing it. Also, I made it clear from the beginning that I could not relocate. (It's probably a Chinese thing: family comes first)

After the degree, he went home, at first planning to stay for a month or so before moving to Bangkok. However, his supervisor encouraged him to apply for a PhD, so he stayed on for longer to do some more research and write up a proposal. Meanwhile, to support himself, he took on a full-time (but rather low-paying) job. (This has been going on for 9 months and we're doing long-distance right now)

Current Situation:
He submitted his PhD proposal and the university accepted him. Because his MA thesis was so good, they will be giving him partial scholarship as well. Of course, he has always wanted a PhD and he was thrilled.

However, there's a problem. The MA left him around 40K in debt. He has no savings and even when he is working a full-time job right now, he's barely scraping by. He's got tooth pain and needs work done on it and he can't even afford it. If he's going to do the PhD, he will have to take out another 50K, even with the scholarship and provided that he could find a part-time job in England during the time. That means by the end of his three-year PhD, he will be at least almost 100K in debt.

I know if you're going for higher education, you've got to expect to be in debt. But as his dream job is to be teaching somewhere with low hours and in a stress-free environment, like in a community college, where you average around 40K a year, he might have problems paying back the 100K. (Currently they want 500 USD from him a month -- and he can barely afford to pay that amount. Now all his income goes towards food, gas and loads of bills. He hasn't totally paid off his BA student loan yet. I imagine that with a 100K debt after his PhD, they might be wanting as much as 1K a month, and there is no way he is going to be able to pay that back)

And, of course, this would totally eliminate the chance of moving to Asia -- as it won't be sensible to work in Asia where the pay is lower to pay American bills.

How I feel about this:
I'm happy for him that he is getting to do what he wants. But I really don't like the idea of borrowing more money. Right now he simply has absolutely no money. If something bad happens, like he needs medical care that the insurance doesn't cover, or if his car breaks down, or if his parents cannot afford to let him live on their property anymore -- he will not be able to cope. He's already maxing out his credit card, so he needs to pay that back too. My thought is, if he is going for the PhD, he has to try to get a better-paying job afterward. He has to really work for it. There's no easy way out. Unless he is willing to live broke probably for the rest of his life. I've been trying to tell him this and it doesn't seem to be registering very well. He always said he was bad at planning things, and all his life he never "thought that far into the future". Also, I told him that if he gets this PhD, it probably won't be a good idea to come to Asia later, and he didn't take that very well either.

I don't want to be selfish. I will respect his decision if he chooses to go for the degree, but from our current situation, it doesn't look like we would ever be together again. Of course, if there was no money problem and he could come to Asia afterward, there would be more chance of this long-distance thing working out. However, I don't want it to be a scenario where I give him the ultimatum and say "Choose between our relationship or your degree". It's simply not fair.

SHORT VERSION
My INFP boyfriend is thinking about going to a PhD program in another country for 3 years. After that, due to various circumstances, there is very little chance of us being together again. However, he's got financial problems right now and is in a huge amount of debt, so the idea of taking out more money for a PhD in something that's not entirely job-search-friendly (Philosophy) might not be a good idea.

My questions are:
1) For the financial problem: is his plan sensible? Can you realistically live on 40K a year and pay back 100K of debt?
2) Should I let him know that the relationship might have to end if he does this PhD? I don't want to force him too choose. Do I say nothing and let him make his decision or should I tell him to take this into account as well? It's not that I plan to break up with him as soon as he decides to go. It's not even certain yet. But if he chooses to go, there will be almost no chance of us being together physically again and I'm not sure our relationship can survive that kind of indefinite uncertainty.
3) I have this feeling that he doesn't fully realize the implications of that much financial burden yet. However, I'm not entirely sure if my underlying motivation for not wanting him to go for the PhD is not actually a selfish one. If that's his calling, then I can accept the fact that our life paths might have to go in different directions. I just want to be certain that he knows what he is choosing. My INFP is prone to regrets -- I don't want years from now to hear that he is unhappy and regrets his choice and he's stuck with it for the rest of his life. What should I do? What can I do? Is it even up to me at all?


He is extremely stressed out about his financial situation and very confused about what he should do. I don't know how to help and I feel horrible seeing him worry so much. I want to be supportive, but I don't know how. I'm confused and I feel we are caught up in this situation where nothing seems to be working out. I feel guilty for thinking about giving up on us but I simply do not see how it can work out. I don't want to be manipulative. Sometimes I just simply don't know what to think and I feel like I'm going crazy weighing all the options that aren't even mine. Am I being selfish? Any advice?

Wow, this post is a lot longer than I intended. Thank you for reading. I feel so lost right now, like I'm being a horrible girlfriend, so any input would be extremely helpful. :cry:
 

PeaceBaby

reborn
Joined
Jan 7, 2009
Messages
5,950
MBTI Type
N/A
Enneagram
N/A
^ as far as the debt goes, has he tapped into potential sources of grant money or other scholarships? There are a great deal of grant programs, even at the doctoral level, where the money does not need to repaid.

100k is a huge burden when one is just starting off in a career. I would advise a ton of research to find free money to get this done. If he never does the PhD he may regret it, so creative ways to make it happen are imperative. Have a doctoral fund-raiser party - does he attend church, some folks there would likely offer gifts for his education - set up a web-page to "help John Doe do his doctoral research" - VA offers grants to students of veterans ..... just a few thoughts that come to mind.

It can be done. Find the inspiration!
 

21%

You have a choice!
Joined
May 15, 2009
Messages
3,224
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
4w5
^ as far as the debt goes, has he tapped into potential sources of grant money or other scholarships? There are a great deal of grant programs, even at the doctoral level, where the money does not need to repaid.

100k is a huge burden when one is just starting off in a career. I would advise a ton of research to find free money to get this done. If he never does the PhD he may regret it, so creative ways to make it happen are imperative. Have a doctoral fund-raiser party - does he attend church, some folks there would likely offer gifts for his education - set up a web-page to "help John Doe do his doctoral research" - VA offers grants to students of veterans ..... just a few thoughts that come to mind.

It can be done. Find the inspiration!

Thank you Peacebaby! That was very helpful! Your post actually made me suddenly a lot happier. I really want him to be able to do this PhD, because I know it's something he's truly good at. The university has a deadline of when you have to decide to accept the scholarship, but we will try to see if there are other options. You're right! We need to first believe it's possible. :)

Now that you've mentioned other possibilities, I realize that maybe he doesn't even have to take out another loan right now to go this year. We were so caught up in the complications that we didn't see that. Thanks so much!
 

Phoenix_400

New member
Joined
Sep 1, 2009
Messages
297
MBTI Type
INxP
Enneagram
5w6
That kind of financial burden is unfortunately becoming more and more common these days, though you usually see more of it in the medical fields.

The debt could be handled, but its going to require a strict adherence to a budget and I would suggest he have a long sit-down with a financial advisor (some banks offer a free consultation if you have an account with them). If all of this is in student loans, he should see what he can do about deferred interest/payments to buy him time and put his money into putting other affairs in order. Cutting spending, paying off any other debts, reducing bills, etc. Think like a business: Lower your overhead and increase efficiency.

As for pursuing the PhD, that's something to be proud of. If its something he really wants, I would say "go for it". If its more about getting a job, I would do a thorough cost/benefit analysis. Look at the type of work he wants to do and the education level required. Then look at the pay increase you would receive for having a higher education. If the PhD is unnecessary for the level in which he wishes to work, or the increase in income from having a PhD as part of his credentials doesn't offset what he'd be paying to get the PhD, I'd pass. If he's got an MA, that should be more than adequate for teaching at a community college and its already a higher education than most people achieve. There's nothing wrong with stopping there if it meets the requirements to get him exactly what he wants.
 

cascadeco

New member
Joined
Oct 7, 2007
Messages
9,083
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
9w1
Instinctual Variant
sp/sx
Others have given decent advice, and I especially liked Phoenix's advice - seems very reasonable and smart.

Only aspect of all of it I'm not clear on is the whole 'relationship' element - i.e. If he gets the phD it sounds like you'll never see him again? Not understanding if he'd eventually come back or if he'd never come back? If he'll never come back, even with the degree, and you already know you don't want long-distance, then isn't that your answer as far as the relationship bit? Is that still the unknown? But sounds like even you aren't sure yet re. your feelings on that piece.
 

Red Herring

Superwoman
Joined
Jun 9, 2010
Messages
7,498
MBTI Type
INTP
Enneagram
5w4
Instinctual Variant
sp/sx
Hi 21%!

You definitely aren´t a bad girlfriend for whishing your boyfriend all the best with his projects and wanting to be with him at the same time!

I have several friends who do/did a PhD in philosophy, all of them had a scholarship and were able to do it wothout accumulating too much debt. My little sister finished her PhD in Molecular Biotechnology a few weeks ago and financed it working for the university as a research assistent. There are many possibilities. (But then again I am talking about Europe, I don´t know what tzhe situation is like in America). You might want to do some research into different possibilities at different universities as well, since the conditions vary from university to university and country to country!

The question is if your boyfriend wants to continue in Academia (which would mean he definitely needs that PhD as a philisopher) or if he decides to work abroad as an English teacher. Both paths have their strengths and weaknesses.

That being said. Is there really no way you could eventually relocate instead at some point in time? Oh, and the somewhat careless attitude towards money sounds very INFP, I´m afraid :blush:
 

21%

You have a choice!
Joined
May 15, 2009
Messages
3,224
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
4w5
That kind of financial burden is unfortunately becoming more and more common these days, though you usually see more of it in the medical fields.

The debt could be handled, but its going to require a strict adherence to a budget and I would suggest he have a long sit-down with a financial advisor (some banks offer a free consultation if you have an account with them). If all of this is in student loans, he should see what he can do about deferred interest/payments to buy him time and put his money into putting other affairs in order. Cutting spending, paying off any other debts, reducing bills, etc. Think like a business: Lower your overhead and increase efficiency.

As for pursuing the PhD, that's something to be proud of. If its something he really wants, I would say "go for it". If its more about getting a job, I would do a thorough cost/benefit analysis. Look at the type of work he wants to do and the education level required. Then look at the pay increase you would receive for having a higher education. If the PhD is unnecessary for the level in which he wishes to work, or the increase in income from having a PhD as part of his credentials doesn't offset what he'd be paying to get the PhD, I'd pass. If he's got an MA, that should be more than adequate for teaching at a community college and its already a higher education than most people achieve. There's nothing wrong with stopping there if it meets the requirements to get him exactly what he wants.

Very sound advice about how to deal with debt, Phoenix. Thanks! I'll talk to him about it. As for the PhD, he's already got "this paper that needs to be written" in his head, so it's more of a personal fulfillment than anything else. I think he wants to go "all the way" with his interest -- pursue it in depth and devote his life to it if he can. I just wish he didn't have to risk everything for it, because in the long run it's probably not going to earn him an easy, comfortable life that he wants. He also wants to travel and see the world. I guess in the end it just comes down to whether you have money or not :(
 

21%

You have a choice!
Joined
May 15, 2009
Messages
3,224
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
4w5
Others have given decent advice, and I especially liked Phoenix's advice - seems very reasonable and smart.

Only aspect of all of it I'm not clear on is the whole 'relationship' element - i.e. If he gets the phD it sounds like you'll never see him again? Not understanding if he'd eventually come back or if he'd never come back? If he'll never come back, even with the degree, and you already know you don't want long-distance, then isn't that your answer as far as the relationship bit? Is that still the unknown? But sounds like even you aren't sure yet re. your feelings on that piece.

Cascadeco, I admit I'm still pretty confused right now about the whole thing. We've been doing long-distance for nine months and it hasn't been easy. If it was just me, I would have packed up and moved to be with him long time ago. But I also have my family to consider. There are other people who need me, too, and I'm not willing to leave them. It seems no matter what I choose, I'll be letting someone I care about down.

We originally had a plan: he would come to Bangkok for a little to see if he liked it. If he does, he's moving here. If he doesn't, then we'll decide if we want to end things and just be friends or to continue with our long-distance and be content with occasional visits. Ultimately, however, I think I want to settle down someday and have kids, and I don't think I will truly feel fulfilled with just yearly visits.

The unknown lies largely in that opportunities do happen. If, after his degree, a miracle happens and he can find a job in Bangkok that will pay enough for him to repay his loan, that would solve everything. If there is even a little hope of us being together afterward, I'm more ready for this three-year long-distance. And to be honest, even when there's no hope, I think I'm going to go with it anyway. Sometimes I just can't help but wonder if I'm just being too naive and that a brave decision now would save us from so much pain in the long run.
 

Randomnity

insert random title here
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
9,485
MBTI Type
ISTP
Enneagram
6w5
Instinctual Variant
sp/sx
I tend to agree with what the others wrote, but I'd be far more cautious about doing it. 100k is a ridiculous amount of debt to pay off, particularly if it's with a degree that isn't financially...productive. It might be worth taking a break from school and working for a while, to pay off some of the debt so he won't be stuck paying huge amounts in interest (or simply with impossible amounts to pay per month) later on. This is assuming he can't get more scholarships/grants/bursaries, which hopefully he's already applying to like crazy! If he can't survive after graduating, is the phd now really worth it?

Depending what your costs of living are vs. expected income, 1000$+/month payments might be literally impossible to survive with. If he doesn't "get it", you could have him try to make a balanced budget with your expected numbers...and maybe even try living on it now, to see what it's like.

When thinking about these kinds of degrees, I tend to liken it to a hobby...would you take out a 50k, or 100k loan to go travelling, or to do some expensive hobby? Even if it was really inspiring and fulfilling? Or would you wait until you could somewhat afford it?

You can always go back to school and get a phd...you can't return it though.

edit: this is all assuming that a pHD in philosophy won't really help his job prospects/salary where you are (it definitely doesn't where I live, in my experience). If it does, that changes things somewhat.
 

kiddykat

movin melodies
Joined
Jul 27, 2008
Messages
1,111
MBTI Type
ENFP
Enneagram
4, 7
1) For the financial problem: is his plan sensible? Can you realistically live on 40K a year and pay back 100K of debt?
Depends on what kind of job he lands, if what's offered is something that a school is willing to help re-imburse? I don't know how the system works in the U.K. I'm thinking it would be sensible to pursue our passions that we're really good at. Those who stand out stand out for doing what love doing, and make it very successful, because their talents/hard work shine, if it's recognized for the current trend.

If his dissertation is something that his work of choice recognizes would be beneficial to their reputation or financial gains, then I wouldn't see how they won't help out with paying back the cost of his education. It also depends on who we know, connections, etc.

2) Should I let him know that the relationship might have to end if he does this PhD? I don't want to force him too choose. Do I say nothing and let him make his decision or should I tell him to take this into account as well? It's not that I plan to break up with him as soon as he decides to go. It's not even certain yet. But if he chooses to go, there will be almost no chance of us being together physically again and I'm not sure our relationship can survive that kind of indefinite uncertainty.If it were me- no. Weigh it out a little more. It sounds like you guys have something pretty serious going. I don't think that he'd be willing to jeopardize what you guys have. Telling him that will add to his stress even more.

3) I have this feeling that he doesn't fully realize the implications of that much financial burden yet. However, I'm not entirely sure if my underlying motivation for not wanting him to go for the PhD is not actually a selfish one. If that's his calling, then I can accept the fact that our life paths might have to go in different directions. I just want to be certain that he knows what he is choosing. My INFP is prone to regrets -- I don't want years from now to hear that he is unhappy and regrets his choice and he's stuck with it for the rest of his life. What should I do? What can I do? Is it even up to me at all?I don't think there's much a person can do in this case, because it's his dreams he's pursuing.

Tough call. I think you have a really difficult decision to make. On one hand, you don't want to let go of the one that you love, in hopes that one day you can marry/have kids with this person. On the other hand, there is this agony of distance, time, schooling, finances, and it seems like the externals are really outweighing the relationship that you guys have.

Call me an idealist, but I think if you two truly love each other, it can work out. It will take lots of effort. Anything in life takes effort though, right? It's about how much we're willing to compromise? Really depends..

I've seen couples who were apart for 5 years. The guy went back to the girl's home country to marry her, and they reunited eventually to have twin girls. I've never seen any couple as genuinely happy/in love with one another. They're struggling financially right now. Still have that spark after over 15 years of marriage. Every time I see them, it makes me realize the power of love and its effects on happiness- that is- if a couple both genuinely cares/respects one another mutually the same, which sounds like the relationship you guys have.

I think finances are a bit of a burden right now for most people. I get this feeling that if you do let this relationship go, will you find another like this or more rewarding? Only both of you guys know that answer.. Sorry. I wish I could've been more of help.

As I see it, if it's an external issue. I think if the relationship is strong internally, if what's shared is solid, you can/will work it through some way somehow..:hug:
 

cafe

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
9,827
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
9w1
I don't think you need a PhD to teach at Community College. When I went there in the late nineties you didn't, but maybe things have changed.

My husband and I are in the boat you are afraid of sailing in. :D We have around $100K or student debt and he is driving a truck making $40-something K a year.

Right now our saving grace is that we've qualified for income based repayment , which is a new-ish program. May or may not help, but it might be worth looking into.

I read somewhere that INTPs and INFPs can have a tendency to be professional students.

Anyway, FWIW, we've really struggled a lot financially (we have four kids, along with the other stuff -- we married young and were kind of naive about the whole grown-up thing.) It can be a real drain on your psyche and relationship to be flat broke and worried about money all the time.

However, good partners -- compatible ones, can be hard to come by. I think I probably would have discouraged his graduate studies if I had it to do over again, but I don't think I'd really change a whole lot else. We do really love each other and all the struggles have made us a pretty strong team. I know, come hell or high water, I can rely on this man and I think he knows, come hell or high water, I will be there with him.

OTOH, with our kids, we do push them to get good grades so that they can get scholarships. We don't push them crazy hard. We don't really have to. They are all fairly intelligent, so all we have to do is make sure they complete and turn in their homework and they do just fine. But we preach Scholarships/Grants = good. Student loans = evil. We didn't have that kind of guidance, but by golly, our kids are getting it.
 

Tallulah

Emerging
Joined
Feb 19, 2008
Messages
6,009
MBTI Type
INTP
I teach at a community college, and I know you don't have to have a PhD to get hired. It might help, sure. It might make you a more attractive candidate. But is the advantage worth $100K in debt? Absolutely not. I've considered getting a PhD, but then I realized that it would mostly be to prove to myself I could do it and for the education itself, and not because of any extremely high aspirations I have to be tenured at a prestigious university. If he's going to be happy teaching at a CC, he really doesn't need the PhD.

I agree with whoever said he could wait a while, take some time off and teach.

I know if I had 100K of debt, I would be extremely depressed and discouraged as I tried to pay it off with my meager salary, knowing I couldn't have any "fun" stuff for a very long time.
 

CuriousFeeling

From the Undertow
Joined
Dec 18, 2009
Messages
2,937
MBTI Type
INfJ
Enneagram
4w5
Instinctual Variant
sp/sx
1) For the financial problem: is his plan sensible? Can you realistically live on 40K a year and pay back 100K of debt?

It will take years to pay back that debt on a 40K income. I'm not sure how much interest the bank expects for him to pay back on a yearly basis, so this is another factor to take into consideration too. If I were in his situation, I'd get a teaching job first in the secondary level to gain enough income to pay off the student loans and save up for the grad school. Once that has been accomplished, and he's paid off the loan (or at least 75% of it), then go for the doctorate degree. Also, I recommend him to check into the university's financial aid office to see if they can offer him grants/ scholarships/ financial aid plans.

2) Should I let him know that the relationship might have to end if he does this PhD? I don't want to force him too choose. Do I say nothing and let him make his decision or should I tell him to take this into account as well? It's not that I plan to break up with him as soon as he decides to go. It's not even certain yet. But if he chooses to go, there will be almost no chance of us being together physically again and I'm not sure our relationship can survive that kind of indefinite uncertainty.

Don't force an ultimatum. Rather than having him choose between the relationship and the doctorate degree, the best thing to do is to ask him if he thinks that the relationship will be feasible if he decides to pursue the doctorate degree. Do you have the option of traveling to see him? If so, consider doing that. If traveling to him isn't possible, then the both of you will have to weigh out if you two could handle not seeing each other for an extended period of time.

3) I have this feeling that he doesn't fully realize the implications of that much financial burden yet. However, I'm not entirely sure if my underlying motivation for not wanting him to go for the PhD is not actually a selfish one. If that's his calling, then I can accept the fact that our life paths might have to go in different directions. I just want to be certain that he knows what he is choosing. My INFP is prone to regrets -- I don't want years from now to hear that he is unhappy and regrets his choice and he's stuck with it for the rest of his life. What should I do? What can I do? Is it even up to me at all?

It's up to him to decide to pursue the degree. If he feels inclined to do it, then he should go for it. He just needs to have the financial half presented to him. Be upfront about the financial problems to him. I dated an INFP, and he was not the best with finances either, and I didn't hesitate to tell him if he was making the wrong move with his money.

In sum, I think that you two should have a "state of the relationship" discussion, cos it sounds like to me that you're afraid that you'll ultimately have to break up with your boyfriend because you'll never get to see him again. Not a good sign to me, and it needs to be discussed.

I hope this advice was useful for you. :)
 

PeaceBaby

reborn
Joined
Jan 7, 2009
Messages
5,950
MBTI Type
N/A
Enneagram
N/A
You can always go back to school and get a phd...you can't return it though.

No, no you can't ... it's not as simple as that. Life changes continually, and sometimes there just is no do-over. If he doesn't do this now, the chances (as an INFP particularly) are good that it will be a continual regret too. Once family and children come along ... those are the priorities. Even actually having this thesis accepted at this point, there's no guarantee it will be this easy again in the future.

That's why I'm an advocate of extreme creativity here. 15 years ago, I fund-raised over $25000 for a little known charity project in less than a few months, so I know it can be done. That was before the internet, all done through networking, personal contacts, walk-a-thons, grant applications etc.

You simply make yourself the project here. :) You'd be surprised at how many people and organizations may want to offer to help.
 

21%

You have a choice!
Joined
May 15, 2009
Messages
3,224
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
4w5
Thanks everyone for the great ideas and support! I truly appreciate all of your feedback!

Red Herring: That sounds very heartening! Thank you! My INFP is asking his supervisor if it would be possible to work as a teaching assistant during his studies. If that's an option, he can borrow much less and there's a chance that it's going to work out okay after all. I don't know if he really knows what he wants in life, but I know he wants this degree very much. Well, if it comes down to it sometime in the future that I must move to another country, there is still a chance. I know my family would want me to go and be happy. However, I don't know if I will be able to forgive myself. I've got a loving, supportive family and all they ever ask of me is to be around, and if I can't even do that I would probably feel like a horrible, selfish person for the rest of my life. Right now I'm just trying to avoid thinking about it :blush:

Randomnity: Thank you! Your advice sounds very sensible, and I wish he would really think things through with the finance bit. Whenever I force him to plan things it stresses him out so much that I feel like I'm being mean. He'd probably be horrified by the idea of putting all the numbers on a spreadsheet to see if it would work. Maybe I should do it for him. My J-ness is freaking out about not having a plan (This happens a lot in our relationship :D). So many important factors are up in the air right now and the university is pressing him to decide within a month. I guess we need to sit down over skype this weekend and really talk about the options.

kiddykat: Thank you for your inspirational words! I really, really want to believe that love conquers all (and deep down I sorta do). I know that despite all my reasoning, as long as it feels right, I'm probably going to go with it anyway. Long-distance is just hard. As time goes by without any real prospect of being together again, you can't help but go into this downward spiral of is-it-worth-it. Your friend's story is so sweet -- proof that it can be done. I'll do my best to try to remain optimistic!

cafe: Aww, you guys seem to be a great, great couple! I'm so happy for you. Thanks for sharing your insight and experience. I totally agree with the 'professional students' comment. My INFP actually said that he would love to be a student all his life. One time he said he was thinking about going to yet another school for a few years after getting his PhD and I got quite a bit mad at him. I can't help but feel like I'm evil for being so realistic. I always thought I was not a realistic person, but being in this relationship sometimes makes me feel like I'm a practicality tyrant.
Your kids are lucky. :) This simple advice would save them tons of money in the long run. It's frightening to think that most people have never been taught the right attitude and skills in handling their money.

Tallulah: Thanks! I'll let him know. I'm afraid his case is similar to yours in that it's more about doing something he loves and proving that he can be successful in it rather than wanting a job at a good university. And he should try teaching first to see if he actually likes teaching. Good point!

CuriousFeeling: Yes, it's certainly helpful. Thanks. I think I really do need to discuss the relationship aspect with him. It's still going to sound like I'm forcing him to choose though. He sensed the other day over the phone that I was sad about the prolonged long-distance and he got depressed. I told him it was not his fault, but it still bothered him a lot. I hope we'd be able to work out an alternative that will allow us to see each other and not go into financial ruin.
 

21%

You have a choice!
Joined
May 15, 2009
Messages
3,224
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
4w5
That's why I'm an advocate of extreme creativity here. 15 years ago, I fund-raised over $25000 for a little known charity project in less than a few months, so I know it can be done. That was before the internet, all done through networking, personal contacts, walk-a-thons, grant applications etc.

Wow, that's impressive!


Yes, that's exactly his fear that if he doesn't do it now the opportunity will be lost forever. This partial scholarship is not deferrable, and there is no guarantee that he's going to get it again when he applies in the future.
 

CuriousFeeling

From the Undertow
Joined
Dec 18, 2009
Messages
2,937
MBTI Type
INfJ
Enneagram
4w5
Instinctual Variant
sp/sx
CuriousFeeling: Yes, it's certainly helpful. Thanks. I think I really do need to discuss the relationship aspect with him. It's still going to sound like I'm forcing him to choose though. He sensed the other day over the phone that I was sad about the prolonged long-distance and he got depressed. I told him it was not his fault, but it still bothered him a lot. I hope we'd be able to work out an alternative that will allow us to see each other and not go into financial ruin.

Could visit each other during holidays and have three to four day weekends if necessary.
 
Top