Thanks for tagging me.
I have to say this, though, because credit is due where it must be due - a friend of mine has been typing some RvB characters, and I have basically matched their typing with what I could discern from canon. (I think I function better as an aux role anyway)
A few things that come to mind, keeping in mind soime of them will be quoted off the top of my head and therefore probably wrong, but, knowing myself, probably just SLIGHTLY wrong as opposed to horrendously wrong.
I can see where ESTJ for
sarge is coming from, but his instinctive attention to possibilities, his incredibly strong attunement to personal morals/feelings make me type him as
ENFP. (Ne-Fi.)
Felix: ESTP
- Dominant Se. He's very much being in the moment, in s14 (and some extent chorus seasons) he's usually the first to react.
- Ti because Miles' piece about writing practise screams Ti - his definition of "humanity" works on if x then y level, not "most humans are empirically x, therefore humanity is y". He throws in some generalisations about some manifestations of humanity, etc etc because he knows the power of empircal values, but all his arguments are twisted for his own benefit, to justify his own bloodlust.
- Fe - because it comes very easily to social manipulation and generally has quite a bit of affinity with Se.
- Ni - feeling "empty" when the most likely outcome appears doomed (S14)
Locus-ISFJ (Looping in most -monster- episodes)
- Si - his continual search for the idea of the soldier comes from the past; what is inculcated into him (his CO). Then he looks at past examples of soldiers, like Wash and Maine.
- Fe - his concern for his fellow teammates, his ability to make peace when sharkface and felix get into a fight, authoritatively. His rationale for acting, where he truly shines, come forth here, BUT he's looping a lot, because that's what he thinks the ideal soldier should do. (In contrast, the reason Wash holds his own so well is because that Fi provides a personal compass, and Locus spends a lot of time trying to figure that part out.)
- Ti - Si-Ti reinforcing each other: If soldiers act according to X (a suit of armour), and I am a soldier, then I must act according to X.
- Ne: Si doms don't usually make life changes easily, but when pushed to the edge, it is usually a complete and utter change, and an alternative way of doing things since it requires everything that Si knows to be refuted completely. (S13 e19, my fave
)
Agree with
Church (I know way too many INTJs and they all relate to him, plus, he's a lot like them), but I think
Caboose is more of an iNtuitive. Just not a conventionally "smart" one (...I actually also disagree with conventional ideas of intelligence.)
Caboose:
- likely an Fe-Ni-Se-Ti. Where he comes to shine is really his treatment of machines, which is entirely subjective and nowhere based off concrete observation (eg: the book where he talks about dogs having wifi and cats don't, and in an oddly symbollic way it makes some very strange sense.) He wants everyone to be happy and to be friends - Fe dom.
Other things I haven't bothered to proof:
North: ESFJ (Fe dom)
Grif: INFP (Fi dom, literally doesn't give a shit unless it's something he cares about, then he kicks into gear and starts doing things with alternative methods).
Simmons: Unhealthy ESFJ (This one I remember the rationale for and agree with it, but typing it out would take too long.)
Donut: I don't think he's a prominent Si user.
Doc: I realise it's a comedy, but he's got some weird ways of seeing the world that's not very concrete. One thing that comes to mind is a reason for not killing people: "Don't know, uhhh karma?" He does offer suggestions that would work, and stereotypes of how he is useless is, frankly, nothing but stereotypes, but I do think he has Fi-Te in his stack, and in this precise order. IxFp is my likely guess, with Ne or Se. I'd venture to say Ne, because he's good at thinking of different ways of doing things.
Can't comment on enneagrams.
