Shirley Manson

[Azure Flame]

Shirley Manson from garbage. Ideas?

I definitely see Se/Ni somewhere in there.

 

[OrangeAppled]

I've always typed her as ENFP. She's usually typed 4w5, but I could see an argument for 4w3. I think she's pretty obviously a 4, which makes Se-dom unlikely (it's too connected to poor Sensing).

If you've ever read her old online diary or an interview than being xxFP is really obvious. She uses lots of metaphorical language when speaking also. More than any ESFP I've ever known. IDK, I just see NeFi for her.

I knew we weren't done. I'm surprised it took us this long to want to make a record again. For me, the spark came when I went to Coachella a couple of years ago. I felt like a lion in a cage. I wanted to chew through my bars.

That bolded part is really typical of her.

 

[Winds of Thor]

Hot

 

[Riva]

Their song 'i'm only happy when it rains' screams enneagram 4. However now that I googled it it seems the song is a parody of 1990s emo rock. It still screams e4 to me. I've dedicated that song to infjs. Since getting to know about enneagrams i've begin to realize it's the e4ness of infjs that I had in mind when I did so. Then again most infjs are e4s.

 

[Speed Gavroche]

ENFP 4w5 So/Sx.

 

[neko 4]

Definitely Four!
I think INFJ or INFP. Just because she can come across aggressive doesn't mean she's an E.