• You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to additional post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), view blogs, respond to polls, upload content, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free, so please join our community today! Just click here to register. You should turn your Ad Blocker off for this site or certain features may not work properly. If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us by clicking here.

brainwashed into thinking looking a certain way is the only way to make it through

cafe

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
9,827
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
9w1
I didn't think they were that expensive :) Clearly a lot less expensive than a car or whatever. Meaning, basically anybody who has a car too - which is basically anyone in the US right - can afford such clothes.

But alright call me a yuppie too if you want :D And no, I'm not one of them. You'd have a really hard time correctly categorizing me. :)

OK, my real point is, I'm not into making assumptions without actual experience with the specific person. Perhaps because I'm so atypical myself.

Guess our opinions on what "fairly accurate" means differ ;)
A quarter of my town are in poverty. The median family income is $31K/year. Half of the kids in the public schools in the county are on free/reduced lunch. The temps are very cold right now and a lot of the roads are covered in ice. Only the very hardcore fitness people or the very poor are riding bicycles right now. If you are trying to choose whether to pay your water bill or buy food for your kids, spandex is expensive.
 

valaki

New member
Joined
Jan 1, 2014
Messages
940
MBTI Type
SeNi
Enneagram
8+7
Instinctual Variant
sx/sp
A quarter of my town are in poverty. The median family income is $31K/year. Half of the kids in the public schools in the county are on free/reduced lunch. The temps are very cold right now and a lot of the roads are covered in ice. Only the very hardcore fitness people or the very poor are riding bicycles right now. If you are trying to choose whether to pay your water bill or buy food for your kids, spandex is expensive.

I thought only my country had people complaining about paying bills in this fashion. Even over there in the great USA, they do that?

And of course people in my country still seem to have the money for expensive cars, gadgets, whatnot. Just not for the bills, apparently.

My point is still this, you can't decide motivation by looking at clothing.

But at least you changed from "yuppie" to "very hardcore fitness people" :p
 

prplchknz

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
34,397
MBTI Type
yupp
I thought only my country had people complaining about paying bills in this fashion. Even over there in the great USA, they do that?

And of course people in my country still seem to have the money for expensive cars, gadgets, whatnot. Just not for the bills, apparently.

My point is still this, you can't decide motivation by looking at clothing.

But at least you changed from "yuppie" to "very hardcore fitness people" :p
omg the U.S is falling from grace, it has been since 2000, the U.S is fucked in the ass or will be in the next 50 years max.

and I agree you can't base judgements on clothing. I'm not poor I can survive on the money I have, but I wear hoodies and jeans and my shoes have holes in the soles. mostly because I don't have a car and going shoe shopping? fuck that. though my mom is coming down end of febuary and I need new pants and shoes and bras so she'll have a car and we can go shopping, even though I despise shopping.
 

cafe

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
9,827
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
9w1
I thought only my country had people complaining about paying bills in this fashion. Even over there in the great USA, they do that?

And of course people in my country still seem to have the money for expensive cars, gadgets, whatnot. Just not for the bills, apparently.

My point is still this, you can't decide motivation by looking at clothing.

But at least you changed from "yuppie" to "very hardcore fitness people" :p
Well, I honestly don't know many poor hardcore fitness people. Those people are usually closer to middle class and better. We have, for the first time in history, I think, a group of people in my country who has lost years of life expectancy: white women who are not high school graduates. They have lost five years of life expectancy. They are often stressed out, overworked, and have little access to healthcare. Working out is not even on the radar for them because their life is one crisis after another. Maybe the poor people you know and love are different from the ones I do.

You can't usually tell motivations, but you can tell a decent amount about someone's circumstances. Not 100% accuracy, but probably better than fifty percent. Some people don't fit well into their boxes, but a lot of us, really do, no matter how much we want to believe ourselves special snowflakes.

If you live in an area with poor public transportation, having a reliable motor vehicle can be a necessity. If you don't have internet access at your home, having a phone with that capacity is pretty important. The upfront cost of a prepaid smartphone can be a lot less than buying a computer and getting internet access in your home. In my area, if you don't have a car and a phone, you're going to have a very hard time finding anyone willing to employ you, even for a $8/hr job.
 

valaki

New member
Joined
Jan 1, 2014
Messages
940
MBTI Type
SeNi
Enneagram
8+7
Instinctual Variant
sx/sp
omg the U.S is falling from grace, it has been since 2000, the U.S is fucked in the ass or will be in the next 50 years max.

It's actually sad :/

and I agree you can't base judgements on clothing. I'm not poor I can survive on the money I have, but I wear hoodies and jeans and my shoes have holes in the soles. mostly because I don't have a car and going shoe shopping? fuck that. though my mom is coming down end of febuary and I need new pants and shoes and bras so she'll have a car and we can go shopping, even though I despise shopping.

Haha I wish you luck to survive the ordeal ;)


Well, I honestly don't know many poor hardcore fitness people. Those people are usually closer to middle class and better. We have, for the first time in history, I think, a group of people in my country who has lost years of life expectancy: white women who are not high school graduates. They have lost five years of life expectancy. They are often stressed out, overworked, and have little access to healthcare. Working out is not even on the radar for them because their life is one crisis after another. Maybe the poor people you know and love are different from the ones I do.

I didn't say that someone who works out regularly using a bicycle would be a very poor person, no, I just don't think it has to be in the "yuppie" category.


You can't usually tell motivations, but you can tell a decent amount about someone's circumstances. Not 100% accuracy, but probably better than fifty percent. Some people don't fit well into their boxes, but a lot of us, really do, no matter how much we want to believe ourselves special snowflakes.

That's fine I just don't view 51% accuracy as very fair :) I prefer to first learn about the actuality, not guessing. It's just how I go about this. But I originally responded to your post not because of that difference in thinking but because I hate pigeonholing.


If you live in an area with poor public transportation, having a reliable motor vehicle can be a necessity. If you don't have internet access at your home, having a phone with that capacity is pretty important. The upfront cost of a prepaid smartphone can be a lot less than buying a computer and getting internet access in your home. In my area, if you don't have a car and a phone, you're going to have a very hard time finding anyone willing to employ you, even for a $8/hr job.

Well here people who complain about the bills have access to public transportation but some of them do go by car because it's more comfortable... not a necessity. This one thing may be different in your area.

As for the computer and internet access, an older computer (basically can be had for free) & free wifi works for the people I know who are actually poor :/

And I would think a computer even if old, is a lot better for proper internet access than a smartphone with a little sucky display and a more limited browser.
 

cafe

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
9,827
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
9w1
I didn't say that someone who works out regularly using a bicycle would be a very poor person, no, I just don't think it has to be in the "yuppie" category.
I probably define yuppie more broadly than you do. Sheep don't look the same to other sheep, perhaps?

That's fine I just don't view 51% accuracy as very fair :) I prefer to first learn about the actuality, not guessing. It's just how I go about this. But I originally responded to your post not because of that difference in thinking but because I hate pigeonholing.
Yeah, a lot of people do, especially if they believe it is being applied to them. I make initial assumptions but I am generally open to specifics when presented with individuals. I'm pragmatic, though, and it's not like my assumptions about people matter most of the time anyway. I am classist, but it's not like I'm going to run over someone just because I think they are a yuppie.

Well here people who complain about the bills have access to public transportation but some of them do go by car because it's more comfortable... not a necessity. This one thing may be different in your area.
It can take a couple of hours to get anywhere in my town by bus. It's -16 degrees celsius here right now. That's unusually cold, but it's not crazy uncommon in the winter. It's $1.75 each way for anyone over five years old unless you buy a bus pass. A bus pass is $45/month/person. They don't run before 6AM, after 11PM or at all on Sunday. Gas is $3/gallon. You can get older used cars on payments. It's usually a rip-off, but they used to charge as low as a couple hundred dollars a month, back when we were poor.

As for the computer and internet access, an older computer & free wifi works for the people I know who are actually poor :/

And I would think a computer even if old, is a lot better for proper internet access than a smartphone with a little sucky display and a more limited browser.
But you can get a smart phone for under $100, including the first month's service and you can use it anywhere. It is also a multi-purpose device. Can be used for calling and texting as well. Even an old laptop from a pawn shop is going to cost more than that initially (I think) and you are going to have to drive someplace to get free wi-fi. We've only got one public library still open in town and everyplace else is going to expect you to buy something to use the wi-fi. Plus, what are your kids doing while you're using the wi-fi someplace public?
 

valaki

New member
Joined
Jan 1, 2014
Messages
940
MBTI Type
SeNi
Enneagram
8+7
Instinctual Variant
sx/sp
I probably define yuppie more broadly than you do. Sheep don't look the same to other sheep, perhaps?

I just go by the dictionary definition. My native language is not English though.


Yeah, a lot of people do, especially if they believe it is being applied to them. I make initial assumptions but I am generally open to specifics when presented with individuals. I'm pragmatic, though, and it's not like my assumptions about people matter most of the time anyway. I am classist, but it's not like I'm going to run over someone just because I think they are a yuppie.

Lol fair enough.


It can take a couple of hours to get anywhere in my town by bus. It's -16 degrees celsius here right now. That's unusually cold, but it's not crazy uncommon in the winter. It's $1.75 each way for anyone over five years old unless you buy a bus pass. A bus pass is $45/month/person. They don't run before 6AM, after 11PM or at all on Sunday. Gas is $3/gallon. You can get older used cars on payments. It's usually a rip-off, but they used to charge as low as a couple hundred dollars a month, back when we were poor.

Wow, that's cold. That kind of temperature happens maybe for 1-2 days for us in winter and only in the evening/at night/dawn. Your bus pass seems cheap. So is the gas price ;)

Why do poor people do monthly payments though... rhetorical question; yep it's a rip-off. More than a set of spandex clothing ;) ...Am not saying that someone who's really poor should instead buy sports clothes. See below for more.


But you can get a smart phone for under $100, including the first month's service and you can use it anywhere. It is also a multi-purpose device. Can be used for calling and texting as well. Even an old laptop from a pawn shop is going to cost more than that initially (I think) and you are going to have to drive someplace to get free wi-fi. We've only got one public library still open in town and everyplace else is going to expect you to buy something to use the wi-fi. Plus, what are your kids doing while you're using the wi-fi someplace public?

Sure you can use it anywhere but I thought we were talking about the poor for who comfort is a secondary concern. I know a guy who *IS* poor. He uses an old computer, didn't buy it from a pawn shop, that's a rip-off, they can be had virtually free if you look hard enough & he steals wifi off neighbours. He sometimes asks for a bit of a loan. It's all terrible yeah... Anyway my point here was just that I don't think a smartphone is more essential than spandex clothing ;) And I guess if someone doesn't have money for both, only one of these, they will have to prioritize. And then get put in the wrong category perhaps :p (Not necessarily by sports clothing, that's just an example.)
 

cafe

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
9,827
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
9w1
I just go by the dictionary definition. My native language is not English though.




Lol fair enough.




Wow, that's cold. That kind of temperature happens maybe for 1-2 days for us in winter and only in the evening/at night/dawn. Your bus pass seems cheap. So is the gas price ;)

Why do poor people do monthly payments though... rhetorical question; yep it's a rip-off. More than a set of spandex clothing ;) ...Am not saying that someone who's really poor should instead buy sports clothes. See below for more.




Sure you can use it anywhere but I thought we were talking about the poor for who comfort is a secondary concern. I know a guy who *IS* poor. He uses an old computer, didn't buy it from a pawn shop, that's a rip-off, they can be had virtually free if you look hard enough & he steals wifi off neighbours. He sometimes asks for a bit of a loan. It's all terrible yeah... Anyway my point here was just that I don't think a smartphone is more essential than spandex clothing ;) And I guess if someone doesn't have money for both, only one of these, they will have to prioritize. And then get put in the wrong category perhaps :p (Not necessarily by sports clothing, that's just an example.)
Who doesn't password protect their home wi-fi? :shock:
 

valaki

New member
Joined
Jan 1, 2014
Messages
940
MBTI Type
SeNi
Enneagram
8+7
Instinctual Variant
sx/sp
Who doesn't password protect their home wi-fi? :shock:

Some people don't do it here; I don't know how exactly he gets the internet, either unprotected or he cracked it.

No thoughts on my main point?
 

cafe

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
9,827
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
9w1
Some people don't do it here; I don't know how exactly he gets the internet, either unprotected or he cracked it.

No thoughts on my main point?
Nah. Not right now. I have a bunch of stuff to cook and we'd really have to get into a lot of details about access to stuff and how much stuff costs in respective places. I have been poor in my area and you have not, so even though it's anecdotal evidence on my part, your stuff isn't super-relevent for me. And really, my opinions and judgements don't matter to you in any material way. So I'm going to do my annoying domestic stuff and listen to John Green explain the New Deal on youtube.
 

valaki

New member
Joined
Jan 1, 2014
Messages
940
MBTI Type
SeNi
Enneagram
8+7
Instinctual Variant
sx/sp
Nah. Not right now. I have a bunch of stuff to cook and we'd really have to get into a lot of details about access to stuff and how much stuff costs in respective places. I have been poor in my area and you have not, so even though it's anecdotal evidence on my part, your stuff isn't super-relevent for me. And really, my opinions and judgements don't matter to you in any material way. So I'm going to do my annoying domestic stuff and listen to John Green explain the New Deal on youtube.

My main point was independent of the small details. It would still apply in your area.

Anyway sure, have fun doing whatever :p
 

cafe

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
9,827
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
9w1
My main point was independent of the small details. It would still apply in your area.

Anyway sure, have fun doing whatever :p
Until I can carry my kids in my spandex pants, I am going to have to stick with my minivan. :laugh:
 

valaki

New member
Joined
Jan 1, 2014
Messages
940
MBTI Type
SeNi
Enneagram
8+7
Instinctual Variant
sx/sp
Until I can carry my kids in my spandex pants, I am going to have to stick with my minivan. :laugh:

I wouldn't take kids for my workout.

See, it's not as simple, as this idea of a mother with kids...

Another way to put my main point is, not everyone lives by the standards.
 

prplchknz

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
34,397
MBTI Type
yupp
well the idea that we can't be naked all the time because of law reasons isn't good. or maybe it is, because if we were just naked all the time we would have to come up with some other arbituary system to judge people on the spot. so really there's no getting around snap judgements
 

Siúil a Rúin

when the colors fade
Joined
Apr 23, 2007
Messages
14,038
MBTI Type
ISFP
Enneagram
496
Instinctual Variant
sp/sx
life?

I mean obviously it's true now, but maybe it wasn't before like I wonder if we're conditioned to only judge based on appearances? and those appearances have to fall within a certain spectrum and if they don't you're screwed. I'm gonna just become a hermit and not talk to anyone.
I want to also be a hermit and not talk to anyone.

At least I had the Brooke Shields eyebrows during the 80's, but I didn't have the poofy hair or boobs so necessary to that time period. I really loathe the beauty ideals out there, and once had a crush on a really sweet, smart, creative guy who ended up being into bodysculpter women with boob jobs set at 40psi. Some of these images are reinforced for men through pornography and you could brainwash anything through repeated orgasm. I know I look good enough for my age, but I now notice the idolizing of youth and feel a bit meh about that.
 
W

WhoCares

Guest
I work with lots of people who've hit the genetic jackpot. They are beautiful by most standards out there. And while I can see what others see about that, it doesn't attract me personally at all. Especially when a great deal of these people are just gaping holes of neediness because they have extremely low levels of self esteem. For a very brief time in my life I managed to hit the ideal in terms of body shape and discovered just how frightening it is to place all your value in something as ephemeral as looks. I was never more neurotic nor more fearful of gaining another year to my birthdate. When looks is all you have you are in a situation you can't win. One day, they will be gone and there's little you can do about it.

In my job even the very young (early 20's) start identifying their self worth with their looks and go for surgery, botox and fillers. They look like freaks and develop a certain nastiness to their personality. They become envious and fearful or anyone that presents as well or better than them. Thats when the claws come out. It's very sad. Of course there are some physical beauties I work with who do not over identify with their looks and they are indeed something to behold. But they have the realistic notion that this advantage is fleeting at best and they need to develop other interests in life than spotting wrinkles in the mirror.

To be honest publicised images of beauty aren't a good indicator of attractiveness at all. There is someone for everyone out there. Sure some people are pursued by a larger group but that's a creepy situation in and of itself. From my short stint amoung the beautiful people (note, facial attractiveness is often overlooked if the body is right) I realised what a blessing it is to be a plain jane instead.
 
Joined
Jun 6, 2007
Messages
7,312
MBTI Type
INTJ
No thoughts on my main point?

Not to speak for Cafe, but I think she's trying to be polite in not telling you that your points don't really hold up for people who don't live like you. I can't imagine basic communication is less of a priority than the luxury of fashion unless you never have to think about not having either.
 

valaki

New member
Joined
Jan 1, 2014
Messages
940
MBTI Type
SeNi
Enneagram
8+7
Instinctual Variant
sx/sp
Not to speak for Cafe, but I think she's trying to be polite in not telling you that your points don't really hold up for people who don't live like you. I can't imagine basic communication is less of a priority than the luxury of fashion unless you never have to think about not having either.

You misunderstood..... I wasn't talking about fashion, at all. I was talking about doing sports, not fashion. And I'm not seeing your point about devaluing communication. I did not do that. Basic communication is done well by a cheap phone and browsing of the internet is still done better on a PC than on a smartphone, which is what I was also pointing out earlier.

Also what is this with bringing up the very poor again? It was somewhat irrelevant originally too; my point was about how you don't have to be a yuppie to be able to do sports in sport specific sports clothes instead of jeans or whatever. I was not talking about very poor people with that. I don't think that there would be only two categories, "yuppie" and "very poor".
 

prplchknz

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
34,397
MBTI Type
yupp
You misunderstood..... I wasn't talking about fashion, at all. I was talking about doing sports, not fashion. And I'm not seeing your point about devaluing communication. I did not do that. Basic communication is done well by a cheap phone and browsing of the internet is still done better on a PC than on a smartphone, which is what I was also pointing out earlier.

Also what is this with bringing up the very poor again? It was somewhat irrelevant originally too; my point was about how you don't have to be a yuppie to be able to do sports in sport specific sports clothes instead of jeans or whatever. I was not talking about very poor people with that. I don't think that there would be only two categories, "yuppie" and "very poor".
It started out as people wearing yoga pants, which cost money. I don't think it was clear at least not to me anyways, that you were talking about sports themselves but rather it seemed as though you were talking about what people typically wear when doing yoga. and [MENTION=4]cafe[/MENTION]'s argument was that people where she lived were too poor to worry about owning yoga pants. not about doing yoga it's self
[MENTION=4]cafe[/MENTION] is this true? correct me if I'm wrong.
 

cafe

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
9,827
MBTI Type
INFJ
Enneagram
9w1
Where I am, middle class people and up wear specialized clothes for sports. Riding a bicycle can be cheap, but the specialized clothes often are not: more than that they aren't necessary. Unnecessary expenses are for people with extra money. In the summer, you can wear a pair of shorts and a tee shirt you spent less than a dollar on from a thrift shop and be fine riding a bike. Cold weather sporting gear can be even more expensive.

Here, a lot of fast food places and restaurants require employees to wear black shoes (usually tennis shoes) and black pants (usually black jeans or chinos). Someone wearing black shoes and black pants riding a bicycle has a better than fifty percent chance of working at a fast food place or restaurant and is riding a bike because they can't afford a car, can't afford to fix their car, or their partner/family member with whom they share a car is unable to give them a ride/let them use the car. I've known one or two people to do it because they are afraid of getting fat, but they generally didn't turn down rides when they were offered, especially in bad weather. And they didn't have specialized clothes.

It's not 100% accurate and it depends how much you are into fitness. I have no idea how things are in other areas, but I've lived in this town for over thirty years. I've watched it decline and, though I'm not very social, my family has been here or in the neighboring counties for generations. I mean, back to one that came over on a boat, served in the Revolutionary war, then managed to settle in Indiana before dying.

So I know the area and I have a pretty good feel for the people. A lot of the people I know are poor and working class. I know some people that are better off, too. Like my cousin recently was trying to sell over seventy pairs of her daughter's sports shorts on facebook. They are cheap shorts, but they are specialized: they do not meet the dress code for our public schools and over 70 pairs. One kid. I would think it was a typo, but I used to clean her sister's house and that's really not out of line for them.

I know it hurts people's sensibilities to be categorized based on very surface things. I don't always like it myself, but even with me, it's generally pretty accurate. I dress and look maybe a little younger than I am, but no one is terribly shocked after seeing me to learn that I am a housewife and mother or that my husband is a truck driver. No one would be shocked to learn I'm from a conservative religious background. I drive a mini-van. I wear Danskos, jeans, Lands' End tops. You could guess a lot about me by the way I look.

My political ideas would probably come as a surprise unless you happened to catch me driving our second car: a compact car with a marriage equality bumper sticker. But usually the only thing people express surprise upon learning about me is my age and the ages of my kids. The fact that I still have all my visible teeth says a lot about my economic situation in this area, as does the fact that they are not perfectly straight or bright white.

Now my husband, my husband does not look like a college educated fiscal liberal. He does look like a truck driver and no one would be surprised he is from a conservative religious background to look at him unless he was just off work and had had to crawl around on the ground for some reason, which happens sometimes.

But anyway, my point is that most people do make judgements about us based on how we look and to some degree, those judgements are accurate. I'm sure there are some people who do not make those judgements, but I suspect that even when we think we don't we just aren't doing it consciously. I'm fairly conscious of it because I've been followed around stores like a thief based on how I looked, even though the last time I shop-lifted I was four years old. I've been told by a dentist that he didn't give a shit about me and that I was nothing when I complained about how he was treating my daughter because we were on Medicaid (obviously poor).

Learning that people are like that was not a pleasant revelation to me, but it was pretty undeniable. I've done what I could to mitigate the negative effects of that kind of thing since I figured it out. Being aware of it gives you a little control over it but no one can completely overcome it. If Oprah can't buy a pricey bag without being talked down to, I hardly think the rest of us are exempt.

But I am not going to argue it further. Life is too damn short and there are much funner things to do. And virtually anything else I chose to do with my time would be more useful.
 
Top