• You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to additional post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), view blogs, respond to polls, upload content, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free, so please join our community today! Just click here to register. You should turn your Ad Blocker off for this site or certain features may not work properly. If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us by clicking here.

Description of ENTJ or P?

Stanton Moore

morose bourgeoisie
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
3,900
MBTI Type
INFP
I found the follwing description of the ENTJ. Do you think it's more accurate for ENTP or ENTJ?

ENTJ people are doers. They set out to accomplish things and are determined to succeed one way or another. They must, however, learn the difference between being confidently aggressive--a responsible "take-charge person" on whom others rely to get things moving-- and being rudely aggressive-- a "know-it-all" who is insensitive to the feelings as well as the wisdom of others.
ENTJ individuals react in a physical way to everything they experience in life. That is, before they assess the practicality or worth of what they are doing, before they sort out their true emotions, and, before they take time to reason things out intellectually, their tendency is to shoot first and ask questions later. Their nature is inspiring and flattering to others, but unless impatience and rash behavior are curbed, their unbridled enthusiasm backfires when they lose interest just as quickly as they gained it. They quickly forget frustration and anger. Since theirs is essentially a generous nature, their selfishness is usually a result of carelessness rather than intentional unkindness.
ENTJ are high-spirited, energetic individuals. Courageous, optimistic, and friendly, they are lively participants in the everyday bustle of life, maintaining a frantic pace others find difficult to match. Constant physical activity works off excess energy, and its vitalizing influence is important to their intellectual and creative endeavors. It is usually the ENTJ who is willing to start projects others would be afraid to tackle. However, it is also the ENTJ who often fails to finish things when too many details demand attention or they simply lose interest. In spite of the physical energy associated with this type, they are not above using the inability of others to keep up with them as an excuse for their own idleness. If they expect others to provide them with constant stimulation and are unwilling to find their own diversions, they become lazy. Cut off from physical activity, they become depressed, unproductive, and overweight.
They are eager athletes and generous players. They enjoy the challenge of a tough contest, but they can be so stimulated that they become too aggressive. Combative by nature, they may enjoy boxing, wrestling, and most team sports. They are apt to be mechanically inclined and adept at arts and crafts, typing, working with machinery, playing musical instruments. They have a tendency to allow their enthusiasm to exceed their actual ability. Before taking something apart, they don't stop to wonder if they can put it back together.
 

rav3n

.
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
11,655
I found the follwing description of the ENTJ. Do you think it's more accurate for ENTP or ENTJ?

ENTJ people are doers. They set out to accomplish things and are determined to succeed one way or another. They must, however, learn the difference between being confidently aggressive--a responsible "take-charge person" on whom others rely to get things moving-- and being rudely aggressive-- a "know-it-all" who is insensitive to the feelings as well as the wisdom of others.
ENTJ individuals react in a physical way to everything they experience in life. That is, before they assess the practicality or worth of what they are doing, before they sort out their true emotions, and, before they take time to reason things out intellectually, their tendency is to shoot first and ask questions later. Their nature is inspiring and flattering to others, but unless impatience and rash behavior are curbed, their unbridled enthusiasm backfires when they lose interest just as quickly as they gained it. They quickly forget frustration and anger. Since theirs is essentially a generous nature, their selfishness is usually a result of carelessness rather than intentional unkindness.
ENTJ with some ENTP elements.
ENTJ are high-spirited, energetic individuals. Courageous, optimistic, and friendly, they are lively participants in the everyday bustle of life, maintaining a frantic pace others find difficult to match. Constant physical activity works off excess energy, and its vitalizing influence is important to their intellectual and creative endeavors. It is usually the ENTJ who is willing to start projects others would be afraid to tackle. However, it is also the ENTJ who often fails to finish things when too many details demand attention or they simply lose interest. In spite of the physical energy associated with this type, they are not above using the inability of others to keep up with them as an excuse for their own idleness. If they expect others to provide them with constant stimulation and are unwilling to find their own diversions, they become lazy. Cut off from physical activity, they become depressed, unproductive, and overweight.
They are eager athletes and generous players. They enjoy the challenge of a tough contest, but they can be so stimulated that they become too aggressive. Combative by nature, they may enjoy boxing, wrestling, and most team sports. They are apt to be mechanically inclined and adept at arts and crafts, typing, working with machinery, playing musical instruments. They have a tendency to allow their enthusiasm to exceed their actual ability. Before taking something apart, they don't stop to wonder if they can put it back together.
More ENTP although ENTJs have elements of this.
 

Stanton Moore

morose bourgeoisie
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
3,900
MBTI Type
INFP
I dunno. It could be decribing ESTP too.

Can anyone help me understand this?
 

FDG

pathwise dependent
Joined
Aug 13, 2007
Messages
5,903
MBTI Type
ENTJ
Enneagram
7w8
Some average ExTx
 

DiscoBiscuit

Meat Tornado
Joined
Apr 13, 2009
Messages
14,794
Enneagram
8w9
I bolded what applies to me (at this point in time).

ENTJ people are doers. They set out to accomplish things and are determined to succeed one way or another. They must, however, learn the difference between being confidently aggressive--a responsible "take-charge person" on whom others rely to get things moving-- and being rudely aggressive-- a "know-it-all" who is insensitive to the feelings as well as the wisdom of others.
ENTJ individuals react in a physical way to everything they experience in life. That is, before they assess the practicality or worth of what they are doing, before they sort out their true emotions, and, before they take time to reason things out intellectually, their tendency is to shoot first and ask questions later. Their nature is inspiring and flattering to others, but unless impatience and rash behavior are curbed, their unbridled enthusiasm backfires when they lose interest just as quickly as they gained it. They quickly forget frustration and anger. Since theirs is essentially a generous nature, their selfishness is usually a result of carelessness rather than intentional unkindness.
ENTJ are high-spirited, energetic individuals. Courageous, optimistic, and friendly, they are lively participants in the everyday bustle of life, maintaining a frantic pace others find difficult to match. Constant physical activity works off excess energy, and its vitalizing influence is important to their intellectual and creative endeavors. It is usually the ENTJ who is willing to start projects others would be afraid to tackle. However, it is also the ENTJ who often fails to finish things when too many details demand attention or they simply lose interest. In spite of the physical energy associated with this type, they are not above using the inability of others to keep up with them as an excuse for their own idleness. If they expect others to provide them with constant stimulation and are unwilling to find their own diversions, they become lazy. Cut off from physical activity, they become depressed, unproductive, and overweight.
They are eager athletes and generous players. They enjoy the challenge of a tough contest, but they can be so stimulated that they become too aggressive. Combative by nature, they may enjoy boxing, wrestling, and most team sports. They are apt to be mechanically inclined and adept at arts and crafts, typing, working with machinery, playing musical instruments. They have a tendency to allow their enthusiasm to exceed their actual ability. Before taking something apart, they don't stop to wonder if they can put it back together.
 

sculpting

New member
Joined
Jan 28, 2009
Messages
4,148
Hmm, the few ENTJs I have known are some of the most intense people ever. They dont seem as charming as this description seems-intensely friendly yes, but charming no. They also always finish what they start-in a driving intense, non stop way. The bull-in-a-china-shop description is an excellent one as very often they just mow over other people, totally unaware in the drive to complete things. Exceptional leaders though, and I would gladly work for one again.
 

rav3n

.
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
11,655
Hmm, the few ENTJs I have known are some of the most intense people ever. They dont seem as charming as this description seems-intensely friendly yes, but charming no. They also always finish what they start-in a driving intense, non stop way. The bull-in-a-china-shop description is an excellent one as very often they just mow over other people, totally unaware in the drive to complete things. Exceptional leaders though, and I would gladly work for one again.
I don't disagree that we're near unstoppable when it comes to something integral to accomplishing a task at work. It's true.

When it comes to personal, not sure if charm is the best way to describe it although I'm sure other ENTJs are capable of it, perhaps more approachability and as you've stated friendly.
 

rav3n

.
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
11,655
I did give a very brief response by partitioning out top and bottom. Were you looking for something more specific, as in what DiscoBiscuit has posted?

It would really help if you gave us the reason(s) why you're looking for this.
 

LunarMoon

New member
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
309
MBTI Type
ENTJ
Enneagram
3
Like DiscoBiscuit I've bolded all that applies to me.

I found the follwing description of the ENTJ. Do you think it's more accurate for ENTP or ENTJ?

ENTJ people are doers. They set out to accomplish things and are determined to succeed one way or another. They must, however, learn the difference between being confidently aggressive--a responsible "take-charge person" on whom others rely to get things moving-- and being rudely aggressive-- a "know-it-all" who is insensitive to the feelings as well as the wisdom of others.
ENTJ individuals react in a physical way to everything they experience in life. That is, before they assess the practicality or worth of what they are doing, before they sort out their true emotions, and, before they take time to reason things out intellectually, their tendency is to shoot first and ask questions later. Their nature is inspiring and flattering to others, but unless impatience and rash behavior are curbed, their unbridled enthusiasm backfires when they lose interest just as quickly as they gained it. They quickly forget frustration and anger. Since theirs is essentially a generous nature, their selfishness is usually a result of carelessness rather than intentional unkindness.
ENTJ are high-spirited, energetic individuals. Courageous, optimistic, and friendly, they are lively participants in the everyday bustle of life, maintaining a frantic pace others find difficult to match. Constant physical activity works off excess energy, and its vitalizing influence is important to their intellectual and creative endeavors. It is usually the ENTJ who is willing to start projects others would be afraid to tackle. However, it is also the ENTJ who often fails to finish things when too many details demand attention or they simply lose interest. In spite of the physical energy associated with this type, they are not above using the inability of others to keep up with them as an excuse for their own idleness. If they expect others to provide them with constant stimulation and are unwilling to find their own diversions, they become lazy. Cut off from physical activity, they become depressed, unproductive, and overweight.
They are eager athletes and generous players. They enjoy the challenge of a tough contest, but they can be so stimulated that they become too aggressive. Combative by nature, they may enjoy boxing, wrestling, and most team sports. They are apt to be mechanically inclined and adept at arts and crafts, typing, working with machinery, playing musical instruments. They have a tendency to allow their enthusiasm to exceed their actual ability. Before taking something apart, they don't stop to wonder if they can put it back together.
 

Stanton Moore

morose bourgeoisie
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
3,900
MBTI Type
INFP
I did give a very brief response by partitioning out top and bottom. Were you looking for something more specific, as in what DiscoBiscuit has posted?

It would really help if you gave us the reason(s) why you're looking for this.

Is your well-honed Spidey-sense tingling? Yes? All in good time...
 

Jaguar

Active member
Joined
May 5, 2007
Messages
20,647
I found the follwing description of the ENTJ. Do you think it's more accurate for ENTP or ENTJ?

ENTJ people are doers. They set out to accomplish things and are determined to succeed one way or another. They must, however, learn the difference between being confidently aggressive--a responsible "take-charge person" on whom others rely to get things moving-- and being rudely aggressive-- a "know-it-all" who is insensitive to the feelings as well as the wisdom of others.
ENTJ individuals react in a physical way to everything they experience in life. That is, before they assess the practicality or worth of what they are doing, before they sort out their true emotions, and, before they take time to reason things out intellectually, their tendency is to shoot first and ask questions later. Their nature is inspiring and flattering to others, but unless impatience and rash behavior are curbed, their unbridled enthusiasm backfires when they lose interest just as quickly as they gained it. They quickly forget frustration and anger. Since theirs is essentially a generous nature, their selfishness is usually a result of carelessness rather than intentional unkindness.
ENTJ are high-spirited, energetic individuals. Courageous, optimistic, and friendly, they are lively participants in the everyday bustle of life, maintaining a frantic pace others find difficult to match. Constant physical activity works off excess energy, and its vitalizing influence is important to their intellectual and creative endeavors. It is usually the ENTJ who is willing to start projects others would be afraid to tackle. However, it is also the ENTJ who often fails to finish things when too many details demand attention or they simply lose interest. In spite of the physical energy associated with this type, they are not above using the inability of others to keep up with them as an excuse for their own idleness. If they expect others to provide them with constant stimulation and are unwilling to find their own diversions, they become lazy. Cut off from physical activity, they become depressed, unproductive, and overweight.
They are eager athletes and generous players. They enjoy the challenge of a tough contest, but they can be so stimulated that they become too aggressive. Combative by nature, they may enjoy boxing, wrestling, and most team sports. They are apt to be mechanically inclined and adept at arts and crafts, typing, working with machinery, playing musical instruments. They have a tendency to allow their enthusiasm to exceed their actual ability. Before taking something apart, they don't stop to wonder if they can put it back together.


Same description, nearly verbatim, for people born with the Sun in Aries.
http://www.psychicfred.com/astrotext/aries.htm

Aries people are doers. They set out to accomplish things and are determined to succeed one way or another. They must, however, learn the difference between being confidently aggressive--a responsible "take-charge person" on whom others rely to get things moving-- and being rudely aggressive-- a "know-it-all" who is insensitive to the feelings as well as the wisdom of others.

Aries individuals react in a physical way to everything they experience in life. That is, before they assess the practicality or worth of what they are doing, before they sort out their true emotions, and, before they take time to reason things out intellectually, their tendency is to shoot first and ask questions later. Their passionate nature is inspiring and flattering to others, but unless impatience and rash behavior are curbed, their unbridled enthusiasm backfires when they lose interest just as quickly as they gained it. Theirs is the astrological sign of the soldier but in their haste, they forget the practicality of being adequately armed before rushing headlong into physical or verbal combat. They quickly forget frustration and anger. Since theirs is essentially a generous nature, their selfishness is usually a result of carelessness rather than intentional unkindness.

Aries people are high-spirited, energetic individuals ready to try anything at least once. Courageous, optimistic, and friendly, they are lively participants in the everyday bustle of life, maintaining a frantic pace others find difficult to match. Constant physical activity works off excess energy, and its vitalizing influence is important to their intellectual and creative endeavors. It is usually the Aries who is willing to start projects others would be afraid to tackle. However, it is also Aries who often fails to finish things when too many details demand attention or they simply lose interest. In spite of the physical energy associated with Aries, they are not above using the inability of others to keep up with them as an excuse for their own idleness. If they expect others to provide them with constant stimulation and are unwilling to find their own diversions, they become lazy. Cut off from physical activity, they become depressed, unproductive, and overweight.

They are eager athletes and generous players. They enjoy the challenge of a tough contest, but they can be so stimulated that they become too aggressive. Aries rules guns and weapons, so it isn't surprising that many Aries individuals enjoy hunting. Combative by nature, they also enjoy boxing, wrestling, and most team sports. They are apt to be mechanically inclined and adept at arts and crafts, typing, working with machinery, playing musical instruments, or performing magic tricks. They have a tendency to allow their enthusiasm to exceed their actual ability. Before taking something apart, they don't stop to wonder if they can put it back together.

I am not an Aries and your Astrology stunt was lame. Lol.
 

Stanton Moore

morose bourgeoisie
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
3,900
MBTI Type
INFP
Jaguar wins.
Yes, the above is a description of the Aries from an astrology site. I chose ENTJ because it seemed to fit with some of the curent threads.
It is interesting to note that all I had to do was find/replace the word Aries with ENTJ, and remove a few overtly astrological sentences to make it seem more-or-less accurate.
I'll take that as proof of the poverty of MBTI as a means of describing personality. It would seem that it has little more to offer in terms of actual insight than astrology. Mostly, it's an exercise in ego syntonic self-flattery.
 

LunarMoon

New member
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
309
MBTI Type
ENTJ
Enneagram
3
Jaguar wins.
Yes, the above is a description of the Aries from an astrology site. I chose ENTJ because it seemed to fit with some of the curent threads.
It is interesting to note that all I had to do was find/replace the word Aries with ENTJ, and remove a few overtly astrological sentences to make it seem more-or-less accurate.
I'll take that as proof of the poverty of MBTI as a means of describing personality. It would seem that it has little more to offer in terms of actual insight than astrology. Mostly, it's an exercise in ego syntonic self-flattery.
Astrology isn't incorrect because the descriptions that it provides don't resemble actual people. Astrology is incorrect because the idea that being born in a particular month can determine someone's personality is nuts.
 

ajblaise

Minister of Propagandhi
Joined
Aug 3, 2008
Messages
7,914
MBTI Type
INTP
Astrology is fun (but not to be taken seriously). Even Jung went a little mystic with elementals! :)

Yeah.. and Jung and I had a little talk about that.

Shortly after.. he wrote Psychology and Religion
 
Top