Mostly agree.
Let me attempt to narrow them down:
Japan: ISFJ
Italy: ENFP
Germany: ESTJ
France: ESFP
England: INTJ
China: ESFJ?
Russia: ISTP
America: ESTP
Canada: INFP
Austria: ISTJ
Hungary: ESFP
Poland: ENTP
Prussia: ENTJ
K. I agree mostly with this. I tried more on this typing than others because I was bored and had an unusual amount of energy that day so
A lot of these typings are based on the author's view of the work as well as how they act actually in the manga. I'm tempted to say Japan's INFP because he behaves that way but I have a feeling the author is ISFJ from reading and they are very similar to each other, I actually think he modeled the character after himself and experiences he'd had in America. But ISFJ seems to fit.
I see China typed as sensor often. Tbh I have no idea what type he is. I know he's no Ni dom, he doesn't seem like one. He's been typed by other as ESTJ on a blog I was looking at, which makes sense but I was trying to be original and argue against myself. For now, Si/Ne axis.
Germany's type makes sense too, but again. Original. I was like, this is too obvious. It makes too much sense. And then I was like, I'm probably wrong but you can disagree with me. I definitely think Te/Fi
France I disagree with because I compare him with Seychelles. Seychelles is like a little version of him, but more sensitive. And I mean more sensitive in some kind of intuitive sense, some people type her as ISFP I think (?) so I could see why. I was thinking of subtext and actions when I did this.
America I have no idea about. On the one hand, I'm tempted to agree with ENFP because that's how he wants people to see him and how he wants to see himself, as well as how others actually see him. I could see your argument for ESTP though because he does make some stupid mistakes, though not necessarily one an intuitive would make, I think.
I think you might be onto something with Canada. For him I couldn't decide. But I decide on INFJ by looking at other typings and their arguments, though I'm still torn.
As for Prussia, I think he's more Si than Ni because I can't imagine an intuitive keeping a diary about themselves. It would be just too much effort. He keeps the diaries so he can remind himself of things, which is Si. He wants to relive those memories over and over, and this is pleasant for him. It doesn't hurt. I mainly think this (also) because of Fritz and the little bird he's attached to. Again, side habits.
EuropeLover said:
Quite a long post! Well I haven't seen R+V characters typed that much. But how did you find that people typed, for example, Tsukune as ISFP? I thought he was typed as ISFJ more. And to me, he seemed more Si with little to no Se. So either ISFJ or INFP. Also, Yukari typed as INFJ? She's clearly an extrovert, no signs of Ni dominance. And Mizore? I thought people typed her as IxTP, haven't seen anyone else typed her as a feeler. But yeah, where did you find other people typing the R+V characters?
I combined results from two different forums, summarized the argument in one paragraph, and then decided on the type that each person is. I really can't say about Tsukune, trust me I was torn for him as well. I decided ISFP because he seemed actually pretty goal oriented. Keep in mind I hadn't seen what was past the second season, but I did see glimpses from the comic where he became a ghoul or whatnot, and he actually seemed to enjoy it quite a lot in a way I didn't expect an ISFJ to. But that doesn't mean I won't listen to your argument if you have it. Just provide textual evidence.
I say Yukari INFJ because INFJ are known to be extroverted if they use their thinking function (yes, not feeling). Thinking combined with Fe makes for a more extroverted mindset so I think Ni over Fe because she only seems to make herself talk when she needs to. INFJs tend to use their Fe as a sort of weapon, and I think (not just because she's a genius kid) that she found a way to manipulate her functions well and this is why you get the girl you do.
I see IXTP but also I think people just like to think any white-haired character is like Jack Frost. They all get mistyped (usually) as ISxP. But I don't think that's true. I do see why there are arguments for that though. I just think she's really sensitive inwardly, that's all. She tries to put up a front, but I think her character distracts from her actual tastes. Ti is the cold function, so people mistake it as that. Fi is could, but inwardly warm. It's like hitting a wet blanket, it's soft but when it's wet it ain't that appealing, I guess that's why people like Ti more I guess. IDK