Virtual ghost
Complex paradigm
- Joined
- Jun 6, 2008
- Messages
- 19,920
I am curious if anyone else noticed that the entire thing about MBTI and ennegram profiles does not fit the reality always since the profiles are americanized or at least westernized ?
For example: X will have a hard time being bossed around and as soon it is possible it will start its own business.
Now the prooblem is that this person could have lived in communist country. So the only way to the top is through the hierarchy of the party. What will force this type to act alot more like some other type.
Also you can live in a country where economy is not product/goal based. I know that this sounds impossible to some one that lives in USA like country but trust me it is possible. Many countries were viped from the map for a reson.
Also that some tipes basically always end in college but no where it says what happens when there is no one around offering student loans and the person lives somehwere in pretty rural area.
Another example is: they are often very spiritual and helpful.
But the question is what happens when being spiritual becomes illegal ? Will that person still be so helpful and friendly ... or it will run to the hills are nurture the spirituality there. Even at the cost of ...... extroversion for example.
I am wondering if anyone else noticed that because of unamerican environment types sometimes behave pretty differently from what they are supposed to ?
Also if the country is being restructured on the fundamental level would it also make sense that some people change some to their typological preferances ?
For example: X will have a hard time being bossed around and as soon it is possible it will start its own business.
Now the prooblem is that this person could have lived in communist country. So the only way to the top is through the hierarchy of the party. What will force this type to act alot more like some other type.
Also you can live in a country where economy is not product/goal based. I know that this sounds impossible to some one that lives in USA like country but trust me it is possible. Many countries were viped from the map for a reson.
Also that some tipes basically always end in college but no where it says what happens when there is no one around offering student loans and the person lives somehwere in pretty rural area.
Another example is: they are often very spiritual and helpful.
But the question is what happens when being spiritual becomes illegal ? Will that person still be so helpful and friendly ... or it will run to the hills are nurture the spirituality there. Even at the cost of ...... extroversion for example.
I am wondering if anyone else noticed that because of unamerican environment types sometimes behave pretty differently from what they are supposed to ?
Also if the country is being restructured on the fundamental level would it also make sense that some people change some to their typological preferances ?