Being in the ISTJ mindset, I would want to swap the I for an E.
ESTJ gets to order people around. It sounds fun!
As for the other possibilities:
INTJ: INTJs are very smart, but this just got edged out by the ISTP. INTJs are very successful too.
ISFJ: No thanks. It sounds very tough and hard to be an ISFJ male. No offense to any ISFJ reading this.
ISTP: This is very appealing, but not as appealing as ESTJ. I'll say this is my second preference given that they are so adaptive.