sleuthiness
jump
- Joined
- Jul 3, 2008
- Messages
- 1,858
- MBTI Type
- INFP
- Enneagram
- 54
- Instinctual Variant
- so/sp
Tori - ENFP
Ani - ENFJ
the imagination can be such a soothing place.
Tori - ENFP
Ani - ENFJ
ISFPprince
INTPfrank black (the pixies!) (unsure)
ISTPpj harvey
Prince is more of an ISFP
oops yeah. Btw, Prince is to ISFP as Einstein is to INTP.PJ Harvery ?
I've heard ISTP more than anything
Rivers Cuomo is INTJ. I could maybe see INFJ, but absolutely not P. The man's entire career was one big methodical master plan to write catchy songs and become a rock star, and he rules Weezer with something of an iron fist (check out the recent biography, Rivers' Edge.) He's far too calculated to be P. Early in his musical career, he was obsessed with wank-metal and mastering every technical aspect of the guitar. The compulsive need for technical competence is characteristically NT.
Isaac Brock is probably INTP; he's definitely not an F. Everything I hear about him says he's a complete dick with little to no regard for the feelings of others. He obsesses over logical inconsistencies in religion/God/the afterlife far more than over his own ethical perfection. Name a single Modest Mouse song that sounds F to you in any way! Most of them are bitterly sarcastic or satirical--not that Fs aren't capable of this (see Nirvana's "In Bloom" about how much the very INFP Cobain hated rednecks.) But still, just listening to interviews and so on with Brock, his personal style comes off as very blunt, intentionally controversial NTP.
Billy Corgan is ENTJ, though (2nd guess possibly INTJ.) F and P for him are both ridiculous. Talk to anyone who's been on tour or in the studio with him.
Mostly good, from what I've heard about the various people on the list.
Rivers Cuomo is INTJ. I could maybe see INFJ, but absolutely not P. The man's entire career was one big methodical master plan to write catchy songs and become a rock star, and he rules Weezer with something of an iron fist (check out the recent biography, Rivers' Edge.) He's far too calculated to be P. Early in his musical career, he was obsessed with wank-metal and mastering every technical aspect of the guitar. The compulsive need for technical competence is characteristically NT.
Isaac Brock is probably INTP; he's definitely not an F. Everything I hear about him says he's a complete dick with little to no regard for the feelings of others. He obsesses over logical inconsistencies in religion/God/the afterlife far more than over his own ethical perfection. Name a single Modest Mouse song that sounds F to you in any way! Most of them are bitterly sarcastic or satirical--not that Fs aren't capable of this. But still, just listening to interviews and so on with Brock, his personal style comes off as very blunt, intentionally controversial NTP.
SP songs seem to be mainly about identity, feelings, and sentimentality. How does that point to T vs. F? P/J I'm not sure of however, but it seems like a P would be more likely to spend 36 hours straight mixing a song than a J. (A J would be more likely to know what they're looking for in a mix and get it done rather than messing around with it for hours on end.)
myspace.com/averydenamusic
Its me!
Wow! You're really talented, and you have style and creativity and I think it crazy that no one has signed you onto some record deal! Keep it up!
Yep, she sounds good, but the problem with record deals is that they're business propositions designed to make money, not benevolent attempts to bring exposure to good music.
There are tons and tons of great artists out there who will never get recording contracts with major labels because their music simply isn't marketable in the current musical landscape. It's a shame, but if you want a big company to invest in mass-producing your product, it needs to be something that the vulgar, stupid masses will buy en masse. Sad, but that's the way of the business.
Yep, she sounds good, but the problem with record deals is that they're business propositions designed to make money, not benevolent attempts to bring exposure to good music.
There are tons and tons of great artists out there who will never get recording contracts with major labels because their music simply isn't marketable in the current musical landscape. It's a shame, but if you want a big company to invest in mass-producing your product, it needs to be something that the vulgar, stupid masses will buy en masse. Sad, but that's the way of the business.
About Corgan, now that you mention it, F makes a little more sense. Reading his recent blogs and such he's gone totally nutso-Fe...maybe he's an ENFJ that took a really really long time to grow up? He would need some serious charisma to convince club owners to book his band early in their career, being that his live vocals were so bad and all. I still can't really see P for him, though, because it takes a serious control freak to overdub virtually every guitar and bass part on the records, virtually eliminating Iha and D'arcy from the band's recorded output (except in rare cases.) Rivers Cuomo did this exact same thing to Jason Cropper/Brian Bell during the "Blue Album" sessions--according to Ric Ocasek, who produced it, 100% of the guitars on that record are Cuomo.
Beck always seems Ni to me.
Hendrix seems INFP... sometimes I think ISFP but the more I listen to interviews and stuff the more he definitely seems to be N.