I empathise with the OP.

I do the same thing and I end up screwing up the delivery of the joke most of the time. *facepalm* Fun though.

Quote Originally Posted by Fluffywolf View Post
It's like nocap says, some humor is best with a straight face. :P
My best pal could absolutely nail the deadpan look.

It gave me great satisfaction to watch mutual pals get taken in by it again and again (one would think they'd learn at some point). They'd wear these quizzical looks as they attempted to absorb the implications of what he'd just said and it would be ALL I could do to keep a straight face.

Ni-Se humour FTW! (not to say that deadpen delivery is specifically Ni-Se)