This thread was a reaction to the hottest chick thread. But males don't need to live up to anything, even in jest, that females don't need to live up to.
Look at who "won" - it's someone who had nothing to do with the female thread. People talking about hypocrisy should take a second and think about that. It was obviously on purpose.
I think it's funny, turning the tables, but there are a lot of men who still might have gotten hurt with this thread. There are many attractive guys that weren't mentioned or many totally awesome guys that weren't mentioned who outshine the supposed hot ones. Even the innocent "hot" one had people saying negative things about him.
Just because some men posted in the female thread complaining about us disapproving of the thread because we didn't want women to get hurt doesn't mean that there should be comeuppance that could hurt other guys. You don't fix problems by causing more problems, you fix problems by getting rid of the problem, or at least trying to address it, and making people think.