Trent Reznor

[particularsolution]

Originally Posted by CaptainChick

Oh man, I'll try.

i still haven't seen any valid points to counter my original argument (other than your invocation of "i know trent better" and "i'm an ENFP and am naturally tuned in to people's emotions"). just try this: give me a preference by preference explanation of trent's type. for each one give a reason.

[Evan]

How did you "pwn" him with your reasoning? By quoting a type profile? Hmm....

[SillySapienne]

Creative geniuses have often been documented as being sufferers of some or multiple chronic mental/psychological "pathologies".

Sanity doesn't preclude creative genius, per se, but if one's sanity is defined as that of their being and exhibited normal, i.e. average human behaviors/characteristics, then I would confidently say that, yes, to a certain degree, creative people are crazy.

[particularsolution]

Originally Posted by CaptainChick

Creative geniuses have often been documented as being sufferers of some or multiple chronic mental/psychological "pathologies".

Sanity doesn't preclude creative genius, per se, but if one's sanity is defined as that of their being and exhibited normal, i.e. average human behaviors/characteristics, then I would confidently say that, yes, to a certain degree, creative people are crazy.

and the line of reasoning is...?

[SillySapienne]

Originally Posted by particularsolution

i still haven't seen any valid points to counter my original argument (other than your invocation of "i know trent better" and "i'm an ENFP and am naturally tuned in to people's emotions"). just try this: give me a preference by preference explanation of trent's type. for each one give a reason.

I have provided lyrics and my analyses of those lyrics supporting why I view Trent to be an _NFP, though I can accept the possibility of his being an INTJ.

What I am sure about is that he is an N and a hardcore Fi user.

Originally Posted by dissonance

How did you "pwn" him with your reasoning? By quoting a type profile? Hmm....

No, I pwned him with my NeFi ninja skills.

[SillySapienne]

Originally Posted by particularsolution

and the line of reasoning is...?

Lol, do some research kid.

My Ne led me to intuit the hypothesis that creative geniuses must be a bit "crazy" and the research I have done provided me with the reasoning behind/for it.

When I feel so inclined I will provide you with a deluge of links supporting or backing my fanciful thoughts of/on creative folks, k?

[particularsolution]

Originally Posted by CaptainChick

I have provided lyrics and my analyses of those lyrics supporting why I view Trent to be an _NFP, though I can accept the possibility of his being an INTJ.

What I am sure about is that he is an N and a hardcore Fi user.


No, I pwned him with my NeFi ninja skills.

ah! INTJ. that's what i was campaigning for. it seems to be the best fit given the character traits he shows. after all this we agree (sort of).

[Evan]

Originally Posted by CaptainChick

Lol, do some research kid.

My Ne led me to intuit the hypothesis that creative geniuses must be a bit "crazy" and the research I have done provided me with the reasoning behind/for it.

When I feel so inclined I will provide you with a deluge of links supporting or backing my fanciful thoughts of/on creative folks, k?

Blah, tune down the ego a bit. Why should anyone believe you before you post reasoning?

[particularsolution]

Originally Posted by CaptainChick

Lol, do some research kid.

My Ne led me to intuit the hypothesis that creative geniuses must be a bit "crazy" and the research I have done provided me with the reasoning behind/for it.

When I feel so inclined I will provide you with a deluge of links supporting or backing my fanciful thoughts of/on creative folks, k?

is THIS what you are trying to say?

trent reznor had mental health issues
creative geniuses have mental health issues
NPs are creative geniuses
therefore trent reznor is an NP

?

[SillySapienne]

Oy vey, NO!!!

Stanford Researchers Establish Link Between Creative Genius And Mental Illness

have fun reading that while I find some more proof to put in my pudding.