Inspector Morse.

[Xander]

I'm not sure how many of the members here will even have heard of Morse but it's a Colin Dexter character.

The character has been the subject of a case study before, I'll keep the results to myself for the meanwhile, and I thought it makes for an interesting topic.

So, if you know of the characters (and I'm thinking more the TV interpretation done by John Thaw than the novels themselves) I'm thinking of the following..

What type is Morse?
What type is Lewis?
From these what type is Colin Dexter?


As an interesting aside, I'm wondering what type John Thaw is as he's described as somewhat like Morse but shy. Whilst whatching a documentary on the TV series I did think of several types but I was unsatisfied with such crude stabbing in the dark. Ergo I thought it'd get a whole lot more refined by including more blades

[LadyJaye]

FREAKY! I was just thinking about what Inspector Morse's type was this morning! Get out of my head! Do you watch Inspector Lewis as well? ( That Lawrence Fox is a hotty. )

I would say Morse is an ISTP, Lewis is an ISFJ, and Hathaway is an INTJ.

Do you think that sounds about right?

[AllAboutSoul]

I've always seen Morse as pretty intuitive. Lewis? Not so much. I loved the Morse series, I miss John Thaw.

[Xander]

Originally Posted by LadyJaye

FREAKY! I was just thinking about what Inspector Morse's type was this morning! Get out of my head!

But.. but.. it's soo murky and mysterious in here..lots of squidgey stuff to poke and such..

Originally Posted by LadyJaye

Do you watch Inspector Lewis as well? ( That Lawrence Fox is a hotty. )

I haven't as yet. The attraction with Morse started as my father used to watch it and so I picked up an interest in the staring pair and it's that interplay of characters that got me hooked.

I guess I should try Lewis really... it's about the only detective style thing I haven't seen yet.

Originally Posted by LadyJaye

I would say Morse is an ISTP, Lewis is an ISFJ, and Hathaway is an INTJ.

I don't know about Hathaway but I'd have placed Lewis as more of an extrovert myself.

Your estimation of Morse's type surprises me somewhat.. May I ask what in particular lead you to that conclusion?

Originally Posted by LadyJaye

Do you think that sounds about right?

I think it sounds like good thinking.. or intuition... right is something I'd probably argue over

If you mean are your results the same as the case study then in Morse's case definitely not... which is why I'm interested (I'm not sure they got it right either to be honest). In any case thinking about it's more interesting than getting it "right"

Originally Posted by AllAboutSoul

I've always seen Morse as pretty intuitive. Lewis? Not so much. I loved the Morse series, I miss John Thaw.

I'd concurr that I think Morse is intuitive but I'm being wary that such may be myself fitting the character to a pattern rather than observing one. If Morse is played as having high intelligence then the writer will include links not obvious to the audience to illustrate his intellect.. I'm concerned that can lead to people seeing intuition when in fact it's leaps put in to represent high intelligence.

Having said all that to me the most telling parts of the character is Morse's distain for Lewis' "basic" thinking and also how Morse has a tendency to grasp the first idea he has and persues it until Lewis says something, sometimes a random thought and other times actual constructed thinking, which shows Morse where he's going wrong.

I realise that similar was evident in the Holmes stories but somehow that always seemed to be executed with less finesse. Crass somehow. Where Morse actually uses what Lewis has said to come to his next bright idea Holmes seems more prone to just leap off at another tangent almost without regard to what Watson actually said.

[AllAboutSoul]

We must watch the same TV. Holmes? Jeremy Brett's Holmes? Weird, somehow you're in my head, it's the only Holmes I ever liked. He was great. Damn, I miss him too.

[Xander]

Originally Posted by AllAboutSoul

We must watch the same TV. Holmes? Jeremy Brett's (sp) Holmes? Weird, somehow you're in my head, it's the only Holmes I ever liked. He was great. Damn, I miss him too.

I'm sorry... there's another Sherlock Holmes?





Reruns rock..

[mippus]

I always saw Morse as the antisocial, snobbish, chaotic INTP. (great for identification)
And I know it is the obvious interpretation to see Lewis as ESFJ then, but I still buy it

As for the late John Thaw, he is an actor, I have no idea...

[PinkPiranha]

It's true. Jeremy Brett was the best Holmes.