What Type is Yoda?

[Mal12345]

You persist to stay on your stupid point. Nothing in this line is especially INFJ related. Prove me wrong.

 

[Speed Gavroche]

Ok. As we can all see you have not any argument. You loose.

 

[Mal12345]

Ok. As we can all see you have not any argument. You loose.

Skylights demolished you long ago in this thread.

 

[Mal12345]

Yoda is soooo INFP.


Ne:

�Life creates it, makes it grow. Its energy surrounds us and binds us. Luminous beings are we, not this crude matter. You must feel the Force around you; here, between you, me, the tree, the rock, everywhere, yes. Even between the land and the ship.�


He seems pretty constantly focused on explaining the interconnectedness of everything (Ne), and he spends a lot more time talking about personal feelings and emotions (his as well as others') than does the obviously INFJ Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan's insistence that his lie about Vader "murdering Luke's father" was true "from a certain point of view" is classic Ni--but Yoda doesn't mince words or sidestep problems this way. His ethical view is private, personal and deeply ingrained--seems like Fi to me. He's always directly informing Luke of the dangers associated with losing touch with his own emotions; that's so Fi!

I think Fi+Ne is pretty clear. Where are you guys getting Ni or Fe?





Luke is pretty clearly ISFP.

.

 

[RaptorWizard]

http://similarminds.com/forums/view...tart=120&sid=a98aefb88d5e4ffb4992891106422b7d

If the picture doesn't post just click the above link and you will see a Yoda INTP motivational poster.

 

[Mal12345]

http://similarminds.com/forums/view...tart=120&sid=a98aefb88d5e4ffb4992891106422b7d

If the picture doesn't post just click the above link and you will see a Yoda INTP motivational poster.

Those kinds won't link directly.

 

[RaptorWizard]

Those kinds won't link directly.

On that link when you scroll down the 5th picture is Yoda INTP.

 

[Mal12345]

I think you guys are right that Yoda was an INFx...thanks for peeing all over my ENFJ parade.

.

 

[Mal12345]

http://similarminds.com/forums/view...tart=120&sid=a98aefb88d5e4ffb4992891106422b7d

If the picture doesn't post just click the above link and you will see a Yoda INTP motivational poster.

Often times in those mbti motivational posters they will show the same person as different types in different posters.

 

[Speed Gavroche]

Skylights demolished you long ago in this thread.

Her post can be summarized as "thinkers can be emotionals too".Which actually make my point since the few emotional side of Yoda are coherent with his INTPness.

 

[Speed Gavroche]

.

Yoda is INTP, he is indeed looking at interconnections, so an Ne user, not an Ni user. But he doesn't judge thing in a value oriented subjective way. For Yoda must feelthings as they are withoud judging it, not make value judgment about this. So he is a T, not a F.

Luke is INFP, not ISFP, he focused on the future, not the present moment.

 

[RaptorWizard]

I am highlighting all the famous figures with parallels to Yoda:

Abraham Lincoln ENTP/INTP 150
Adam Smith INTP
Adolf Hitler INFJ/INTJ 141
Albert Einstein INTP 205
Alexander Graham Bell
Alexander the Great ENTJ 180
Aristotle INTP 190
Augustus Caesar INTJ
Benjamin Franklin ENTP 185
Bill Gates INTJ/INTP 173
Buddha INFJ/INFP
Charlemagne
Charles Darwin INTJ 173
Constantine
Francis Bacon INTJ 180
Galileo Galilei INTP 180
Gandhi INFJ/INFP 160
George Washington ISTJ 140
Isaac Newton INTJ 195
Jesus INFJ
John F. Kennedy INTJ 119
John Locke INTP 165
Joseph Stalin ESTJ/ISTJ
Julius Caesar ENTJ 175
Karl Marx INTP
Leonardo da Vinci INTP 220
Ludwig van Beethoven INTJ/INFJ 165
Martin Luther INTJ/INTP 170
Martin Luther King Jr. ENFJ
Max Planck
Michelangelo INFP 175
Muhammad ENTJ
Napoleon Bonaparte ENTJ 145
Nicolaus Copernicus
Niels Bohr
Nikola Tesla ENTP/INTP 200
Pablo Picasso ISFP 160
Plato INTP 180
Rene Descartes INTP 175
Sigmund Freud INFJ/INTJ 156
Thomas Edison ENTP 180
Thomas Jefferson INTJ 195
Walt Disney ENTP 123
Warren Buffett INTP
William Shakespeare INFP 210
Zoroaster
That's what this website thinks
http://www.slayerment.com/blog/ns-are-smarter-ss-mbti

 

[Mal12345]

Her post can be summarized as "thinkers can be emotionals too".Which actually make my point since the few emotional side of Yoda are coherent with his INTPness.

Only because that's how YOU want to summarize it.

 

[Speed Gavroche]

Only because that's how YOU want to summarize it.

Summarize it in another way if you can.

 

[Mal12345]

Yoda is INTP, he is indeed looking at interconnections, so an Ne user, not an Ni user. But he doesn't judge thing in a value oriented subjective way. For Yoda must feelthings as they are withoud judging it, not make value judgment about this. So he is a T, not a F.

Luke is INFP, not ISFP, he focused on the future, not the present moment.

Luke is another topic. He is focused on the present. At the beginning of Star Wars he whined that he wanted to go play instead of doing his chores (Se). His attacks on everything were direct: he directed the attack on the Imperial walkers - straight into their guns; the attack on Jabba's fortress was straightforward - just waltz right on into the hornet's nest. In the end, the Emperor goaded Luke into using his light-saber by pointing to his friends being decimated - something he could see right out the window.

 

[Mal12345]

It really is pretty obvious, like I said earlier: Ti's argue with logic, Ni's argue with ideas. Yoda's heart is filled to the brim with ethical knowledge and insightful NF poetry and philosophy. He barely riddles in logic, only once or twice to elegantly ornament one of his revelations. Nor does he deal in more 'dry-theory' like NTs.

Agreed. You have a far better idea of all this than SG.

 

[Speed Gavroche]

Luke is another topic. He is focused on the present.

No, Yoda critics him because he is too much focused to the future and not enough on the present moment. Watch the movie.

At the beginning of Star Wars he whined that he wanted to go play instead of doing his chores (Se).

He is an NP, so he daydreams about being somewhere else and dislike limiting concrete tasks. Normal. Beru Lars and Chewbacca are real SFPs, see the difference.

His attacks on everything were direct: he directed the attack on the Imperial walkers

He is so aware of his surroundig that the tusken warrior attacked him while he was using his binoculars... Actually the Lukes's lack of awareness of his direct sensory environment is obvious.

the attack on Jabba's fortress was straightforward

Hem, no. He spent a long time doing vain diplomacy before he truly take action. Typically INFP.

the Emperor goaded Luke into using his light-saber by pointing to his friends being decimated - something he could see out the window.

You're basically saying that Luke have a pair of eyes, so he is a sensor. Brillant.

 

[Speed Gavroche]

Agreed. You have a far better idea of all this than SG.

I have ever demonstrated that his idea was wrong.

 

[Mal12345]

No, Yoda critics him because he is too much focused to the future and not enough on the present moment. Watch the movie.

I don't have to go digging up information trying to verify or knock down your arbitrary statements. There are Yoda quotes all over the internet. Find one.

He is an NP, so he daydreams about being somewhere else and dislike limiting concrete tasks. Normal. Beru Lars and Chewbacca are real SFPs, see the difference.

Daydreaming about being somewhere else is what Se-dom does when it is stuck on a desert planet doing chores for aunt and uncle.

He is so aware of his surroundig that the tusken warrior attacked him while he was using his binoculars... Actually the Lukes's lack of awareness of his direct sensory environment is obvious.

That means nothing.

Hem, no. He spent a long time doing vain diplomacy before he truly take action. Typically INFP.

What are you talking about now?

You're basically saying that Luke have a pair of eyes, so he is a sensor. Brillant.

I've noticed something over the threads. Whenever you start a sentence with the word "basically," you're wrong.

 

[Speed Gavroche]

I don't have to go digging up information trying to verify or knock down your arbitrary statements. There are Yoda quotes all over the internet. Find one.

No, you prefer to stick on one line which doesn't prove anything. Anyway, the entire movie is online, watch it.

Daydreaming about being somewhere else is what Se-dom does when it is stuck on a desert planet doing chores for aunt and uncle.

No, they are focused on what they do, not on the future.

That means nothing.

Of course. It proves your wrong, so it means nothing. It's obvious.

What are you talking about now?

Spending a long time doing diplomacy and negotiating with Jabba. Luke is more focused on diplomacy than on tactic. He is an NF, not an SP.

I've noticed something over the threads. Whenever you start a sentence with the word "basically," you're wrong.

Prove it.